HTC Hero for Sprint hands-on and impressions

When we first caught wind of HTC's Hero coming to Sprint, we were more than a little hopeful that the issues we experienced with the European version would be alleviated. If you'll recall, we had a bit of a love-hate affair going on with the chinny, wine-drinking iteration of the Android-powered phone due to a seeming lack of horsepower required to push HTC's totally amazing Sense UI. In the last few weeks, we've heard lots of chatter about the forthcoming Hero update and the wonders it would do for the speed of this phone... but unfortunately there's no such luck in the US, CDMA version of this device.
So, the point here is we were planning on doing a whole new review to showcase the differences between the old and new version of the Hero, but there really aren't any besides the obvious physical changes. Sprint has added some great new apps, like its visual voicemail, which works like a charm (oh by the way Coleen, you got that job -- maybe you should give them your new number too), and Sprint Navigation, though it's also muddied up the mix by including the yawn-maker NASCAR app. Of course, this phone provides a full-on 3G experience, unlike the European version (for obvious reasons), and Sprint's network seems as snappy as ever -- general web browsing was a noticeably more enjoyable experience, for instance.
Here is what we can say about the phone: the industrial design of this version versus the older model is a marked improvement, chucking that awkward chin shape for a proper bottom half, and rearranging the hard buttons so that you're not constantly getting your hands cramped up. We also have to mention the trackball, which is the most comfortable we've ever used. While the performance is still not where we think it should be, the Hero is an awesome addition to Sprint's growing line of serious contenders in the smartphone game. If that new update is all it's supposed to be (and if Sprint is expedient in bringing it to market), many of our complaints should be quelled -- and this will be the killer device we know it can be.
Update: To commenters asking for a longer review, or asking about discrepancies in our findings versus other sites -- we can only report on what we observed. In our eyes, there is nothing significantly different or improved about the Sprint version to warrant a second review. There are some very minor differences in camera quality, and obviously the network performance is better (since it's not EDGE), but a full-length review did not seem necessary (you'll note many of our contemporaries also have short-form reviews). While reports may differ (especially those stating that this phone has the updated ROM we've heard about), we're still seeing the same kind of sluggishness and slowdown we experienced with the European version. What we said in the original Hero review very much applies to the Sprint version, and we suggest you take a peek.
So, the point here is we were planning on doing a whole new review to showcase the differences between the old and new version of the Hero, but there really aren't any besides the obvious physical changes. Sprint has added some great new apps, like its visual voicemail, which works like a charm (oh by the way Coleen, you got that job -- maybe you should give them your new number too), and Sprint Navigation, though it's also muddied up the mix by including the yawn-maker NASCAR app. Of course, this phone provides a full-on 3G experience, unlike the European version (for obvious reasons), and Sprint's network seems as snappy as ever -- general web browsing was a noticeably more enjoyable experience, for instance.
Here is what we can say about the phone: the industrial design of this version versus the older model is a marked improvement, chucking that awkward chin shape for a proper bottom half, and rearranging the hard buttons so that you're not constantly getting your hands cramped up. We also have to mention the trackball, which is the most comfortable we've ever used. While the performance is still not where we think it should be, the Hero is an awesome addition to Sprint's growing line of serious contenders in the smartphone game. If that new update is all it's supposed to be (and if Sprint is expedient in bringing it to market), many of our complaints should be quelled -- and this will be the killer device we know it can be.
Update: To commenters asking for a longer review, or asking about discrepancies in our findings versus other sites -- we can only report on what we observed. In our eyes, there is nothing significantly different or improved about the Sprint version to warrant a second review. There are some very minor differences in camera quality, and obviously the network performance is better (since it's not EDGE), but a full-length review did not seem necessary (you'll note many of our contemporaries also have short-form reviews). While reports may differ (especially those stating that this phone has the updated ROM we've heard about), we're still seeing the same kind of sluggishness and slowdown we experienced with the European version. What we said in the original Hero review very much applies to the Sprint version, and we suggest you take a peek.


























Old hero looked a million times better
Ye!! Look sooooo greate than before.
the fact that engadget adds a disclaimer to their review makes it null and void. Next time, please do a quality review with all of the facts, your readers will appreciate it.
NO WAY. how?
Yeah, the olde Hero design was much better than what we have TOY like design now.
The CHIN was making it different from any other phones....I hope they change the design...
I agree with JJ. Engadget's outlook is somewhat biased, they have done more than the lion's share of phone reviews and always given their opinion, but at the same time remained neutral if you understand that.
If it had been an iPhone with modest upgrades, then there would have been an in depth review...
RT: @htc: Oh! On the same token, the Hero on Sprint will indeed have the performance tweaks found in the recent EU update. Rejoice!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bRPr4K_mpkM
MINE
i still think the original looks better, minus the chin maybe
damn, i had to be the second person in a row to say, that didn't i.
god i'm sucking bad today
"...row to say that, didn't i."
does it still have the oilophobic screen? And more importantly, how is Sprint and HTC going to handle donut when it comes out?
I believe they will be required to have Donut, since it is the first android version to actually support CDMA. I just really hope they also put in the new speed upgrading firmware!
If i remember correctly, the original never had an oleophobic screen. It was however Teflon coated ( only the white one ) and my guess is that is what you mean.
@ Shravran
The original Hero had the oleophobic coating:
http://www.infosyncworld.com/news/n/10360.html
I guarentee you every single Android device from the G1 on up will get Donut. Eclaire may be another story though.
Sweet. Thanks. I wasn't sure if the Sense UI was going to screw with updates. Good to hear. My Helio contract is up (finally) and I'll probably be picking up this bad boy.
Chinny?
Ring ring ring ring ring ring ring
The Leno phone
Boo-ba-doo-ba-doop!
That could be a possible candidate name for HTCs future phones with a chin, HTC Leno..
So does this one have the new update? or we have to wait for that? I thought there was a performance boost on the new ROM that was being updated. Anyone got any ideA??!
Can you comment on the Menu, Search, Back and Home buttons? Are they touch sensitive or do they actually move a la Touch Diamond?
Blah Blah.. enough with the "Old one looks better."
I personally like the new one. I never really got over "the chin", and after having the G1 since release day.. I've grown tired of it.
Finally! Now Oct. 11 seems really far away. This phone looks incredible, albeit less aesthetically pleasing than the GSM Hero
And it feeeeeeels
And it feeeeeeeeels like
Heaven's so far away
I guess you are putting in overtime Josh
So I'm taking this to mean the Hero won't launch with Donut or the HTC update? Or is this a early evaluation version that isn't entirely representative of the launch version?
I'm guessing it's the latter since the update was just released yesterday.
Since Donut is the first Android release to support CDMA I have to assume it is required on this phone. Correct me if I am wrong?
@ Jake and Eric, those are very good questions, However, this post was not written to answer any questions. What the author clearly is trying to tell you is
1. He thinks the old phone was ugly.
2. He wanted to get to play with updated version and since he didn't he is gonna take his
ball and go home.
3. There are some good things about the phone, i'll tell you a few that you really dont care
about but that's all you get until I get to play with the updated version.
@Ron
I totally forgot that. If this has Donut, why wasn't it mentioned in the review, since Donut should have the new market as well as universal search, which warrants at least some mention.
Yeah, I thought donut was sposed to fix the sluggishness that the author seems to attribute to the hardware. Seems like worth mentioning if a software update remedies an issue that would keep people from considering the device.
Can't wait for this phone. Hopefully they get the update for this version squared away for
launch.
FINGER print haven on the back... where's the white teflon?
wtf...
The back is soft touch, so if you're leaving fingerprints on rubber you probably just need to take a bath.
tell that to the reviewer then ... lol
I have seen some reviews saying the white teflon is wearing off after only a few weeks (with some cases and pouches). I am very glad sprint picked a different finish
Hero looks intresting..i kud care less about the chin cuz people still complained about the other android phones and said.."Sure be great without that chin" Now its gone. Shut up. Be Happy.
But im gonna be attatched at the hip to my Touch Pro 2 for Quite awhile...
Josh, can you please post some shots of the phone that are taken in a brighter room?
Also, does the phone have sort of a rubberized coating?
root?
cyan ROMs?
The more I see it, the more I like it without the chin. Why couldn't these phones have been out two years ago Sprint? Sprint is doing some great work. My experiences with their support were terribly lackluster, and I went through 8-9 devices over 2 years due to faulty software programming on their part. And of course, now, they're showing up every other carrier with the best rates and devices with improved CDMA service and not many people seem to be noticing. I think I may switch back to them in a year or two. They're doing great, and I have to say, I'm rooting for them now. Sprint is the only carrier currently attempting to bring some form of innovation and improvements to their network. Kudos to them.
I agree. Sprint is on a roll - they are doing all of the right things.
Why are you asking Sprint that?
Sprint can't market and sell phones that don't exist.
Ask HTC and Google.
Do you take everything you read literally my friend? I was still with Sprint a couple years ago. I said that if they had had the level of service and quality that they have now, I probably would have stayed with them. I switched because I had some bad experiences with the hardware and service. I also wanted an iPhone, like many people. I love my iPhone, but AT&T's service has been performing sporadically for me. Now, not only does Sprint have great service and improving support, but they also have phones that are worthy alternatives to the iPhone. Best of both worlds. It's because of the iPhone that many of these phones exist today, this I know. The iPhone wasn't/isn't perfect, but for its faults it has twice as many positives. It's a pretty good phone. Now we have other phones that are arguably better in different areas. Depends on your opinion.
Why so serious? As a former Sprint customer, I was merely expressing my satisfaction with the company's renewed vitality and commitment to good service. And even if I don't go back to Sprint, their new unlimited plans ought to provoke price cuts around the country, if the other carriers know what's good for them. Sprint ain't Ol' Yeller no more; they're returning in full force.
So I guess there's no way to get this version of the phone unlocked, right?
Does it fix that problem where it runs android? lol
I'm looking forward to checking this phone out in person....Finally a good time to be on Sprint...and what do you know perfect timing my contract is up this mouth. But will the Samsung be a better contender with the full keyboard....i love hard keys....but HTC has the custom UI , may be lagy ......so will see..........
Wow thanks engadget for the fail. I'm direly waiting for this thing to come out. Could you not be bothered for a more in depth review on this US version?
Gizmodo is reporting that the Sprint Hero has an updated ROM that fixes the sluggishness.
http://gizmodo.com/5361245/sprint-hero-review-faster-stronger-uglier
Maybe it's Josh that is sluggish. It is 12:30 p.m. in NYC.
Or possibly he's just used to the iPhone 3GS. The phone is really fast. Impressively so.