Latest in Code signing

Image credit:

Rogue Amoeba on code signing, iPhone SDK

Share
Tweet
Share

Sponsored Links

Mike Ash at Rogue Amoeba has published his fairly extensive thoughts on Apple's code signing policies and plans, as well as how they relate to the iPhone SDK. He makes some solid points and elaborates on thoughts that are being bandied about elsewhere on the 'net. In his critique of some points in the iPhone SDK announcement, his concerns regarding the "banned" iPhone apps are quite valid, in my opinion. Out of the list of apps to be denied (illegal, malicious, unforeseen, privacy, porn and bandwidth hog), he picks out a couple that are of concern.

In regards to the issue of "porn", he notes that "...Apple is making moral judgements of the apps they sign." To me, it seems like Apple chose the safe option and just categorically denied materials that could sully their reputation, which I personally think was a good (if not obvious) choice. But the question arises, as it always does, about the definition of porn and obscenity... and who makes the call. Apple, as gatekeeper, gets to make those decisions for all of us. I can see some torrid debates arising in the future.

Also of particular (and potentially more controversial) concern is the category "unforeseen," which provides a fairly broad scope for Apple to add to the list later. Again, it's likely a smart decision on Apple's part and a good way of sealing off loopholes without making the list read like a legal contract (see "License Agreement"), but leaves open the option for some heavy-handed control over what you can put on your iPhone.

Of course, this initial list is incomplete, with restrictions outlined in the SDK license agreement (as pointed out in Rogue Amoeba's subsequent post). If you take an interest in this debate, be sure to check out Mike's post, "Code Signing and You."

All products recommended by Engadget are selected by our editorial team, independent of our parent company. Some of our stories include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Share
Tweet
Share

Popular on Engadget

The Morning After: Hasbro's $60 'Baby Yoda' toy is coming this fall

The Morning After: Hasbro's $60 'Baby Yoda' toy is coming this fall

View
FCC forced to ask for public feedback on net neutrality repeal

FCC forced to ask for public feedback on net neutrality repeal

View
See how 'The Mandalorian' used Unreal Engine for its real-time digital sets

See how 'The Mandalorian' used Unreal Engine for its real-time digital sets

View
Google's wireless gigabit internet is now called Fiber Webpass

Google's wireless gigabit internet is now called Fiber Webpass

View
'PUBG' cross party play capability for PS4 and Xbox One has arrived

'PUBG' cross party play capability for PS4 and Xbox One has arrived

View

From around the web

Page 1Page 1ear iconeye iconFill 23text filevr