Elecom's "gear drive" keyboard prevents typing errors
By Thomas Ricker 
posted Sep 19th 2006 9:25AM
posted Sep 19th 2006 9:25AM
posted Sep 19th 2006 9:25AM
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
"just like Stevie and Paul"...you guys crack me up...lol
how does it work?
That has got to be the smallest spacebar I've ever seen! Is it even usable?
"That has got to be the smallest spacebar I've ever seen! Is it even usable?"
I have a feeling the stateside board won't have those extra keys between the alts that the Japanese boards do...
Um...hows about some deets?
"CHECK OUT THIS NEW KEYBOARD WITH GEAR DRIVE!!!"
Ooooooook...what is gear drive?
How does it prevent typing errors? Does it just make it more difficult to press the keys or something, to try and reduce fat finger syndrome? I find that most of my typing errors are not from hitting neighboring keys to what I wanted, but instead typing too fast and getting ahead of myself. Heh, maybe I'm just an inaccurate typist :-P
Ok, I kinda get this "gear drive" has gears under each key..... but how does this prevent typing errors? By making the jeys so hard to push down you reduce your typing speed to a crawl? Kinda like one fingered pre-school typing?
Ok, yeah, I guess that would prevent typos.... and also waste entire days of time.
Ivr got to gt me onew of theaes!
Perhaps this prevents adjacent keys from depressing when the desired key is pressed, avoiding typos from accidentally brushing the neighboring keys?
David
That's what I was thinking too... It'd somehow not let you accidentally press two keys next to each other at the same time...
I guess it prevents typing errors by only depressing the key if it's hit square in the middle.
I think the space bar is small because it's a Japanese keyboard, look at the extra keys. Plus Japenese text doesn't use as many spaces.
i think the idea is that it firms up the keys.
try this at home kids!
put a finger on the corner of a key and wiggle it. The key moves. Now press down. it has a bit of a sticky feeling to it.
Now what these little gears do is even everything out. So now when you put a finger on the corner of a key is doesnt wobble! Even better is that when you push down on a corner, the key doesn't go down corner first, it all goes down level because each cog has to be at the same height.
I happen to think its a great idea, but i can also see keys breaking a lot more often. and my monthly act of pulling all my keys of to clean out the breadcrumbs will become a bit difficult...
Think about when them breadcrumbs mash in the gears. Don't get me wrong, but even the cleanest person leaves part of themselves in the keys...
oh cos that wouldn't make gaming an absolute whore of a task... when i want to go forward and strafe left.. for example..
from the drawings, it looks like the gears make you press the exact center of the key in order to fully depress it.
The gear system allows for the key to be pressed no matter where on the key you press. You can press it on a corner, but the gears will make the key travel down at the same rate, and the button will press down on the sensor.
I would bet the little gears would get gummed up with all the crap that gets down into keyboards. Its a good idea but preobally reall bad for gaming you know?
I'm typing this on a BenQ A122 Keyboard, and this is the nicest keyboard I've ever used. It has a similar idea to the gear thing, in that the keys are cushioned by a crossbar that makes sure the key is pressed straight down, even when you push on the corner. I think they called it X-Key or something. The keys have a lower profile, similar to laptop keys as well.
Someone told me this keyboard was designed by BMW. If you ever see a BenQ A122 in stores, I reccomend getting it without hesitation.
I think jc is right. I have a cheap, crappy Dell keyboard at work, and whenever I press a key *slightly* off-center, it binds.
Yeah, that's about as over-engineered a keyboard as you'd ever want. I can certainly see the benefits while tooling around on livejournal, or something.
will, you have such fat fingers that you use the same one to press left and forwards? - just strange... i use separate fingers, and always catch the E key, which if playing bf2 is a bit of a sh** cos i fall 5,000 feet from my heli.
Hey guys, I can make the worlds best typing keyboard!
All you got to do is make large, square spaced out querty keyboards to minimize the probability of an error!
Also, even then, I personally feel that errors are inevitable and i am not sold by their marketing gimmick.
If i use that keyboard and lightning type, Im sure to make some errors... like for example, i have made three errors in writing this passage and had to backspace it...
Just some lame comments that i hope is constructive.
Gerald
How is it possible to misspell "qwerty"? Please tell me you have an AZERTY keyboard, or some other non-English based keyboard?
koan
I still think my 16 year old IBM Model M is better. :]
Hear, hear!
The Model M is (probably) the best keyboard ever made! You either love it or hate it! :)
Will it prevent you from posting crappy blog titles!
OMFG just kidding! LMNOP!
The keys are motorized! they move down in order when windows automatically enters text, kind of like a player piano!
Well, most of my typing errors comes from not hitting the right key so I doubt this will help. I mean, if I press "I" by misstaked but wanted a "O" instead, the keyboard won't know.
Well, you could always just run it through ye old google search engine if you're so curious. In actuallity, the four sides of the keyboard are linked, so that when one side of the key is pushed, the other sides are lowered along with it. It shouldn't reduce typing errors, it's just another way for the keys to be mounted.
Actually, the spacebar is normal width. It's just that everything else is HUGE. The entire keyboard is the size of a desk. Look at the size of the fingers in the diagram. Those crazy Japanese.
This would be good for gaming if used correctly. All of a sudden, pressure sensitive keystrokes are possible.
Actually, my keyboard broke a couple months ago (A damn fine keyboard too, I sanded off all the keys so it was really a DIY Das Keyboard) so I had to dig through a closet to find a keyboard. Lo and behold, in my dad's closet I find three brand new Japanese keyboards. They're pretty hard to get used to, with the keys, especially the spacebar, being so insanely small, and with like four or five keys that don't do anything. Plus the question mark key is moved to the side one...and the number symbols are all moved to the side one, despite they're labelling. But I'm used to it by now. I'm just lucky I don't play games on this beast. eMachines for the win!
Very cool
I explained how this works on digg, if anyone is interested:
http://digg.com/hardware/How_Elecom_s_gear_drive_keyboard_prevents_typing_errors#c3120999
interesting.