I know Ryan was just referring to the interviewer's observation that "there didn't seem to be any ipod killers", but I don't think the Gigabeat S is an iPod killer. Even if it is a superior device, there are so, so many obstacles it would have to overcome to topple the iPod.
1) It would need software as easy and elegant to use as iTunes with an equal amount of content available for purchase
2) It would need a major image boost. Its so hard to compete with Apple's marketing muscle. Who outside of this super gadget circle knows Toshiba makes mp3 players? My brother, my mom, and my grandparents sure don't.
3) It would have to have a sexy form factor that's easy to use. That plus pad looks more confusing and harder to use than apples simple and sleek scroll wheel.
I'm rooting for more competition in the mp3 player market, but it's so hard to match Apple's software, design, and ease of use.
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
I know Ryan was just referring to the interviewer's observation that "there didn't seem to be any ipod killers", but I don't think the Gigabeat S is an iPod killer. Even if it is a superior device, there are so, so many obstacles it would have to overcome to topple the iPod.
1) It would need software as easy and elegant to use as iTunes with an equal amount of content available for purchase
2) It would need a major image boost. Its so hard to compete with Apple's marketing muscle. Who outside of this super gadget circle knows Toshiba makes mp3 players? My brother, my mom, and my grandparents sure don't.
3) It would have to have a sexy form factor that's easy to use. That plus pad looks more confusing and harder to use than apples simple and sleek scroll wheel.
I'm rooting for more competition in the mp3 player market, but it's so hard to match Apple's software, design, and ease of use.