Dell Special Committee Receives Two Alternative Acquisition Proposals in "Go-Shop" Process
ROUND ROCK, Texas--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The Special Committee of the Board of Dell Inc. (NASDAQ: DELL) today announced that the "go-shop" period provided for in the merger agreement between the company and entities owned by Michael Dell, Dell's Founder, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and investment funds affiliated with Silver Lake Partners, has elicited two alternative acquisition proposals. One proposal was submitted by a group affiliated with a private equity fund managed by Blackstone and the other by entities affiliated with Carl Icahn. Both proposals are attached.
The Special Committee, consisting of four independent and disinterested directors, has determined, after consultation with its independent financial and legal advisors, that both proposals could reasonably be expected to result in superior proposals, as defined under the terms of the existing merger agreement. Therefore, each of the Blackstone and Icahn groups is an "excluded party" and the Special Committee intends to continue negotiations with both.
The Special Committee also noted that Michael Dell has confirmed to the Committee his willingness to explore in good faith the possibility of working with third parties regarding alternative acquisition proposals.
Alex Mandl, Chairman of the Special Committee, said, "We are gratified by the success of our go-shop process that has yielded two alternative proposals with the potential to create additional value for Dell shareholders. We intend to work diligently with all three potential acquirers to ensure the best possible outcome for Dell shareholders, whichever transaction that may be."
Pursuant to the existing merger agreement, subject to certain requirements, the Special Committee has the right to terminate the agreement in order to accept a superior proposal. The Special Committee has not determined that either the Blackstone proposal or the Icahn proposal in fact constitutes a superior proposal under the existing merger agreement and neither is at this stage sufficiently detailed or definitive for such a determination to be appropriate. There can be no assurance that either proposal will ultimately lead to a superior proposal. While negotiations continue, the Special Committee has not changed its recommendation with respect to, and continues to support, the company's pending sale to entities controlled by Michael Dell and Silver Lake Partners.
Prior to entering into the existing merger agreement, the Special Committee undertook a rigorous process, over a period of more than five months, to evaluate Dell's risks, opportunities, and strategic alternatives. These alternatives included continuing with or modifying the company's existing business plan, implementing a leveraged recapitalization, changing the dividend policy, and potentially selling all or parts of the business.
As a result of that process, the Special Committee unanimously determined that the sale of the company at a premium would be the best alternative for stockholders, and negotiated aggressively to ensure that stockholders receive the highest possible value, including securing provisions for a robust "go-shop" process. The result was that a number of strategic and financial parties entered into confidentiality agreements with the company and Blackstone and Icahn submitted proposals.
The price of $13.65 per share in cash to be paid pursuant to the existing merger agreement provides value certainty at a 37% premium to the average price for the 90 days before rumors of the transaction surfaced. The Committee noted that the Silver Lake Partners raised its bid six times by a total of approximately $4 billion, or over 20%, during the course of negotiations.
Subject to applicable laws and regulations, the Special Committee undertakes no obligation, to provide updates or make further statements regarding the proposals received from Blackstone or Icahn, any revised proposals that may be received from either of them or the status of discussions with either of them, unless and until a definitive agreement is reached or such discussions are terminated.
The alternative acquisition proposals received from Blackstone and Icahn follow here:
Boulder Acquisition Corp.
c/o Blackstone Management Partners L.L.C.
March 22, 2013
STRICTLY PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL
| Special Committee of the Board of Directors of Dell Inc. |
| One Dell Way |
| Round Rock, Texas 78682 |
| Attention: Alex Mandl, Presiding Director |
| Re: Acquisition Proposal and Request for Designation as "Excluded Party" |
Dear Mr. Mandl:
On behalf of Boulder Acquisition Corp. ("AcquisitionCo"), Blackstone Management Associates VI L.L.C. (in its capacity as general partner of Blackstone Capital Partners VI L.P.), Francisco Partners III, LP, Insight Venture Management, LLC and each of their respective affiliates, affiliated funds and limited partners (all such persons and entities, together with AcquisitionCo, being collectively referred to herein as the "Investor Group"), we hereby submit this Acquisition Proposal and request prompt designation of the Investor Group as an Excluded Party, as such terms are defined in the Agreement and Plan of Merger by and among Dell Inc., a Delaware corporation ("Dell"), and the Parent Parties (as defined therein) dated as of February 5, 2013 (the "Merger Agreement").
Thank you for allowing us the access to management and data that we needed to complete a preliminary review of the Dell business. We believe there is significant upside in the Dell businesses, we see significant upside in the value of Dell's shares, and our proposed transaction structure (described below) will deliver significantly greater value to your shareholders than the value agreed to in the Merger Agreement.
As a result, we would like to proceed in the process to acquire Dell and hereby submit, in accordance with the terms of the Merger Agreement, this Acquisition Proposal. Subject to confirmatory due diligence and negotiation of a mutually agreeable merger agreement (which we expect to include substantially similar terms and conditions as the Merger Agreement, other than certain changes to mechanical provisions required to implement the structure of our Acquisition Proposal as described below), we are prepared to enter into a definitive agreement to acquire Dell in a leveraged recapitalization transaction where shareholders could choose to receive either all cash or stock (subject to a cap), in each case valued in excess of $14.25 per share, representing a Superior Proposal to the $13.65 cash purchase price agreed to in the Merger Agreement.
We are prepared to invest the time and resources necessary to complete a transaction along an expedited timeline, and we would contemplate providing drafts of a definitive transaction agreement (which will include financing commitment letters), along with our more detailed proposal as soon as possible following the completion of satisfactory due diligence.
KEY FEATURES OF OUR PROPOSAL
Our Acquisition Proposal contemplates a leveraged recapitalization transaction with the following features:
- Shareholders who wish to receive cash will have the opportunity to receive greater than $14.25 in cash per share for all of their shares.
- Shareholders who wish to participate in the ongoing upside of the company will have the opportunity to remain as shareholders and receive shares (subject to a cap) valued in excess of $14.25, which shares would continue to be publicly traded on the Nasdaq.
Our proposed transaction would have several important benefits for Dell shareholders:
- Higher price per share for shareholders electing to receive cash
- Shareholder friendly structure, with the ability to choose cash or stock
- Leveraged upside for shareholders who elect to remain as shareholders
We intend to fund the transaction using a combination of equity and debt financing, in addition to Company cash and cash equivalents. We plan to invest equity amounts in excess of those new equity amounts contemplated by the Merger Agreement to facilitate the proposed transaction.
Based on discussions with equity co-investors, certain strategic partners, and debt financing sources, we are highly confident that financing can be arranged, which will include comparable debt sources and structures as the existing deal. We are currently working with Morgan Stanley & Co LLC ("Morgan Stanley") as our lead debt financing source to prepare financing, and have had discussions with other debt financing sources that have indicated a strong interest to finance our Acquisition Proposal. We have received from Morgan Stanley a "highly confident" letter related to our ability to raise the required debt financing for this transaction. Upon designation of the Investor Group as an Excluded Party we expect to finalize discussions with other financing sources on an expedited basis. Additionally, at the time of execution of definitive agreements with respect to our proposal, we expect to provide binding financing commitments from debt and equity financing sources in the form customary for a transaction of this type.
We have held discussions with some of Dell's largest shareholders, and we anticipate inviting them, certain of Dell's other shareholders and certain other strategic and financial partners to participate in the transaction as part of our group. We would also expect to encourage (but would not require) the MD Investors (as defined in the Merger Agreement) to participate in our transaction by rolling over equity held by the MD Investors.
We have significant experience structuring and consummating transactions of this nature, and we believe we can complete our due diligence review and negotiate the terms and conditions of a Superior Proposal (as defined in the Merger Agreement) quickly during the next phase of the process. Given our due diligence to date, we anticipate that the remaining due diligence would focus on key business, accounting, legal and regulatory matters and could be completed quickly, assuming full cooperation of Dell and its advisors. As part of this process, we would expect to have full access to the senior management team of Dell, certain other key employees, Dell's independent accountants and Dell's records, financial and operating data and material agreements (including the schedules attached to the Merger Agreement).
We are committed to continuing to pursue a transaction on the terms herein, which we believe will provide a more compelling value proposition to Dell and its shareholders than currently provided under the Merger Agreement. We believe that this proposal meets all applicable requirements under the Merger Agreement to enable the Special Committee to determine that the Investor Group is an Excluded Party in accordance with the Merger Agreement. Due to the considerable time commitment and uncertainty of outcome, we will continue our due diligence and work toward providing a definitive proposal, only upon receipt of written confirmation from the Special Committee of the Board of Directors that the Investor Group has been determined to be an Excluded Party in accordance with the Merger Agreement.
The proposal contained in this letter constitutes an indication of our interest in pursuing a transaction and does not constitute a binding offer, agreement or agreement to proceed with the transaction or to otherwise make a binding offer or agreement at any point in the future.
This indication of interest is submitted by us for review and consideration by the Special Committee of the Board of Directors of Dell on a confidential basis, and the existence of our discussions and this letter (other than such disclosure obligations outlined in the Merger Agreement) shall be kept strictly confidential in accordance with the terms of that certain letter agreement by and between Blackstone Management Partners L.L.C. and Dell, dated February 22, 2013.
This letter shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Delaware without regard to the conflicts of law principles thereof.
This proposal will expire at 5:00pm (NY time) on March 28 if you fail to provide the written confirmation discussed above prior to such time.
Please do not hesitate to contact any of the team members listed below with any questions.
BOULDER ACQUISITION CORP.
Name: Chinh E. Chu
Blackstone Management Partners L.L.C.
| Chinh E. Chu || || |
| Senior Managing Director || || |
Senior Managing Director
| || || |
Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC
| Robert A. Kindler || || |
| Vice Chairman || || |
| || || |
Kirkland & Ellis LLP
| David Fox || || |
| Partner || || |
| || || |
| || || |
cc: Evercore Group L.L.C
Carl C. Icahn
Icahn Enterprises LP
767 Fifth Avenue
New York, New York 10153
March 22, 2013
Special Committee of the Board of Directors of Dell Inc.
One Dell Way
Round Rock, Texas 78682
James B. Lee, Vice Chairman
270 Park Avenue
New York, New York 10017
William O. Hiltz
55 East 52nd Street
New York, New York 10055
Jeffrey J. Rosen
Michael A. Diz
Debevoise & Plimpton
919 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Re: Acquisition Proposal for Dell Inc. ("Dell")
Dear Members of the Special Committee of the Board of Directors of Dell and Advisors:
On February 5, 2013, Dell entered into a merger agreement (the "February 5 Merger Agreement") with certain entities affiliated with Silver Lake Partners and Michael S. Dell. Capitalized terms not otherwise defined in this letter shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the February 5 Merger Agreement. Section 5.3 of the February 5 Merger Agreement provides, among other things, that Dell, its Subsidiaries and its Representatives have the right to initiate, solicit, encourage and receive Acquisition Proposals with respect to Dell up to the No-Shop Period Start Date. This Acquisition Proposal, which is detailed below, is being delivered, as contemplated by the February 5 Merger Agreement, by Icahn Enterprises LP, and Carl C. Icahn, prior to the No-Shop Period Start Date.
Icahn Enterprises LP
We believe that you will agree that Icahn Enterprises is well able to provide the $1 billion cash equity capital (in addition to its existing $1 billion stock position in Dell), and that Mr. Icahn and his affiliates other than Icahn Enterprises are well able to provide the additional $3 billion cash equity capital, contemplated in this Acquisition Proposal, which constitutes an aggregate $5 billion equity commitment. In this regard we invite you to examine the public filings of Icahn Enterprises and to meet with us regarding any additional questions you may have. Further, we have excellent relationship with numerous large banking institutions and we are confident that we would be able to obtain the debt financing contemplated in our proposal. Although we are well known for the performance of our investment activities, over time we have found that our greatest returns have come from the control and ownership of portfolio companies. For example, in May 2012, Icahn Enterprises purchased a controlling interest in CVR Energy, Inc. (''CVR'') for an aggregate purchase price approximately $2 billion. As of March 11, 2013, based on the closing sale price of CVR stock and distributions since Icahn Enterprises acquired control, we had a gain of over $2 billion on our purchase of CVR.
Currently, the portfolio companies owned or controlled by Icahn Enterprises and Mr. Icahn include among others, the following:
| || || || || || || |
| || || || || || || |
| || || |
| || || |
Date of Initial Investment
| CVR Energy, Inc. || || || 82% || || || 2011 |
| Tropicana Entertainment Inc. || || || 67% || || || 2008 |
| West Point Home || || || 100% || || || 2004 |
| Federal Mogul Corporation || || || 78% || || || 2001 |
| Viskase Companies Inc. || || || 70% || || || 2001 |
| XO Holdings || || || 100% || || || 2001 |
| PSC Metals || || || 100% || || || 1998 |
| American Railcar Industries Inc. || || || 55% || || || 1994 |
| ACF Industries || || || 100% || || || 1984 |
| || || || || || || |
The Acquisition Proposal For Dell
As you know, on March 10, 2013 Icahn Enterprises entered into a confidentiality agreement with Dell and commenced due diligence in support of an Acquisition Proposal. On March 13, 2013, Jefferies LLC ("Jefferies"), as a representative of Icahn Enterprises, entered into a confidentiality agreement with Dell and commenced due diligence in support of an Acquisition Proposal. Further, on and after February 8, 2013, Southeastern Asset Management Inc. ("Southeastern") has publicly disclosed its desire to remain a shareholder of Dell, rather than participate in the merger contemplated by the February 5 Merger Agreement and has suggested that the merger be recast as a transaction under which Dell shareholders are provided with the opportunity to elect to continue to hold Dell shares or receive cash, at their option. T. Rowe Price has similarly opposed the February 5 Merger Agreement. For purposes of this proposal, Icahn Enterprises assumes that Southeastern and T. Rowe Price and other larger holders would, if provided the opportunity, support the proposal set forth below and agree to the matters set forth in the fourth bullet item of the proposal set forth below.
We hereby propose that we and Dell engage in the following merger transaction (the "Proposed Merger", and the surviving company of the Proposed Merger, the "Surviving Company"):
- Dell will obtain transaction funding composed of the following:
- $2.0 billion investment ($1 billion by Icahn Enterprises and $1 billion by Carl C. Icahn and his affiliates other than Icahn Enterprises) for the purchase of common shares of the Surviving Company (in addition to the shares currently owned by Icahn Enterprises and its affiliates) at a price of $15 per share, resulting in an additional 133 million shares being issued by the Surviving Company. As contemplated in the fifth bullet item below, Mr. Icahn and his affiliates other than Icahn Enterprises, are willing to commit an additional $2 billion of cash equity financing, for an aggregate $5 billion total equity commitment to this Acquisition Proposal.
- $7.4 billion of cash currently available at Dell.
- $1.712 billion in new factoring receivable facility (total factoring receivable facility of $3.0 billion).
- $5.218 billion in new debt.
- We understand that this Proposed Merger contemplates less total leverage on the Surviving Company than under the February 5 Merger Agreement.
- In connection with the Proposed Merger, Dell shareholders will be entitled to elect to receive either: (x) shares of the Surviving Company on a one-to-one basis with their current holdings; or (y) an aggregate of up to $15.65 billion in cash (the "Payment Funding") payable at a rate of $15 per share. If the Payment Funding is fully utilized this would result in 1.043 billion shares (58.1% of the current outstanding) being subject to the Proposed Merger. If shareholders electing to receive cash exceed the maximum number of shares that may be acquired with the Payment Funding, then such elections will be accepted on a pro rated basis. If electing shareholders are insufficient to utilize all of the Payment Funding, then the balance will be distributed to all of the remaining shareholders of the Surviving Company as a special dividend (the "Special Dividend").
- In addition to the Payment Funding, Icahn Enterprises anticipates that Dell would be required to pay the breakup fee under the February 5 Merger Agreement of $180 million, and that Dell would incur other deal fees and expenses in the Proposed Merger of approximately $500 million, for a maximum aggregate use of funds of approximately $16.33 billion.
- Neither Icahn Enterprises (which together with its affiliates, currently owns approximately 80 million shares of Dell), Southeastern (which publicly reports ownership of approximately 146.5 million shares of Dell), T. Rowe Price (which publicly reports ownership of approximately 82 million shares of Dell), nor other large holders that so agree (collectively with Icahn Enterprise, Southeastern, and T. Rowe Price, the "Rollover Holders"), would be eligible to elect to receive cash or shares in the Proposed Merger, but rather their existing common stock position in Dell would rollover into the Surviving Company. Rollover Holders would receive the Special Dividend, if any.
- Pursuant to the Proposed Merger, if all eligible existing Dell shareholders elect to receive cash, then approximately 58.1% of the currently outstanding Dell shares would be subject to the Proposed Merger and following the completion of the Proposed Merger, Icahn Enterprises and its affiliates would own 24.1% of the outstanding shares of the Surviving Company; Southeastern and its affiliates would own 16.6% of the outstanding shares of the Surviving Company; T. Rowe Price and its affiliates would own 9.3% of the Surviving Company and the remaining public shareholders would own 50% of the shares of the Surviving Company. The opportunity exists to increase the number of shares cashed out by non-Rollover Holders in the Proposed Merger, if the large holders agree with Icahn Enterprises to become Rollover Holders. Further, Mr. Icahn and his affiliates other than Icahn Enterprises would be willing to commit (in addition to the equity investment provided for in the first bullet item above) an additional $2 billion of equity capital in cash, in the event that Southeastern, T. Rowe Price or other existing large Dell shareholders do not agree to become Rollover Holders.
- Closing is anticipated to occur in July 2013.
This proposal contemplates the negotiation, execution and delivery of a definitive agreement (the "Definitive Agreement") containing the terms and conditions set forth herein, together with covenants, representations, warranties and indemnification provisions which are satisfactory to both parties (including, if so requested, limits on the election of merger consideration) and which are typical and standard in a transaction of this nature.
This letter is a non-binding proposal. Neither Icahn Enterprises, Mr. Icahn, their respective affiliates, officers or directors or representatives, have, nor will this proposal letter or any discussions or communications among the parties, create or constitute, any offer, obligation, contract, commitment or duty of any kind or character, to engage in, negotiate or enter into or complete a transaction. Only a Definitive Agreement executed and delivered by the parties thereto, shall be binding upon the parties.
We look forward to proceeding with negotiations as promptly as possible and are prepared, together with Jefferies, to commit the resources to develop a Definitive Agreement with you. In addition, we look forward to receiving your confirmation that the Special Committee has concluded that our proposal is or could reasonably be expected to result in, a Superior Proposal.
Very truly yours,
Carl C. Icahn
Icahn Enterprises LP
By: Icahn Enterprises GP Inc., its general partner
By: Carl C. Icahn, Chairman of the Board