Discussion about

April 6th 2012 3:08 pm

Why would someone choose a Nest over an Ecobee smart thermostat?

sort by

1 reply

It depends on your system. From what I can tell the Ecobee is more expensive, but does have more configurations currently. Another upside is that it is avalible in more countries, where the Nest is still primarily a US product. The Ecobee has also been out quite a while, and as such is considered a more "mature" product. There is also a cheaper version coming out in April, that most likely is meant to compete (at least in price) to the nest. In addition, the Ecobee seems more geared to more complete systems (business, multi zoned houses, etc) where as the Nest is meant more for the average home user (although the nest can also do zones). As such it has features that work with your contactor/ heating guys, and will inform them for you if you house has AC/heat issues.

On the downside it appears to be missing some of the auto features the nest has, such as the motion sensors(which is my favorite part of it). And the cheaper version coming out is missing even more features than its more expensive older brother. The nest has a very streamlined interface, and is meant to be more of a passive experience, requiring less interaction with it, with more auto adjusting features. It's meant more for a person to set it and let it adjust to you, not requing you to fiddle with it if you don't want, while still having it try to adjust to best fit your energy needs.

They both have pretty good remote apps and algorithms to try to make your home as efficient as possible. They both take note of the weather, and connect to most home heating/cooling units (although the ecobee being around longer works with pretty much all of them). They both can have multiple units talk to each other, and work either in tandem, or individually (zoned). I did my own review of the nest on my site - tasel.wordpress.com­/2012­/04­/03­/my­-first­-month­-with... if you want to take a look.
1 like dislike

2 users following this discussion:

  • Tasel
  • raskev

This discussion has been viewed 6134 times.
Last activity .