The Buyer's Guide

Find it, buy it and tell us how you really feel.

85
Engadget
Score
An all-around great product that's among the best in its category. You'll almost certainly be happy.
85

An all-around great product that's among the best in its category. You'll almost certainly be happy.

How we score

The Engadget Score is a unique ranking of products based on extensive independent research and analysis by our expert editorial and research teams. The Global Score is arrived at only after curating hundreds, sometimes thousands of weighted data points (such as critic and user reviews).

Engadget Summary

I'll admit it's been a while since I've been in the market for a smoke detector. A cursory scan of Amazon, however, indicates an average price between $10 and $30, with combo smoke/carbon monoxide detectors landing at the higher end of that spectrum. In either case, it's a range the $99 Protect misses by a country mile. Of course, this isn't just any smoke detector. Like the Learning Thermostat before it, it's a bit of home electronics aimed at gadget nerds, and certainly Nest has managed to do a lot in an otherwise staid category.

It's a lovely object, so far as these things go, and its expressive center lighting and voice directions offer a lot more than the standard series of beeps: alerting you to emergencies, low batteries and even lighting your way at night. The button-based hush can save your eardrums and the smartphone alerts may well save some lives. For most, however, standard smoke detectors will likely still do the trick. Even though certain device idiosyncrasies can be a hassle, $99 still feels like a lot to pay, given the industry average. And for those living in larger homes, it's a price that'll add up fast.
Read Full Review

Scores

Engadget

85
 

User Reviews

100
CableMonkey
I wish these sold at 1/2 the price, but I still like them quite a bit.
100
Erichof
A gadget unicorn - Engadget
30
selesko
A poor product that's more likely to be frustrating than useful. - Engadget
Write a Review
 
85
Average Critic Score

Design and form factor

86
 

Ease of use

83
 

How It Stacks Up

58

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

60
 

User

68
 

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

Not yet scored
 

User

100
 

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

90
 

User

93
 
95

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

90
 

User

90
 
Similar Products

How It Stacks Up

58

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

60
 

User

68
 

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

Not yet scored
 

User

100
 

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

90
 

User

93
 
95

Engadget

Not yet scored
 

Critic

90
 

User

90
 
Video

Related Video

Inside Fox Sports’ World Cup production plans

Inside Fox Sports’ World Cup production plans

Posted   06.07.18

The Latest

ear iconeye icontext filevr