Apple patents systems to warn of impending dropped calls, track down your keys
By Paul Miller 
posted May 29th 2008 12:26PM
posted May 29th 2008 12:26PM
[Thanks, Mark]
posted May 29th 2008 12:26PM
A look back on popular stories from today in a specific year.
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
I just filed for a patent on teeth brushing, hair combing and nail clipping.
Replying to a comment I've written is copywritten beholden to myself and you are expressly forbidden to do so without explicit written permission.
The copyright office needs to be completely revamped.
so are you gonna sue me??? ;)
Well I copyright the copyright office so I own your copyrights!
I consider myself an apple fanboy and even I'm getting tired of seeing "apple patents so and so" 2-3 times every single day.....
Behold the new iPhone in the pic.
At first, I thought they patented the cross section of a tree.
i was thinking the same thing.. or they were sounding lake depths...
or calculating the age of tree
Hmmm...I wonder if they'll use this technology to deflect Apple hardware's constant wireless connection issues on cell towers & hubs.
Lol@philippe
Gtfo@Lol@ comments
Man, patents are becoming a new form of currency. I'm sure many of us have azz loads of patentable ideas but no "old form of currency" to afford to patent and lock em down. Apple (or other) should start a "PATENT UNIVERSITY" (i.e. PU ;^) in which they would hire people (part time) and, well you get where this is going...
u still need money to patent your ideas though
hahahaha!
wait... what?
not if they back u at the university, but then take a cut of the profits you make.
I guess its nice they they would put some thought into this technology... but instead of telling me they will be dropped, what about simply making it so my calls dont get dropped at all ?
It's really simple? Oh I don't think so, otherwise it'd already be implemented.
instead of telling me my call is about to fail, why not have a power-boost to the antenna?
Is anyone really so confused after they drop a call that they need their phone to tell them what happened?
Being able to find your bluetooth headset and/or keys is all well and good, but what are you gonna do if you lose the phone itself.... just sayin'
Rick, I saw you posted a while back about having "No Profile Found", but you seem to have gotten a profile on here somehow. Can I ask how you did it? After 70 something posts (not counting my 4 'test' posts), I still can't figure it out. I've tried allowing all cookies, even the ads! What's the magic? Thanks a ton...!
Awesome idea! What should this be called? Hmm, I know... we'll call it the "iSignal Strength Indicator"! And we'll let users know how strong the signal is by drawing different sized bars on the screen, and what else, oh yeah, we'll just have to go back in time and destroy every cell phone ever made so that there isn't any prior art covering this invention. Yeah, totally new idea!
This technology, already implemented, has been available for over 5 years. How the hell can they patent it when it's already been invented, produced, and sold? This has got to be a joke...
they can file for a patent on anything they want. there is prior art on this though, and it may or may not be rejected. our patent system is very broken, there should be a large monetary penalty when a patent is rejected for prior art, would cut down on these sorts of filings.
My calls on the iphone (att) drop when switching towers, all the time
dude...you need this bad
could be the gun in your mouth interfering with signal
Well, now Apple will alert you with a beep about 1/2 second before your call drops off. That's helpful, isn't it? Why should they fix their sub-par phone, when they can just let you know your call is about to be dropped.
If you look to the right of the diagram there's 2 officially leaked images of the iPhone. Na, why would they put a generic phone to demonstrate their patent instead of their iPhone... Will Apple eventually sell this to other manufacturers (if they want to purchase the rights)?
WIth all the things apple seems to patent that are way out there and off course, yet the iphone patents remained under wraps (mostly) until right before it's announcement, ever wonder if they apply for random patents to keep the rumor mill running full speed as free marketing? Just an idea... They do think differently...
excuse my ignorance. But how exactly does a bluetooth system locate lost keys?
"You are currently using AT&T. Your call will be dropped in 3...2..."
WOW How cutting edge a way to tell how much signal you have.
Oh wait like a signal bar that was cutting edge on my Motorola V50 years ago.
Do we really have to be reminded on daily basis how much of a patent troll Apple is ?
This patent makes a whole lot of sense given that U.S. iPhone users are stuck with AT&T crap service. This feature will get a LOT of use. Even though it's redundant because you can already tell when your call is going to get dropped - once the voice starts cutting out and getting garbly, it's only a matter of time my friend.
AT&T's crap service as compared to, say, Sprint?
Seriously?
floppy bull's eye FTW
People, really, really need to do some reading and learn how patents work. 'Prior art' does not mean 'anything which is vaguely related to the same concept' such as a signal bar which was laughably pointed out above or no-one would ever be able to patent anything, which is quite clearly not the intent of the patent system.
You can't seriously compare a signal strength indicator and a program that says go x ----> that way to get stronger signal as the same thing. The innovation from one to the other is clear.
Come on now...is that innovation or evolution? The idea of a patent is to reward innovation; ie. an idea most people in society would never have thought of. You don't reward ALL ideas, you reward truly revolutionary, innovative ideas. A vocal signal strength indicator is a logical extension of the visual one and doesn't deserve patent protection.
This isn't very useful unless the towers are made to boost the signal right at the moment that the call is about to drop. Otherwise the warning would come right at the moment that the call drops, by then we already know what happened.
I can see it now, all the iPhone-heads walking around talking and whenever their phone beeps, they'll change direction without missing a beat so that they don't lose signal.
'Course the fun part is going to be coming up with a device that puts out the same tone and then getting a bunch of people to walk through the crowd with an iPhone user and start beeping. Get the guy bouncing around the sidewalk - for every change of direction, you get a point - the one with the most points wins. :)
See how long you can get them jumping around the area before they notice that it's not their phone beeping.
Lose all your points if you get them to step into the street however - we don't play to win that hard!
you my good sir win period
that was to Bill in Racine
Isnt At&t supposed to be the network with the fewest dropped calls? I bet they would hate to advertise a feature that basically lets the user know that their product is going to fail, and by product i mean network
I was thinking of submitting a patent for a new spinal column to the Patent Office.
Then I could give myself a pat on the back for a pat. on the back.
Engadget really needs to limit IP related reporting to those who actually understand the terminology. Patent Application != Patent, but that's okay, we'll say it's patented so that people can get up-in-arms about "oh, now they are patenting the wheel!" about something that hasn't even hit an examiner's desk yet.
Man take a "claim the world" approach when submitting an application, leaving it to the examiner to tell them where/how they need to limit. I would bet that, if this actually gets issued as a patent (not likely), the claims will look a lot different than they do today.
Could someone please send me a patent application number on the bluetooth one so i can look it up. i looked pretty hard on google's patent search and couldnt find it.