Discussion about
aaron

June 9th 2011 6:16 pm

Wii U only supports one of the new controllers at a time

While the Wii U is compatible with up to 4 existing Wii Remotes, Shigeru Miyamoto tells GamePro that the system is designed to be used with only one of the next-generation controllers.

He explains that if they wanted to support several touchscreen controllers, they would have probably let people use their Nintendo 3DS systems as input devices.

Since the content on the touchscreen is simply streamed to the controller from the console, perhaps the system doesn't have the horsepower to drive multiple new controllers?

www.gamepro.com­/article­/news­/220292­/e3­-2011­-only­-o...

sort by

10 replies
kris

If this is the way they're choosing to go, then it immediately eliminates some of the advantages of having a screen on your controller: the ability to watch your slice of the action without having to look at a split-screen, and the ability to "hide" your actions from the other players (either because you don't want to bore people with menus, or because you're competing against other people and you don't want them to see what you're doing).
4 like dislike
dave

I didn't even think of that. That was some of the fun (and annoying things) of playing games like Goldeneye back in the day with your friends. As you frantically run around a level, you take a quick peak at another corner of the screen to see where your adversary was. This would have been a pretty neat way to mitigate that.

There'd be tons of use for that though (see also, using the controller to choose a particular play in a sports game.)
1 like dislike
groovechicken

Ditto... football plays.
1 like dislike
mike

Based on what you guys are saying it almost seems as if what Nintendo has included in the new controller is overkill. I reckon there's a greater use case for a less resource-intensive screen that compliments the gameplay (shades of the Sega VMU!), rather than mirroring what's on the screen and allowing you to play the entire game in lower-res on the controller.
1 like dislike
groovechicken

Don't get me wrong, mike, playing on the screen is pretty sweet and I am sure there are lots of households that will appreciate the feature more than being able to choose football plays or whatever on multiple individual screens. Nintendo usually seems to get their research right, or at least right enough to sell tons of whatever they are pushing. They probably even considered the cases we are lamenting not being covered, but chose the other path. It's just a shame they couldn't do both. Considering how much this is likely to cost, though, I suppose they also figured no household would ever buy more than 1, if any, so the point isn't worth debating.
0 like dislike
Dpmt

This is disappointing and I expect them to backtrack on it. Especially seeing all the negative response.

The jury is out until next year.
1 like dislike
groovechicken

Well, do we know if these connect over Bluetooth like the Wiimote or wifi? If it is Bluetooth, don't expect them to backtrack because Bluetooth can only handle so much bandwidth at a time, and that is probably the limiting factor. Besides, they need some reason to sell you a Wii U 2 in 4 years, right? ;)
1 like dislike
dave

I wonder what the resolution on the controller is? I mean, it's not full HD is it? That said, it'd probably require a lot of graphical throughput, not to mention wireless bandwidth in order to push data to multiple controllers.

Plus, the cost of those controllers are going to be pretty damn expensive too!

I guess it was a design decision from the get go, though. And it explains why we only ever saw one controller on screen during the keynote promos. This isn't something they planned to implement.

Bummer.
0 like dislike
jasonact

Maybe I'm not thinking out of the box enough, but I kind of agree with Miyamoto. I can't see how using more than one of these would be beneficial. What am I missing?
0 like dislike
xBBx

Good news! Seeing as this thread hasn't been updated since last year, at this year's E3, Nintendo announced Wii U owners will be able to use two Wii U controllers at a time.
0 like dislike