Discussion about
mbrazle

November 3rd 2012 4:05 am

Windows 8 Hybrid

I've got a HP Elitebook 2740 that had Windows 7. When 8 came out I upgraded. So my laptop is also one of the first Windows 8 hybrid PCs. The Elitebook is a convertible, so it opens like a normal laptop (12.1" screen), and you can swivel the screen and fold it flat to make a tablet. The reason I like mine so much is because it has both the multi-touch screen (a feature that isn't entirely useful in Windows 7) AND it has a stylus (for artistic stuff and handwriting recognition which is cool and fun).
Sure it's a lot bigger than a tablet, but I think these devices are going to be very important because they bridge the gap between the PC of the average user (a basic laptop) and the tablet of the average user (an electronic entertainment slate). These devices can perform BOTH functions and they use one operating system to do so. That's very impressive in my book ... err tablet.

Marc touched on this, but I think these devices and technologies will develop into a better combined technology in the future to replace both. I think touch will be central and even though I am partial to using a stylus, I think it along with the mouse and keyboard will soon be gone, and a convertible/hybrid device like the XPS 12 is going to be a key transition tool.

sort by

1 reply
MtnSloth

What makes more sense: having a variety of specialized devices that are optimized for particular types of computing, or having a smaller number of devices with less optimization? That is after all what we are talking about. Is there a meaningful difference in terms of cost, portability, convenience and capability between a tablet, a phone and a notebook computer? To this point, I think there are too many compromises for consumers with tweener products - like the Galaxy Note (phone/tablet) and Windows 7 era hybrid PCs. I am not disputing that some business users, like yourself, are well served by these hybrid PCs; I just don't see such users as mainstream.

I worry that, because hybrid notebook/tablets were once lame, too many are holding dogmatic positions on hybrids. Sure. Hybrids were lame for just about everyone until recently. However, it is foolish to assume that is going to be the case with Ivy Bridge Windows 8 touch optimized convertibles; and probably dead wrong when it comes to Haswell-based convertibles - where the size and weight differences may not be nearly as great as they are now between the best tablets and a hybrid device.

However, the real winner may be the Surface Pro type of tablets (Intel or AMD x64 CPU) from third-party vendors - the ones that wisely provide desktop docking options. These should be great for business users that roam between home and any number of main or branch offices. Admittedly, it may be less ideal for a mobile sales force - where a convertible may make more sense due to an absence of docking stations at client offices.

For purposes of completeness, I don't want to discount tethering a tablet to a Bluetooth keyboard and mouse (or touch pad); but I question how often "normal" users actually use this sort of setup. It seems far less convenient than a hybrid; and, for that reason, I wonder how often a typical user would go through the trouble of pairing the peripherals (never mind remembering to bring them along!). That said, I'll bet this is the preferred option for many gdgt users as Bluetooth pairing is nothing more than a trivial inconvenience for the tech savvy.

One last observation about touch interfaces and convertibles (or tablets with keyboards), I find touch interfaces awkward as soon as my screen is docked or mounted in a stand and I have a physical keyboard to interact with. Specifically, I hate reaching up from the keyboard to interact with a screen mounted in a more vertical plane. A large touch pad (that is gesture aware) seems preferable to a touch sensitive screen in this mode. Maybe this is just me . . . and a decades old mouse habit.
1 like dislike
share:

Products mentioned

2 users following this discussion:

  • mbrazle
  • MtnSloth

This discussion has been viewed 1456 times.
Last activity .