Emblaze's First Else unveiled in London, promises to be a game-changer


As the name suggests, the First Else's main objective is to be different. This may sound like a marketing hype but Else seems serious -- it wanted to create not just another phone, but rather a brand new mobile user experience (especially the ergonomics, aesthetics and the content delivery system) to upstage the iPhone and the latest Android devices, both of which Else considers to be the market leaders. Eldad Eilam, CTO of Else, explained that this required starting from scratch and using custom technology where possible (such as its proprietary graphics engine), while at the same time the technical details are well-packaged so that they don't intimidate the users (but not just by wrapping an aging OS with some fancy skin; yes, we're staring at you, Windows Phone).
Else started with ALP's Linux foundations, and after two years and 33 partner agreements, it unveiled the Else Intuition OS. When asked about other Linux-based platforms like Android and webOS, Eilam expressed little concern. "Android's a game-changer... [but] people need to consider that Android doesn't bring good user experience. Most [manufacturers] have failed. The Droid is improving, has a great infrastructure but they treat Android as just a component." Interestingly, Else didn't comment on webOS -- probably to avoid stirring up Access's bitter memories of Palm, but it could've been just a miss.

"The death of main menu"
While there's some good old Linux doing the donkey work underneath, the First Else's futuristic and intuitive user interface mesmerized us during the presentation and our hands-on, all thanks to "sPlay" -- a right-thumb-controlled, sci-fi-like fan menu interface. Else actually did a live demo on its prototype First Else with no visible glitches, and when we had our hands on the device we got the same great responsiveness. Else CEO Amir Kupervas made a good point about how "smart" phones should actually be adapting to us instead of us having to adapt to cluttered menu systems, which led the to birth of sPlay and the fisheye display which provide minimal but necessary information, while keeping a consistent layout and visual aesthetics across different applications. At the same time, these features are positioned within reach of the right thumb, and sPlay takes it further by letting you easily browse different content by just a simple swipe of the right thumb. Kupervas went as far as saying this single-hand operation is "the death of main menu," mocking most other smartphone platforms. You'll probably appreciate more of what Else is trying to achieve after watching its presentation (followed by its campaign video which is also available at the 'Source' link):
Impressive hardware, interesting service integration
While Else's focus is on the user experience, it hasn't compromised on the hardware front: inside it's got a powerful TI OMAP 3430 processor (as found on the Motorola Droid and Palm Pre), a brilliant 854x480 3.5-inch capacitive LCD touchscreen, a 5-megapixel camera which promises to capture 480p video at 30fps, and a 1450mAh battery which claims to outlast the iPhone 3GS by at least one hour. Oh, we dig the OLED indicators at the top as well, leaving us some useful space on the screen. Details on storage capacity are still vague, but right now Else is only saying anything up to 32GB. There's no word on where the First Else will make its commercial launch -- all we know is that it'll only operate on HSDPA and EDGE (sorry, Verizon fans).
Speaking of carriers, Else is also working on a self-branded media store which will require no credit card details, thus enhancing the "out-of-the-box experience". How will it do that, you say? Well, it'll work very closely with carriers in full partnership, and let them charge you at the end of the month. This isn't totally revolutionary -- with the iPhone it's just a one-off setup on iTunes -- but it's still a nice touch by Else, and we're sure someone out there will appreciate this extra effort to create a seamless user experience. Similarly, Else will be setting up an app store and they'll release an SDK at launch. We've been told that some big names are already working on the first lot of apps -- World of Warcraft was mentioned -- and there'll be an app approval process to ensure that they'll have the same flow as the handset itself. Good for the users, but probably not so good for the developers.
Wrap-up
There's a lot of potential here and well done to Else for the work so far, but there are still many uncertainties: pricing, availability, carriers, apps, final device specs and, most importantly, usability in the long run. That's a lot of of unanswered questions -- almost enough for us to call this vaporware -- but we're optimistic, as we've actually held and played with a working device in person. We're hoping to hear a lot more about what Else has in store -- until then, we can only drool over this final quickie demonstration. Just remember to wipe up afterwards.



























Too complex for the iphone fanboys.
@yerand
It's nice but too complex for anyone except tech-nerds with nothing but spare time on their hands and a love for unfathomable devices. Look for very low sales on this device. Anything nerds love, average consumers hate. Most five-year olds will never be able to figure that UI out.
And thats why we have Apple.
True, and if most 5 year olds cant figure it out, most 13 year old girls don't even stand a chance.
@yerand
News Flash! A GUI is just that! A GUI! It's the underlying OS and technology that is important and how they well they work in synergy to provide the best experience, I don't understand why there is this idea that gadget hounds and soccer moms can't use the same device. It would be cool to have an OS open and flexible enough so that u can change the entire user experience just like on desktop linux distros. How bout this? "home screens" that are different UI's entirely. One home screen changes the entire UI to soccer mom "iPhone-ish" status and the other turns into Power user 1337 mode. There! problem solved. Now I can get my bleeding edge tech without compromising ease of use or getting crippled or sub standard features.
It's kind of a curvy mashup of Sense and Zune, but requires more slipping around to get to info... kind a branching tree metaphor. I'm not entirely sold on it, but it's certainly interesting, IF they can get devices and devs out there.
False. Nerd adoption often drives "average consumer" adoption. Part of the reason average consumers love the iPhone is because of all the apps. Who do you develops those apps? People who know how to code -- i.e. nerds. And nerds like to develop for devices that they themselves use.
Example 2. Nerds use Google => normal people use Google.
Of course, this isn't always true (pen protectors have yet to catch on), but don't be so quick to bash all things nerdy.
@yerand So troll, I take it you use DOS and make calls on a rotary phone at home? (or should I say Mom's basement?)
@yerand
That actually just looks like something you can install if you run a jailbroken iPhone.
"News Flash! A GUI is just that! A GUI! It's the underlying OS and technology that is important"
I think it is fair to say that the GUI itself is very important since it will be your primary interface with the device and bad interface design will certainly hamper use. At this time I can't tell whether this device has a good or bad interface since the videos don't seem to be working.
"False. Nerd adoption often drives "average consumer" adoption."
You are kidding, right? Or is this really the "Year of the Linux Desktop" that we've been hearing so much about? Nerds have an inflated opinion of themselves.
#1 Lots of nerds use windows. They know how to overclock their custom built PC's so that they can play killer games. Apple didn't quite get this which is one of the reasons why it didn't take over the market.
#2 Regular people used to use AOL. Only a nerd would type in http://www.something.com when it was much easier to type in an AOL keyword. Guess who won?
not really. Geeks love the xbox360. regular people love the Wii. Each owns their respective markets without mixing them.
That comment was actually a response to Average white boy's post. I know the importance of a GUI but I'm saying that it can be changed because its just an interface. An OS is not it's interface and a good flexible OS should be able to cater to basic and advanced users but they shouldn't Judge how good an OS is just by it's mass appeal. Then again phone makers beg for it by not offering enough UI customization.
@yerand this is complicated for most users to use and while the idea might seem really cool this is like a half baked research project. These guys really need to do some research on UI design and usability. Text interface is BAD and slow from a perception stand point. Also they seem to have forgotten completely that some people are left handed and in fact sometimes even right handed people use their phone with their left hand.
Oh and this device DOES NOT adjust to your. Just like any other device you have to adjust to it and there is no way around that. The point is to make something SEEM natural and easy to learn. Anyway the bottom line is this seems like a mod for Android and actually I am offending Android with that statement.
I think it may be in my best interest to wait through at least Q1 and Q2 2010 before buying my next smartphone.
you guys really need to hire some hand models.
Wowwww. That's hot. The UI looks really nice, sorta utilitarian though.
@Anku: Well, the two main concepts they're pushing are the globally available fan shaped "main menu", and the context sensitive "fish eye" view. The global menu could be fairly easily grafted onto WM or Android, while Android 2.0 already has a similar idiom to the fish eye in the contacts, where you long press a contact and get a horizontal menu of available operations (call, text, email etc.) I don't think a whole new platform is needed to implement these key concepts. The visual sugar is higly subjective--some may like a Minority Report like minimalist interface with glowing elements, others might prefer a different look. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw some copycat apps on Android and/or WM implementing some of these ideas.
@Anku Needs to get rid of all those glowing stuff. I bet they can increase the speed of the actual device removing unnecessary animations...
@runner50783 But Eye Candy is Sexy! I guess this is why my Vista is running on a slug's pace.
Im going to go with vaporware here.
Look at the players in the market right now, the only ones that have been successful have been at it for 20 years. Nokia, Microsoft, RIM, Palm, Google and Apple.
There are no start ups in that list. Building a device, a platform, an ecosystem, etc. is extremely difficult, and I really don't think there is any room for anybody to penetrate here. We already have three mature linux-based operating systems.
@(Unverified) I really have to be with you here. Further more, I'm not really sure there's another free spot in the smartphone OS market. We've already got too many choices - WinMo, Android, WebOS, Maemo, Symbian, and soon Samsung's Bada (or whatever they call it).
Why do companies really want to have their own OS? Didn't we try this once, already?
@(Unverified) I agree, but you have to admit that none of the major smartphone OS's out there are are designed for one-handed navigation, which is silly on a tiny device like a smartphone. This is the first OS I've seen that really addresses that problem. Also refreshing to see an OS that doesn't operate by "home screen button. click app icon. do what you wanna do. close/minimize app. repeat."
knowing that it's based on linux is also encouraging.
@(Unverified) you realize that 20 years ago (1989) Google did not exist and Microsoft was going with MSDos 3.something, right?
@(Unverified)
Well its clearly not vaporware.
And Nokia, Microsoft and RIM have been doing this the longest and they can't even make a decent mobile O/S. Google came out of nowhere and made something awesome in a few years time.
Apple did the same thing. Not a startup, but they were new to the mobile arena and rocked it.
I personally have felt like *I* could make a better phone than most of the people out there doing it today, because how many phones come out that *still* don't have a 3.5mm headphone jack or that use a resistive screen? I read so many reviews on engadget that I KNOW what people like us want. I would not be surprised if someone new came in with a passion like us gadget freaks and made something awesome.
-Taylor
@(Unverified) Clearly not vaporware lol, they are showing a functional device. Will it be a huge hit like the iPhone? Probably not, but it's still a functional device.
HTC was a start-up in the early 2000's, a little known company who sold to cell providers only to allow them to rebrand the phone as their own (Cingular 2125, 3125, 8125)
Look how big HTC is now. They got something right, all they had to do was get their foot in the door.
I often feel the same way. When I see a lot of these devices it's like "You're doing it wrong". I'd like to design a smart phone, I bet I can make something better than anything on the market today. How does one go about getting a job like that without an engineering degree?
@(Unverified) Vapor what? You do know what vapor ware is right? Duke Nukem is Vapor ware this is real as shown on video therefor not "vapor"...
@(Unverified) Dude, the iPhone took the cell phone market by storm from nothing flat. And two years ago in November 2007 Google announced Android. HTC is a relative newcomer to mobile phones, and yet doing rather well. I'm not saying its easy to enter the mobile phone market, but many of your points are incorrect on their face.
@(Unverified)
It's obviously a new phone platform, but nothing is guaranteed anymore if you ask me. Look at the iPhone, the newcomer blasted away everyone. And there were quite a few who predicted failure for the iPhone. Similar situation with Android, enough people like it so that it now has a good foothold and will likely continue.
This new phone could be a serious contender, you never know.
@(Unverified)
I think he means back in the day when Sergey Brin and Larry Page started Google from their garage.
@Froggy
@Eternity
I remember we were Alpha testing Search 20 years ago before the Internet as we know it existed. It was some crazy ahead of it's time technology. We used printed diagrams and would put our search queries in the mailbox and then get the results by mail. I'll show you some top secret photos we took:
http://img694.imageshack.us/img694/1769/cardm.jpg
http://img694.imageshack.us/img694/83/gisinreallife737409.jpg
This is where we picked up the habit of keeping everything we do in "beta" forever.
@Fanfoot I wouldn't really say apple took anything by storm. iPhone hype existed for years before it was released, and something anticipated can't really take anyone "by storm".
Damn technology, can never keep up!
Lol at the iPhone ringtone :D
It always gotta be everywhere eh?
Ancient? You must own an iPhone then. Speak for yourself. I remember when basic A2DP and Copy and Paste were "Ooooh ahhhh wow Features" for you guys.
oh and I remember how MMS was "Wow.. New... Amazing" too and real GPS, not google maps.
I can't wait till apple invents multitasking and video calling on a phone /sarcasm.
@Eternity: No it was more of a "WTF! No A2DP? No copy/paste? No MMS? No GPS?!" than an 'ooh/ah' thing. Anyway, not to sound like an apple fanboy but none of those were due to hardware limitations (except GPS of course) and were all implemented eventually.
I understand. Bet it made your phone feel ancient huh?
Super cool but not sure that it is all that practical.
@bjsguess
agreed. it looks uber cool, but say you want to call a friend whose name starts with Z, must you manually scroll all the way to the bottom?
man i wish i had thumbs...
@llee123 what's it like being a literate squirrel?
... Except that Squirrels have thumbs.
Pay attention.
and that's why squirrels are awesome! you hear me? AWESOME
@llee123
You can use other fingers....
@llee123 I must say that as a SouthPaw, me and my 10% of the general population are not going to be interested in this device. I didn't get into Blackberry until RIM moved the cursor away from the right and adopted the trackball, and now I use a 3G S which also offer no right-handed bigotry-- bigotry that's rampant in the rest of the Western World...which I include these Israelies in.
Wow, that UI looks incredibly sexy! Though I'm not too sure about it being text only...
@Jamman yeah, Im with you...but I dont think the text will be a problem. All them images probably slow down speeds anyway, so it might end up being a plus, though I really hope you will be able to change the color schemes. I like the dark ambiance, but would be nice to swap for something brighter every once in a while!