Prepare to be amazed at what passes for investigative journalism on television these days. Atlanta's WSB-TV Action News team ran a sensational iPod "nana" piece last night under the title "Man's Pants Catch Fire At Airport." To set the stage, WSB-TV says that the nano "uses the same technology as those troubled laptop batteries under recall due to the risk of fire." In steps Danny Williams -- mild mannered consumer, airport employee -- who claims that his iPod nano "burst into" chest-high flames while he was at work. So why isn't he covered in burns after exposure to such a serious chemical fire? We've all watched the horrifying video of a lithium ion battery explosion, right? Well, Danny claims that he was protected by a "glossy piece of paper" in his pocket at the time. Taking it up a notch, WSB-TV worries that Danny could have been mistaken for a terrorist due to his smoking airport trousers. Look, we're not saying that nothing happened, after all, we've written about an exploding iPod nano before. We're only saying that it didn't happen in the way described. Check the video of the hot-coffee-in-lap style legal preparation after the break.
Nana is not a surprise from Monica. She misspeaks about 5 times a newscast. Its as much a part of channel 5 news here in Atlanta as Coke is a a part of the cities history.
As for the ipod, despite this being the second melted nano publicly photographed, has anyone proven it was due to a lithium discharge? Sounds like Fox5 may be in in for a little smackdown. And one other problem remains, there has been no forensic analysis of the ipod. Was it bent before it melted applying pressure to it, was he sweating, did he spill coffee on his lap?
Sorry one melted pile of electronics and a scorched piece of paper with no other corroborating evidence doesn't make a news story. I'm sure there were no witnesses at all as he was only in the busiest airport in the country (depending on who you talk to).
I assume the “hot-coffee-in-lap style legal preparation” is a reference to the infamous McDonald’s coffee case (Liebeck vs. McDonald’s). Although this case has become the poster child for so-called “frivolous lawsuits” most people don’t seem to know the facts of that case.
Oh and one thing the author forgot to mention in his speech: the day after the jury verdict, McDonald’s lowered the temperature of its coffee. So if you ever happen to spill McDonald’s coffee on yourself, you won’t end up in the hospital having skin grafts (and you can thank Stella Liebeck of that!)
i wouldn't scoff at it completely-- those batteries store a lot of power, and they can explode, especially while charging. maybe he had dropped it a lot, or something like that. i've read elsewhere that it's not really safe to let any device (cellphone, whatever) charge unattended, and especially not overnight while you're asleep (and prone to be burned alive). of course that doesn't mean all 1st gen nanos will set your pants on fire.
I love how the mom so astutely claims that it isn't about facts, it is about a bunch of what-ifs and the possibility of making money based on those what-ifs. Give the guy a new ipod and send him back to work. Maybe someday he'll be smart enough to tell the difference between flames and bit of smoke and his crazy mom won't dream up possible disasters when their wasn't one.
Seems kind of fishy to me that his USB connector was also burned. I'm sure it can't be good for it, being plugged in all day while being smashed around in a 300lb guy's sweaty pocket.
Wow - how big must his pockets be that the miraculous glossy paper didn't even have to be folded? (Or maybe it was, but the picture quality is crap and I can't tell.)
Otherwise, am I the only one who thinks that "chest high flames" may have caused a bit more damage to said miraculous savior than a small little burn mark? His pants seem to be in excellent condition, as well, after surviving such a dangerous environment.
Watch the video again, in the final 17 seconds there is a profile shot of the Nano. I find it odd how the case is bent up as if something crushed the Nano. I bet what ever it was caused the battery to short out. Thank God he had a glossy piece of paper in his pocket to protect him.
I worked at a local news channel for 4 years. They are a complete joke & the last place I'd go for news, weather, etc. Local media in general usually sucks balls.
Being a resident of Atlanta, its wiser to think "scam" first. More then likely this person is looking for a financial angle. Also I find it hard to believe that the little ipod battery would have enough energy to create ignition much less the flames this person describes. Its possible but doubtful.
As for the news, well WSB is known for aiming for the sensational over the factual. They might give facts, but cherry pick them so don't get the full context of the situation to come to your own conclusions.
Actually I think that describes all of news nowadays. It may be why people use blogs to get information. At least easy to tell the facts from the opinion.
I have a friend that this happened to... well kinda... He had been using a generic wall charger (that he won as a prize) the IP stopped working. While his dad was doing the reset procedure on it black acrid smoke shot from the headphone jack and the touch wheel melted a lot like this one. There were no flames to be seen... just the smoke. It was on a table at the time and didn't have a protective glossy piece of paper to shield... they chalked it up to the charger...
Probably this happened. Guy played around with cigarettelighter in pocket where he has the ipod. Scared to shit for his mum, makes up exploding nano story. Mother contacts Apple for milliondollar settlement. Apple refuses to pay but wants to exchange for a new one, mother goes to media. Apple is wise to refrain from any comments.
Liar, liar, pants on fire. Going to sue Apple and raise their ire. The iPod nano is the world's newest and smallest IED (Improvised Explosive Device). All the iRaqi terrorists are carrying them for their dual purpose.
I think the same thing can happen if you sit on Pop Rocks really hard.
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
posted Oct 5th 2007 5:43AM
Nana is not a surprise from Monica. She misspeaks about 5 times a newscast. Its as much a part of channel 5 news here in Atlanta as Coke is a a part of the cities history.
As for the ipod, despite this being the second melted nano publicly photographed, has anyone proven it was due to a lithium discharge? Sounds like Fox5 may be in in for a little smackdown. And one other problem remains, there has been no forensic analysis of the ipod. Was it bent before it melted applying pressure to it, was he sweating, did he spill coffee on his lap?
Sorry one melted pile of electronics and a scorched piece of paper with no other corroborating evidence doesn't make a news story. I'm sure there were no witnesses at all as he was only in the busiest airport in the country (depending on who you talk to).
I assume the “hot-coffee-in-lap style legal preparation” is a reference to the infamous McDonald’s coffee case (Liebeck vs. McDonald’s). Although this case has become the poster child for so-called “frivolous lawsuits” most people don’t seem to know the facts of that case.
http://www.okbar.org/public/judges/mcdonaldsspeech.pdf
Oh and one thing the author forgot to mention in his speech: the day after the jury verdict, McDonald’s lowered the temperature of its coffee. So if you ever happen to spill McDonald’s coffee on yourself, you won’t end up in the hospital having skin grafts (and you can thank Stella Liebeck of that!)
True, but I still don't feel safe around O.J.
Thomas
OK- that's just flat out funny.
It's her fault for spilling the coffee.
Did O.J. set your pants ablaze?
Really now, who even reads the actual article anyway? It's all about the comments, right?
Why is this guys mom in on the story? He's an adult right? The last time something bad happened to me and my mom got involved I think I was 10.
My 2G Nano stopped working and just says charged when plugged-in. I still have files on it and can sync/restore, but it just goes off when un-plugged.
Is there a problem with the batteries ?
What's so hard to believe about fire-resistant paper? They make children's pajamas out of paper, right?
i wouldn't scoff at it completely-- those batteries store a lot of power, and they can explode, especially while charging. maybe he had dropped it a lot, or something like that. i've read elsewhere that it's not really safe to let any device (cellphone, whatever) charge unattended, and especially not overnight while you're asleep (and prone to be burned alive). of course that doesn't mean all 1st gen nanos will set your pants on fire.
I love how the mom so astutely claims that it isn't about facts, it is about a bunch of what-ifs and the possibility of making money based on those what-ifs. Give the guy a new ipod and send him back to work. Maybe someday he'll be smart enough to tell the difference between flames and bit of smoke and his crazy mom won't dream up possible disasters when their wasn't one.
Seems kind of fishy to me that his USB connector was also burned. I'm sure it can't be good for it, being plugged in all day while being smashed around in a 300lb guy's sweaty pocket.
Wow - how big must his pockets be that the miraculous glossy paper didn't even have to be folded? (Or maybe it was, but the picture quality is crap and I can't tell.)
Otherwise, am I the only one who thinks that "chest high flames" may have caused a bit more damage to said miraculous savior than a small little burn mark? His pants seem to be in excellent condition, as well, after surviving such a dangerous environment.
I thought fire burned things. =(
Watch the video again, in the final 17 seconds there is a profile shot of the Nano. I find it odd how the case is bent up as if something crushed the Nano. I bet what ever it was caused the battery to short out. Thank God he had a glossy piece of paper in his pocket to protect him.
Lawyer lawyer!!! pants on fire
"nana" is the bigger story here
I worked at a local news channel for 4 years. They are a complete joke & the last place I'd go for news, weather, etc. Local media in general usually sucks balls.
I just saw a commercial for my local news (in Las Vegas) and they're going to mention this today apparently. So stupid.
Being a resident of Atlanta, its wiser to think "scam" first. More then likely this person is looking for a financial angle. Also I find it hard to believe that the little ipod battery would have enough energy to create ignition much less the flames this person describes. Its possible but doubtful.
As for the news, well WSB is known for aiming for the sensational over the factual. They might give facts, but cherry pick them so don't get the full context of the situation to come to your own conclusions.
Actually I think that describes all of news nowadays. It may be why people use blogs to get information. At least easy to tell the facts from the opinion.
(insert liberal comment here)
I have a friend that this happened to... well kinda... He had been using a generic wall charger (that he won as a prize) the IP stopped working. While his dad was doing the reset procedure on it black acrid smoke shot from the headphone jack and the touch wheel melted a lot like this one. There were no flames to be seen... just the smoke. It was on a table at the time and didn't have a protective glossy piece of paper to shield... they chalked it up to the charger...
Probably this happened. Guy played around with cigarettelighter in pocket where he has the ipod. Scared to shit for his mum, makes up exploding nano story. Mother contacts Apple for milliondollar settlement. Apple refuses to pay but wants to exchange for a new one, mother goes to media. Apple is wise to refrain from any comments.
Liar, liar, pants on fire. Going to sue Apple and raise their ire. The iPod nano is the world's newest and smallest IED (Improvised Explosive Device). All the iRaqi terrorists are carrying them for their dual purpose.
I think the same thing can happen if you sit on Pop Rocks really hard.
Weren't the recalls on the batteries lithium-ion and the ones inside the ipods lithium-polymer???