DeathPaladin: I had to go with Michael Gray's analysis. Don't neglect style, story and scale. Says it right in the rules. The TOC Champions? They are blank slates. No personalities. No quirks. They don't even say anything. They're boring. There's no style to neglect when they show up. Honestly, the only reason they made it as far as they have is because they turn every fight into a 5v1 battle.
Apple: The faction champions aren't PvE specialized. The massive damage output will make it close, and I'd love to see Rimefang get sheeped, but the champs don't have the proper toolbox for a tank-and-spank, with their lack of single-target healing or aggro control. Tyrannus runs riot, marking the shaman first to stop him from healing, taking him out and then shifting focus to the other dps, killing them in order of fragility. All the while his wyrm is wreaking absolute havoc on anyone who's not presently being axed. Even if we assume the champs play it as cleverly as possible, you don't bring an épée to a joust and you don't send PvPers to a boss fight.
Sumadin: Here is how i see it. The Toc champions hit like a trunk, but only as a union. One by one they are quite harmless. And if there is anything Tyrannus is good at it is keeping people occupied.
The arms warrior may have 300k life but he got no avoidiance and his healer can only hold up about 10k hps. Oh and he forgot his defence cap gear. While the shaman get's the brand(so he can't heal) the arms warrior goes down soon enough.
Next is the Rogue. 300k life is not much when you carry leather and she will go down fast.
At this point Tyrannus will have taken quite some dmg but the dps of the champions is now down to 60% dmg. Tyrannus let's rimefang shot at the shaman while he quickly kills the mage.
With Just 2 up they desperatly fire everything they got at him but Tyrannus just places his brand at the hunter of them while he nukes the shaman. By the time the shaman goes down, the hunter is already down to 60% life. And through Tyrannus is almost at his limit he finishes off the hunter swiftly.
At the feet of his victory he yells the famous words: You should have stayed... IN THE MOUNTAINS.
Sgtkillgore: I believe some people are forgetting law 4 of the Thunderdome: Assume that the opponents share similar levels, health pools and comparative overall damage output. This means, if we assume Tyrannus has 1 Million hit points, that each Champion has about 200k health. The battle would be incredibly close. Runok's amazingly small heals wouldn't do anything to counter the incoming damage, but Tyrannus wouldn't get any returns off of his brand. Tyrannus would ignore the Warrior in favor of taking out the cloth/leather/mail classes first, while Rimefang does his normal rotation of attacking and freezing them.
In the end Tyrannus takes out all Champions except the Warrior. Unfortunately the DPS of the Champions was too high and the Warrior takes him out. Faction Champs have this one, but not by miles. This would be a photo-finish encounter.
The Thunderdome gates clang closed
Two Bosses Enter would like to extend special thanks to judges Michael Gray, Matthew Rossi and reader-judges Sky Paladin and John Zakour, as well as the fans who cheered on their favorites from the stands. And now, as we reach the end of this latest season, the Two Bosses Thunderdome doors swing shut with a mighty clang. The Thunderdome will remain closed for the rest of the Wrath of the Lich King and may re-open when new and even more devious bosses have been unleashed upon Azeroth. Thanks to all who came!
Set aside the world order -- let the Thunderdome determine who's the champion! Your votes determine the outcome in WoW.com's series of fantasy deathmatches, Two Bosses Enter, One Boss Leaves.