Patchwork enforcement on the naming policy

Pepe has done an informal but (as he says) "real FREAKIN interesting" little study of supposedly inappropriate names via the Armory. Blizzard's naming policy, as you'll know if you've ever run afoul of it, is pretty stringent-- you're not allowed to create obscene names at all (obviously), names based on real-life or well-known sources (so no trademarks or references to celebrities or Blizzard employees-- Legolas is completely out), harassing words or phrases, or "partial or complete sentences."

Now, you can't really argue with most of that. The obscene stuff is a given, of course, though where Blizzard gets their criteria for obscene is anyone's guess-- one of my guildies had an undead warrior named "Skinflayer" that Blizz forced him to rename (he renamed it to Tenderheart, actually). And the copyright and famous names seems a little silly, but it's most likely just Blizzard covering their backside-- you never know what copyright holders will do when it comes to user-created content. But harassing phrases? No l33tsp33k? How can Blizzard possibly track this stuff?

The fact is, as Pepe points out very effectively, that they can't (except on Blizzard employees, strangely enough). Reported names, of course, will probably get a message that they must be changed, but there's no way that Blizzard actually examines the rolls name by name to figure out which are compliant with the ToS and which aren't. The problem, then, becomes who gets punished and who doesn't, and what whims that comes by. While I'm with Blizzard on the player bans, I'm not with them on this one-- either they need to stick to their naming policy or change it. As Pepe shows, just a few minutes of Armory browsing yields hundreds of "violations." I've included all of Pepe's links after the break-- be warned that some of the names are in fact obscene according to Blizzard's policy, and thus might be offensive to some of our readers.

These are the categories under which names are inappropriate:


172 characters named Chinese*
55 characters named Azn

Extreme Sexuality/Violence

40 characters named Labia
45 characters named Tigolebitties
41 characters named Nambla

Sexual Orientation

89 Fruitcakes
62 Fairys


54 Sineps
95 Anigavs

Harassing or Defamatory

97 Yousucks

Blizzard Employees

Blizz seems to do a STELLAR job w/ this one. Couldn't find one Mikemorhaime, Robpardo or Chrismetzen! Thanks for protecting us from those, Blizz!


81 Scopes
29 Microsoft*s
341 Googles

Pure Gibberish

127 Asdfghs
433 Qwertys

Leet or Dudespeak

39 Lollerskates
173 Roflcopters


659 Knight*s

Real World References

79 Parishilton*s
43 Tyrabanks
53 Keanureeves

Partial or Complete Sentences

135 Johnthe*s
178 Mikethe*s
42 Mikeis*s

This article was originally published on WoW Insider.