Circuit City CEO details bankruptcy proceedings, admits possibility of liquidation
Things have been a little rocky (to say the very least) for Circuit City since it filed for bankruptcy protection back in November of last year, and now the acting president and CEO has sent out a letter informing a select few (or the world, as the case may be) of what exactly is going / could be going on. In short, the company has just recently "filed with the Bankruptcy Court a motion that seeks Court approval for a process that formally puts the company up for sale." There's a lot of fluff after that, but the long and short of it is this: a sale could be approved before an auction begins (and its working mighty hard to make sure that happens), but if that doesn't go down by the 16th, the outfit will be " forced to liquidate" soon. We're not trying to be overly dramatic or anything, so we'll encourage you to read the entire, soul-soothing email posted just after the break before going into full-on panic mode.
[Thanks, Anonymous]
01/09/2009
Message from Jim Marcum
Team,
This week, the company filed with the Bankruptcy Court a motion that seeks Court approval for a process that formally puts the company up for sale. A sale could include as a "going concern" (meaning that the acquirer would continue to operate Circuit City as a business), pieces of the company as separate business units (such as markets, regions, or operating units) or as individual assets (such as the sale of inventory). The motion was made public today in advance of a hearing to approve the motion later today.
As we told the Court in our motion, we are engaged in active and significant discussions with more than one interested party regarding a sale of the company. The discussions with each of these parties have focused on a "going concern" transaction. In particular, interested parties are contemplating providing Circuit City with financing to complete a reorganization through a stand-alone plan and/or purchasing all or substantially all of our assets. At this point, the parties have substantially completed due diligence and are in negotiations with us and our major stakeholders in order to finalize such a transaction.
Let me back up and explain in greater detail what this filing means, what led us to this point and what it means going forward.
One of the original requirements of our debtor-in-possession (DIP) credit facility was to have a sale or auction process occur no later than early March if no other resolution had been reached for the company at that time.
Since that time, as we have discussed with you, we have worked diligently to pursue various alternatives for our business – a stand-alone reorganization plan, transactions with strategic partners and sales of all or certain parts of our business.
As we have worked, the world has continued to change. Poor macroeconomic conditions are further impacting our business and our vendors' confidence. Some of our vendors, including some key merchandise vendors, are still unwilling to relax their strict terms and have not provided meaningful credit. Securing better vendor credit and terms is essential for Circuit City's survival.
Faced with these conditions, after consulting with our advisors, the Creditors' Committee and our Lenders, in December we agreed with our DIP lenders to move the auction process for the company's assets forward to this week.
Based on the negotiations with the interested parties that I mentioned above as well as discussions with our vendors and lenders, we are optimistic that we can successfully complete a transaction. Of course, nothing is certain and we can't provide any assurance or guarantee that a transaction will be completed.
A number of outcomes are possible. We could reach a sale agreement and have it approved by the Court before the auction starts on the 13th. These discussions or the auction could result in an approved sale agreement before the hearing on the 16th. Or, we could reach an agreement with the DIP lenders to amend our agreement and change or delay the timing of the hearing on the 16th. To the extent that these efforts are unsuccessful, we will need to pursue a more dire path for the company.
There's no way to sugar-coat this, so out of respect for you I'm going to be completely honest: if no sale agreement is approved, then the company will be forced to liquidate beginning soon after the hearing on the 16th. I'm sure this news will shock many of you because we're doing the right things to move our company forward and are making solid progress in improving our operations. In fact, we've been able to accomplish the following:
As planned, in the months of November and December, we completed liquidation sales in and subsequently closed 155 domestic stores that were underperforming or were no longer a strategic fit for the company.
We have achieved significant selling, general and administrative expense reductions as we restructure our business to align operations with the smaller national store base and have implemented more stringent expense controls.
We retained DJM Realty Services, Inc. to negotiate reduced rent for leased properties and to sell owned properties.
And probably most importantly
The company's sales trends improved significantly during the last two weeks of December, and the combination of the improvement in sales and focus on gross margin has enabled us to continue to operate well within the operating budget required by the amended DIP credit agreement.
What are the next steps?
I want you to understand that the management team has worked tirelessly to avoid coming to this point. In fact, the reason I am communicating this via email, instead more personally, is that Bruce Besanko and I will be on the road trying to get support from our banks and our vendors for a deal.
Over the next week we will continue working with interested parties. In the meantime, we've got to stay focused. We must continue to show improvements to the parties who are interested in buying the company and to our vendors and lenders. The auction process is set to conclude at the court hearing on January 16th, so we will soon know whether or not someone will step forward and purchase the company. While we would all prefer it to be sold in its entirety, we cannot say for certain that will happen.
If you receive questions from our guests, your families, friends or acquaintances, please continue to use the Q&A document provided on ccity.com. This news does not change the answers to those questions or the way we respond to customers. Again, the only thing that I can ask of you is to continue to work hard through this major distraction so we can continue to show improvement in our results to any potential purchasers.
Unfortunately, we won't be able to discuss the outcome until the auction process concludes on the 16th. I apologize in advance that I won't be able to discuss it further.
Thank you,
Jim
[Thanks, Anonymous]
01/09/2009
Message from Jim Marcum
Team,
This week, the company filed with the Bankruptcy Court a motion that seeks Court approval for a process that formally puts the company up for sale. A sale could include as a "going concern" (meaning that the acquirer would continue to operate Circuit City as a business), pieces of the company as separate business units (such as markets, regions, or operating units) or as individual assets (such as the sale of inventory). The motion was made public today in advance of a hearing to approve the motion later today.
As we told the Court in our motion, we are engaged in active and significant discussions with more than one interested party regarding a sale of the company. The discussions with each of these parties have focused on a "going concern" transaction. In particular, interested parties are contemplating providing Circuit City with financing to complete a reorganization through a stand-alone plan and/or purchasing all or substantially all of our assets. At this point, the parties have substantially completed due diligence and are in negotiations with us and our major stakeholders in order to finalize such a transaction.
Let me back up and explain in greater detail what this filing means, what led us to this point and what it means going forward.
One of the original requirements of our debtor-in-possession (DIP) credit facility was to have a sale or auction process occur no later than early March if no other resolution had been reached for the company at that time.
Since that time, as we have discussed with you, we have worked diligently to pursue various alternatives for our business – a stand-alone reorganization plan, transactions with strategic partners and sales of all or certain parts of our business.
As we have worked, the world has continued to change. Poor macroeconomic conditions are further impacting our business and our vendors' confidence. Some of our vendors, including some key merchandise vendors, are still unwilling to relax their strict terms and have not provided meaningful credit. Securing better vendor credit and terms is essential for Circuit City's survival.
Faced with these conditions, after consulting with our advisors, the Creditors' Committee and our Lenders, in December we agreed with our DIP lenders to move the auction process for the company's assets forward to this week.
Based on the negotiations with the interested parties that I mentioned above as well as discussions with our vendors and lenders, we are optimistic that we can successfully complete a transaction. Of course, nothing is certain and we can't provide any assurance or guarantee that a transaction will be completed.
A number of outcomes are possible. We could reach a sale agreement and have it approved by the Court before the auction starts on the 13th. These discussions or the auction could result in an approved sale agreement before the hearing on the 16th. Or, we could reach an agreement with the DIP lenders to amend our agreement and change or delay the timing of the hearing on the 16th. To the extent that these efforts are unsuccessful, we will need to pursue a more dire path for the company.
There's no way to sugar-coat this, so out of respect for you I'm going to be completely honest: if no sale agreement is approved, then the company will be forced to liquidate beginning soon after the hearing on the 16th. I'm sure this news will shock many of you because we're doing the right things to move our company forward and are making solid progress in improving our operations. In fact, we've been able to accomplish the following:
As planned, in the months of November and December, we completed liquidation sales in and subsequently closed 155 domestic stores that were underperforming or were no longer a strategic fit for the company.
We have achieved significant selling, general and administrative expense reductions as we restructure our business to align operations with the smaller national store base and have implemented more stringent expense controls.
We retained DJM Realty Services, Inc. to negotiate reduced rent for leased properties and to sell owned properties.
And probably most importantly
The company's sales trends improved significantly during the last two weeks of December, and the combination of the improvement in sales and focus on gross margin has enabled us to continue to operate well within the operating budget required by the amended DIP credit agreement.
What are the next steps?
I want you to understand that the management team has worked tirelessly to avoid coming to this point. In fact, the reason I am communicating this via email, instead more personally, is that Bruce Besanko and I will be on the road trying to get support from our banks and our vendors for a deal.
Over the next week we will continue working with interested parties. In the meantime, we've got to stay focused. We must continue to show improvements to the parties who are interested in buying the company and to our vendors and lenders. The auction process is set to conclude at the court hearing on January 16th, so we will soon know whether or not someone will step forward and purchase the company. While we would all prefer it to be sold in its entirety, we cannot say for certain that will happen.
If you receive questions from our guests, your families, friends or acquaintances, please continue to use the Q&A document provided on ccity.com. This news does not change the answers to those questions or the way we respond to customers. Again, the only thing that I can ask of you is to continue to work hard through this major distraction so we can continue to show improvement in our results to any potential purchasers.
Unfortunately, we won't be able to discuss the outcome until the auction process concludes on the 16th. I apologize in advance that I won't be able to discuss it further.
Thank you,
Jim

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)
dauset @ Jan 9th 2009 1:31PM
The end is near.
bill cant fart @ Jan 9th 2009 2:01PM
...nigh
blackman @ Jan 10th 2009 10:37AM
yessir
so the best deals should come after the 16th
i used to work there, may have to go pick up a flatscreen
Platinum_Skeet @ Jan 9th 2009 1:32PM
Hopefully it'll be kinda like Montgomery Wards liquidation I got a Dreamcast for $100 when that was going on...
dejal @ Jan 9th 2009 5:43PM
Don't bring up M/W. M/W bought Mass. chain Lechmeres sometimes before they went belly up. The local Lechmeres had some come-on where you opened a store account and got a discount on your first purchase. I did, I bought and never received a bill and also never recieved the store card). Time goes on and I forgot about it. Get a letter from a collection agency. Go to the store and pay it in person (never got a bill). I get a receipt.
Fax the collection agency the reciept. M/W goes toes up. 6 months later get a letter from a different collection agency. M/W had sold accounts receivables to GE Credit. GE wants money. Fax the reciept. Get another letter. This happened about 4 or 5 times over a couple of years over 3 or 4 collection agencys. GE sells accounts receivables to someone else.
Process starts all over again. Finally I get all the credit bureau reports from all the CB agencys showing bill was paid years ago.. E-Mail a copy of the credit reports to EVERY E-mail address at some collection agency in Boston. Within 10 minutes get an e-mail back saying we will look into it. Hour later get another says it's all taken care of. That was a few years ago.
Whatever you do, DON'T USE a store credit card. If you have a bill and pay it and the store closes and the payment doesn't make the books you could end up having the fun I had. I have no idea why a store receipt printed at a register showing my store account # and the dollar amount never made it into what GE took over.
pika2000 @ Jan 9th 2009 1:32PM
It's kinda sad seeing these local retailers going away. First CompUSA, now Circuitcity. In my area, the only guy left is Bestbuy. Having only 1 big electronic retailer locally doesn't sound too good going forward. My local Bestbuy already charge a lot of things higher than actual MSRP.
STINK @ Jan 9th 2009 1:36PM
The Best Buy around me looks like a flea market inside. Not a good sign.
Terry Thomas @ Jan 9th 2009 2:29PM
PIKA2000:
The names you listed are NOT local retailers. They are national chains.
A local retailer would be "Main Street Computers", etc.
I should know, I am one.
Terry Thomas
President
PC Tech
Atlanta, Georgia USA
ferrisUML @ Jan 9th 2009 2:45PM
Thats a great idea! Lets keep allowing a handful of internet sites that operate with little to no overhead because they're mostly overseas and/or employee a fraction of the people of a retail chain to shutdown our local retail chains. First it was the mom and pops vs Walmart, now its evolving to everyone with a retail outlet (and the associated overhead) vs internet only. The weakest will (and are) die first, but the rest will follow.
When we people learn that we're selling ourselves out to save a buck.
ferrisUML @ Jan 9th 2009 2:53PM
Stupid comments system...Pika, that wasn't directed at you.
pika2000 @ Jan 9th 2009 3:05PM
Terry: You're right. I meant to say local B&M stores.
OneLove @ Jan 9th 2009 3:47PM
@Terry Thomas: Your name is Terry Thomas, really? I wonder what you look like? :)
@pika2000: Best Buy has always been charging higher than most. However, in my area they are doing something that I really wouldn't expect; they now match walmarts prices!, even the prices online. (Walmart doesn't even match its own online prices. lol)
michgar @ Jan 9th 2009 5:08PM
There's this awesome retailer called "the internets", it's totally better than even the best of Best Buys.
Boarderwoot @ Jan 9th 2009 1:34PM
Full on panic mode? I'll be waiting in anticipation to finally snag a d90 for a price i can afford and then weep because then the only local option to buy electronics would be BB...
Chris @ Jan 9th 2009 1:36PM
It's a shame that CC is going under. In the northeast, Tweeter home entertainment has gone under, COMPUSA, and now Circuit City. That leaves Best Buy for electronics. That's really too bad...
Competition is good for all...whether we like the store/company behind it or not.
216 @ Jan 9th 2009 1:40PM
CC's Liquidation is sad but inevitable. If anything, instead of accepting the idea that Best Buy is now your only electronics alternative, begin to accept the idea of purchasing ALL of your stuff from online places like Newegg or Tigerdirect or Amazon. Change the game up force Best Buy to HAVE to compete, not just exist.
Christian @ Jan 9th 2009 1:49PM
100000X AGREED!
Gaucho @ Jan 9th 2009 2:58PM
100002X AGREED!
Circuit city always had those $10 gift cards for buying games there. . . that will be missed.
David W @ Jan 9th 2009 3:14PM
*blinks*
uh...Best Buy price matches...how does it get more competitive than that?
tuaamin13 @ Jan 9th 2009 5:19PM
Bestbuy doesn't price match online retailers. They also don't pricematch freebies, like the giftcards, usually.
Matt @ Jan 9th 2009 3:48PM
How do price matches work when you're the only company? What do you do, compare the prices of the things with the same price?
ProfessorKaos @ Jan 9th 2009 8:47PM
I buy 80 percent form newegg, only use BB or CC for things like Blank DVD-R's. THumbs up
dookieshoo @ Jan 9th 2009 10:08PM
Well, in Houston, we also 2 (count them), 2 Frys and a huge MicroCenter. They are both doing well and don't seem to be going anywhere. And don't forget about Target, WalMart, Costco and so on and so forth.
The best thing about CircuitCity is/was that they will take back just about any merchandise you brought back. No questions asked (at least in my experience with them).
Dominic @ Jan 9th 2009 1:44PM
Wow guys....I don't think i would ever go to circuit city for anything. Theres still costco and Frys,Bestbuy and even online like buy.com and amazon, also I bestbuys prices might be higher than circuit city's were, but at least when you went in there it you didnt have to walk in 10 circles before you found anyone who knew what a cat5 cable was.
Mike @ Jan 9th 2009 1:50PM
Probably because Circuit City doesn't sell Cat 5 cables.
(We have CAT6)
joe23521 @ Jan 9th 2009 1:47PM
I wish one of the big online retailers would buy CC and open some physical stores.
z0phi3l @ Jan 9th 2009 1:50PM
CC can go as far as I'm concerned, crap stores, crap prices.
At least here we have a BestBuy if I'm really desperate or I can hit up Costco or BJs for great deals on the same electronics, and if I'm not in any hurry, there's also Newegg and Tiger Direct.
sully810 @ Jan 9th 2009 1:56PM
I love BJs! Wait...there's a store named BJ's?
Munky @ Jan 10th 2009 1:58PM
Yeah. I saw a picture of a BJ's Electronics next to a Dick's Sporting Goods. Pretty funny.
bandigolo @ Jan 9th 2009 1:51PM
spend those gift cards!
MadMike @ Jan 9th 2009 1:54PM
What's killing the Big Box retailers is the Internet. I can find Product X on the internet for 30% cheaper on average with shipping. People have given up on the "Have it Now" for "wait a few days and save $50."
Internet operations have almost no overhead. They buy at bulk discounts and they make bulk shipping deals, and sometimes they drop-ship directly from the manufacturer so they don't have to store the product.
A friend of mine ran a computer sales company from his 1100 square foot 2 bedroom apartment. He literally had a bunch of metal racks in the spare room, filled with parts, a bench, chair, light and a collocated server in the Turks and Caicos islands. He sold stuff for HUGE discounts and made a killing. His only overhead was a $175/mo server & and bandwidth fee, $500/mo rent, $200 worth of utilities and shipping to him on non drop-shipped items. His first year of profits was like $70,000. The second year he was making $200k+ free and clear.
Coolty @ Jan 9th 2009 2:19PM
I'd like your friends email address. Then I too can make millions doing nothing.
holycow @ Jan 9th 2009 1:57PM
What about the Circuit City's in Canada. Same story?
Kate F @ Jan 9th 2009 2:17PM
There are no Circuit City's in Canada, but we do have 'The Source' by Circuit City (formerly Radio Shack). They appear to be going strong up here and there has been no news of them going under.
I'm not sure if they will continue to be operated as such though.
JRH @ Jan 9th 2009 2:10PM
Here in northern VA, without even thinking about it I can list half a dozen Best Buy locations and only one Circuit City. It's sad, to be sure, but I've rarely found better deals at CC anyway (so I'm not exactly surprised by their demise). It'll be interesting to see, though, what happens near Sawgrass Mills mall in Fort Lauderdale. There's a CompUSA and a Circuit City on one side of Sunrise Blvd., a Best Buy on the other, and a BrandsMart USA at the mall. Before Christmas, the sales at all four stores were mostly within a few dollars of each other.
Also, Darren:
http://www.cgl.uwaterloo.ca/~csk/its.html
ombraweb @ Jan 9th 2009 2:19PM
How will this effect "The Source" in Canada?
Cellien @ Jan 9th 2009 2:21PM
I'm worried about my TVs extended warranty!
joe hobo @ Jan 9th 2009 2:50PM
Don't worry about your warranty, it is backed by a third party company known as GE Assurant. They will take care of you.
alex1jam @ Jan 9th 2009 2:24PM
Its okay i stil have my Apple store were i can buy a cinema display and a Apple TV and im done.
thedudeabides @ Jan 9th 2009 2:29PM
Maybe this will open the door for some new retailers to move into these cities to compete with Best Buy. Here in Orlando is one of the CompUSAs that stayed open under TigerDirects ownership and the store is remarkably better. Fairly good prices (competes with online) and a good selection of just not the "main stuff" but lots of adapters, connectors and other tech related valuables.
My hope is for Fry's to expand out east as they also carry general electronic goods (fans, IC stuff etc) which if you don't have a local shop for it, is hard stuff to find (forget Radio Shack).
But yes, buy online is the lesson here.
Terry Thomas @ Jan 9th 2009 2:36PM
thedudeabides:
Where have you been? Fry's is already "out east".
We have two stores in the Atlanta area.
(In case you went to a public school, Georgia is on the east coast of the United States).
Terry Thomas
Atlanta, Georgia USA
Roderick @ Jan 9th 2009 2:55PM
We don't have any Fry's down here in San Antonio. We need some of that action and fast!
mrSeeloeSickser @ Jan 9th 2009 3:23PM
We need Fry's in FL!!! There is nothing like it here, non-existent...
thedudeabides @ Jan 9th 2009 3:27PM
SeeloSickser:
If your in or close to the Orlando area there's a store here called "Skycraft Parts and Surplus" and they have an abundance (to use the term lightly) of electronics parts and bits and pieces. Easily my favorite shop in the city.
And for the record GA is the only east coast state with Fry's (next closest is Illinois) so hopefully this will encourage them to expand out on this side even further.
mrSeeloeSickser @ Jan 9th 2009 3:36PM
@thedudeabides:
thanks for the info, i'll have to try and check it out....i'm not too far way, over in Tampa. here we have the standard national stores and a couple mom and pops (mostly computer fix, not parts) but nothing like good ole' Frys (and the internet :)...
Jake @ Jan 9th 2009 2:47PM
I'm fairly certain that that picture is of the old Circuit City in Johnstown, PA. In which case, it is misleading, because that CC moved into a shiny new (actually very nice) location in a different shopping center. The fact that it still bears the hallmarks of being a CC is a poor reflection on J-town, not on CC. ;-)
At JRH: I'm in NoVa, too, and I know of 4 BestBuys (and one in Tyson's doesn't count b/c Tyson's has two, and one is closing) and 5 Circuit Cities in Fairfax County and Falls Church. See where I'm going with this? My experience is the exact opposite of yours: BB nearly always has the worst price on any tech; CC often has good deals; but generally, neither of them beats Amazon and Newegg.
jimboismydad @ Jan 9th 2009 3:08PM
Eh, sorry, this is the store in Mentor, Ohio. At least I think. That one closed.
jimboismydad @ Jan 9th 2009 3:13PM
I take that back, the one in Mentor had a little car port to the right of the entrance for loading. Maybe they spent to much money on identical giant signs over the entrance?
Joe Hobo @ Jan 9th 2009 2:50PM
Damn shame.... Talks of liquidation so soon. Say what you want about this place, good/bad, thats 40 thousand plus jobs gone and one less competitor. I work at one... what will I do.... ohh yeah... get a 9 month paid vacation paid for by the state!! LIQUIDATE !! LIQUIDATE!!
va jj @ Jan 9th 2009 2:53PM
what will you do? become a hobo.