Never mind, realized that you have to mark it as "Have it" or "Had it". What a silly design, very confusing to newcomers and you are left with no warning as to why you can't write a review...
I would suggest fixing that..
Looks like a bug to me if its not detecting your typing! I do see the products you mentioned in your screenshot under "already reviewed" though.
The screen is displaying the items based on what is currently on your have/had/want lists. So if CoBullet has nothing on their list, nothing is going to show up.
I apologize for the issue and will be passing your feedback along to the product team.
Same here. When I try to ask a question, it opens a new page, but not logged in. So, I try to log in and it won't let me. I go back several pages, and I'm still logged in. I try again and again it takes me to a page where I'm not logged in. Essentially, I can't log in and I can't ask a question. This site sucks. I'm out of here.