Crafty iPhone dock mod supports iPhone 3G, saves $29
By Thomas Ricker 
posted Jul 21st 2008 7:57AM
posted Jul 21st 2008 7:57AM
Please note: If you're a current Engadget commenter, you do not need to re-register. Simply login and you will be prompted to select a username.
Diy WORKS. More people should try it! A bit of sandpaper could also make this fellow's handiwork a bit neater too.
Actually, I'm quite impressed with his handiwork. Sanding plastic is no easy task.
Are there really that many iPhone first-gen people who got 3Gs? That's like someone going out and trading in their 20GB 360 for one with 120GB and HDMI.... you wouldn't figure there'd be many... oh well, maybe it's just me
I think it's just you.
@Kinger
No, you're right, and he has done a great job with that dremel. I meant a fine sandpaper just to smooth it out.
My new dock cost me £19, but my chargeable time costs even more, so buying the dock made more sense to me... but a good idea for those with time on their hands, who already own a dremmel tool and the skill.
If you've got the time and the equipment you could even knock up a 3G Iphone and save all your money!
thanks for the comments guys! i posted a few more pics here showing
the tools and how i did the work:
http://web.mac.com/goulwen.pele/Handcrafted/Bidouille_de_Dock_pour_iphone.html
Can i use my old iphone's silicon case on a 3g iphone?
i think it might be fine if it's silicone but it wont work with hard shell. the new 3G is a bit bigger than the last one..
Diy works - More people should try it! A bit of sandpaper could also make this fellow's handiwork a bit neater too.
Sorry.
Seriously, Apple could've make the 3G compatible... But they knew they were passing by a big source of money by making it uncompatible with all the previous existing docks.
I feel that Apple has become much, much more greedy than Microsoft.
A look at the prices of the Zune 2.0 software VS the Touch 2.0 software will tell you that.
I wouldn't be basing, and possibly compromising the design of my most valuable new products based on whether it could fit in an accessory for an old, first-gen model. It may suck for early adopters (me included), but unfortunately it's part of the price you pay.
Although I do agree that removing the dock from the new package is a bit annoying - the price drop of the new unit far outweighs this!
Except there is no price drop... The 8GB version ends up costing you 560 dollars in the end.
I write online reviews.
Over 2000 people read my review the day of the iPhone's 3g launch where I gave it 3/5 stars due to the poor battery life and the incompatibility with previous iphone docks.
I am glad to report that I convinced over 600 people to wait for the Blackberry Bold and the HTC touch Diamond.
"I am glad to report that I convinced over 600 people to wait for the Blackberry Bold and the HTC touch Diamond."
Sure you did.
@Flashpoint
LOLZ
Apple is the most #*$&%*( money mongering company in existance. FUCK the customer. Rake in the cash. I mean, everyone wants to make cash, but you don't have to make customers bend over and take it up the ass.
Completely agree! Everyone seems so pro apple and anti microsoft but honestly they rape you for eeeeeeverything, I definitely understand turning a profit but apple is worse then most companies out there in squeezing every last dime out of you. Someday the mindless zombies that adore stevie so well will come to their senses, you know when they begin to start thinking for themselves.
its a real shame but thats how many companies are going these days. you barely get a cradle with most phones nowadays and they are all pretty prone to scratches.
When it comes to apple products, if you even just remove the crazy packaging off the products you could save 10 bucks right there. Its nice and all but i don't really need a nice box if all i want is the nice product.
Yes, but at least when Apple "rapes" you, you tend to enjoy it...
The failure to include a dock, and not even have them available for those willing to shell over the $29 is just lame, Apple.
Apple customers like it up the ass. They whine, and then come back for more...ooooooh...iphone 3G!!
you know god forbid a company actually tries to turn a profit!
All he did was sand down the bloody dock lol
But its apple! and apple is hip and cool and totally in style!
I make docks for my phones out of lego..... would i get a mention? Probably not because they are windows mobile devices :D
@ThePengwin - I'll bet that other tech site with a lego fetish would post your lego phone docks, windows mobile or not. ;-)
Windows you said? Bah, I don't wanna see them..
he thought of it, did it and you didn't, the end
Sounds like the only way to avoid Cupertino's nickeling and diming, to us.
Yeah I am sure that they purposely designed the new iPhone fatter just for that reason.
@Fernando:
Yes. You don't honestly think that a company like Apple couldn't think ahead and design the dock in such a way that it'd fit future iterations of the product, right?
I did the exact same thing on Friday but with a file and a wire cutter. The File did a great job with the rough side and finish up with the fine side. Came out pretty good.
Ironic that Al Gore sits on the board of a company which consistently forces consumers to re-purchase accessories that can and should be re-used.
Note to you tree-hugging, latte slinging MacHeads, that factory in China stamping "new" iPhone docks is adding more to global warming than all of the Hummers on the planet.
I don't think 100 iPhone Dock stamping factories could be close worse than all of the Hummers on the planet...
I have a universal dock, and the iPhone 3G fits fine in dock adapter for the original iphone. No sanding needed.
What ever happened to those dock connectors?
Sounds like yet another stupid detail that apple uses to take advantage of their dumb dumb customers! People wake up and smell the cupertino valley bs! Their computers are now nothing but a crappy intel and a low end nvidia vid card with insanely to much ram for an average of 300% more than the parts cost! They hate their customers, but for some reason, like religion, people believe in this company. They support and defend this company as if apple has paid them to buy their products! They all suck, sure they may have design appeal, but if you look you will find everything they make cheaper and better if you open your eyes.. Apple sux....
What is everybody's hard-on for a dock anyways? Is it really that important? I've got a first-gen iPhone and I think I've used the dock less than five times in the 8 months since I bought it. Is it really that big of a deal to pick up the cord and slide it into the phone?
One-handed connection of the iPhone to the computer?
A more organized desk than a bunch of loose USB cables laying around?
Not a big deal, and I don't use the dock on all my devices, but I can think of reasons why people would prefer them over a loose cable.
Different strokes for different folks, as they used to say...
What is everybody's hard-on for a dock anyways? Is it really that important? I've got a first-gen iPhone and I think I've used the dock less than five times in the 8 months since I bought it. Is it really that big of a deal to pick up the cord and slide it into the phone?
I just told you!
Just told me what?
I imagine if you're one-handed, it would be a big deal. Same if you're OCD about neatness on your real desktop.
You must be young; young people have a tendency to believe that just because they don't see value or need in a particular product or feature that anyone else who does is a whiner or something. If you don't use a case
Enough people are complaining about the lack of the dock to suggest that your point of view is not the only valid one. ;-)
They have these over at the ATT store here in maryland. (the modded ones)
PG!
I'd gladly buy another manufactures products if it had the same elegance.. style & reliability as an apple... seriously who is a contender.. i have my choice of windows (computing and mobile) or blackberry OS.. do they even compare?
any ideas on when there will be a solution for all the bricked (as far as Iphone 3g is concerned) old chargers that are based on firewire charging pin arrangement?
@ Brad
I'm not sure what kind of "solution" you're looking for...I mean, buying an adapter will be the same as buying a new cable.
thanks for the comments guys! i posted a few more pics here showing the tools and how i did the work:
http://web.mac.com/goulwen.pele/Handcrafted/Bidouille_de_Dock_pour_iphone.html
It's more than just a new cable because the system that I have setup for my car to charge and play music through the car speakers via a single dock connector is a firewire based charger. Basically I'll have to break open my car radio and purchase a new ipod system unless a "solution" is found. Either that, or I'll just have to lose the option to charge in the car.