Entelligence: Gartenberg's best of 2009 in personal tech
By Michael Gartenberg 
posted December 31st 2009 4:30PM
posted December 31st 2009 4:30PM
Entelligence is a column by technology strategist and author Michael Gartenberg, a man whose desire for a delicious cup of coffee and a quality New York bagel is dwarfed only by his passion for tech. In these articles, he'll explore where our industry is and where it's going -- on both micro and macro levels -- with the unique wit and insight only he can provide.
As the year comes to a close, it seems appropriate to cast my vote for the best (and some of the worst) gadgets I've seen. These are my personal choices for products that I felt were best of breed and really managed to differentiate themselves (or didn't at all). In no particular order, here are my picks and pans.
Best Phones: This was a tricky category, and I'm not breaking it down into different segments. This is just the best on the market in my opinion -- no matter how smart it was considered to be, or how well it did in school.
Best Desktop Computers: With the shift from desktop to laptop purchases for many consumers, it's hard to sometimes see anything special in this category. This year, there were two that stood out for me.
Best OS. It was a tough year for the OS market. After all, neither Windows nor Mac OS was due for a major release but both found ways to push the envelope forward.
Best Laptop or Netbook. Another controversial one, since I'm just putting laptops and netbooks into the same category. To me a netbook is just still a laptop with pivotal axis as price.
General Gadgets That Stood Out From the Pack
Worst gadget. Possibly ever.
Most hyped gadget not in existence, launched or even announced but that was reviewed, critiqued on features and price, as well as forecasted with unit shipments.
Let's just say, take two tablets from Apple and Microsoft and call me in 2010 please.
We mourn the loss and reincarnation special mention.
RIP CrunchPad -- hello Joojoo.
Michael Gartenberg is vice president of strategy and analysis at Interpret, LLC. His weblog can be found at gartenblog.net. Contact him at gartenberg AT gmail DOT com. Views expressed here are his own.
Best Phones: This was a tricky category, and I'm not breaking it down into different segments. This is just the best on the market in my opinion -- no matter how smart it was considered to be, or how well it did in school.
- iPhone 3GS. It was a simple choice. Take the coolest phones on the market, bump up the memory and make it twice as fast. Add in some new features like a digital compass and toss in an ecosystem of 100,000+ apps. Sure, it's still locked to AT&T but the iPhone is still the phone that many others aspire to be.
- Palm Pre. At this point last year many had written Palm off entirely. Instead of fading away, Palm came back on strong with webOS, a new way of integrating diverse content called Synergy and two devices launched across the globe. Along the way, the Pre garnered much mindshare from consumers, and Palm showed that you don't need to clone the iPhone to drive the state of the art forward.
- HTC HD2. When Microsoft released Windows Mobile 6.5, there was a chorus of groans about more of the same. HTC took up the challenge and proved that there was more to Windows Mobile than slow devices and resistive screens. The HD2 takes Windows Mobile to places never seen before with a capacitive touch screen, a Snapdragon processor and HTC-created extensions that make multi-touch work the HD2's gorgeous 4.3-inch display. Wrap it all up in HTC's Sense UI and you've got the best Windows Mobile device on the market today.
Best Desktop Computers: With the shift from desktop to laptop purchases for many consumers, it's hard to sometimes see anything special in this category. This year, there were two that stood out for me.
- Apple 27-inch iMac. In a crowded market of dull machines, racing to the bottom, the 27-inch iMac stands out of the crowd. Whether you get the 3.06GHz Intel Core 2 Duo or the 2.66GHz Intel Core i5 you'll have a computer that looks like no other with a price / performance ratio that would have been virtually impossible just a few years ago.
- HP TouchSmart. The TouchSmart line has been around for a while, but HP's been able to take the concept to a whole new level with Windows 7's native support for touch. HP filled the gaps in 7 and the Win 7 TouchPack, adding a host of useful touch based applications and creating a framework for other developers to get on board. The TouchSmart is a great example of a vendor building on Microsoft's foundational work and taking a proof of concept to the mainstream.
Best OS. It was a tough year for the OS market. After all, neither Windows nor Mac OS was due for a major release but both found ways to push the envelope forward.
- Windows 7. If you get a new PC or use Vista, the upgrade is a no-brainer -- you want Windows 7. If you're still using XP and it's working for you, that's a tougher call, since it's not easy to directly upgrade from Windows XP. There's also a somewhat-confusing array of SKUs and a pretty high cost to migrate, but overall Windows 7 is no doubt Microsoft's best OS work ever.
- Snow Leopard. It wasn't a major update in terms of features, but a lot happened under the covers that will set the stage for what comes next from Apple -- and Exchange support alone was worth more than the modest $29 upgrade fee. Leaner and faster, Snow Leopard recovered a good deal of hard drive space for users and boosted performance. Lots of goodness for a pretty cheap price.
Best Laptop or Netbook. Another controversial one, since I'm just putting laptops and netbooks into the same category. To me a netbook is just still a laptop with pivotal axis as price.
- Lenovo X200t. It's the evolution of the Tablet PC with some multitouch goodness thrown in. Add in a long-life battery and Lenovo's industry-leading keyboard and you've got one of the best Windows 7 devices on the market, period. The X200t shows just how tablet devices with touch and pen just might become more mainstream next year.
- 13-inch MacBook Pro. It's not a perfect computer. When I use it home, I wish the screen were larger. When it's on the road with me, I wish it were a little thinner and lighter. It is, however, among the most balanced laptops I've ever seen, which is one of the reasons it's a joy to use. From the LED display, to the backlit keyboard, to the extended life integrated battery, it's everything I think a laptop should be. And it not only runs Snow Leopard but flawlessly runs Windows XP and Windows 7 as well.
- Nokia Booklet 3G. Surprisingly, this turned out to be my favorite netbook this year. It's tiny, light, and elegant with some nice touches that make it a joy to use. Sure, I'd like to have seen a faster processor and a speedier hard drive at a better price point but this "multimedia computer" from Nokia has a lot of potential.
General Gadgets That Stood Out From the Pack
- MiFi. When Novatel called to tell me about their new mobile broadband product, I was a little skeptical. I mean, how many USB sticks does one need? Instead what I saw was a miracle the size of the credit card that takes a 3G modem and crosses it with a WiFi hotspot to make the first personal router. It's amazing. With support for five devices you can make any WiFi device 3G-enabled with just a few clicks. MiFi takes an old concept and adds a lot of new life to it.
- Sonos S5. Take the magic that is Sonos and squish it in a box with some amazing speakers. Pair it with an app for the iPhone and iPod touch and you've got the making for next revolution on home music. With support for Rhapsody, Pandora, Last.fm and others and the ability to connect to your entire iTunes library, Sonos bridges the gap to offer the most complete digital audio experience on the market. Add in the cool iPhone app and you've got the first device that's not an accessory to the iPhone, it's now the first accessory to an app. Impressive and well done.
- 3M MPro120. Pico projectors have been around for awhile but this is the first one that's actually usable and is more than a toy. It's easy to connect to a PC or iPod, and while it's not perfect, this technology is going to get a lot more interesting as it gets embedded in more devices.
Worst gadget. Possibly ever.
- WiKi Reader. It's $99. Has Wikipedia on it. No connectivity, just Wikipedia on an SD card. You then have to buy updates for it, as it's already out of date seconds after you buy it. Who is this for? I have no idea. Perhaps to be airlifted and dropped in areas where people have no internet access, have no way to get internet access and want outdated versions of Wikipedia.
Most hyped gadget not in existence, launched or even announced but that was reviewed, critiqued on features and price, as well as forecasted with unit shipments.
Let's just say, take two tablets from Apple and Microsoft and call me in 2010 please.
We mourn the loss and reincarnation special mention.
RIP CrunchPad -- hello Joojoo.
Michael Gartenberg is vice president of strategy and analysis at Interpret, LLC. His weblog can be found at gartenblog.net. Contact him at gartenberg AT gmail DOT com. Views expressed here are his own.
Wow, aside from the x200t this column is a few obvious choices and many more poor ones.
No Droid? Touchsmart vs. many of the other good desktops out there? HD2 (yes, nice hardware, but a phone needs a competent OS)?
I keep trying to give Gartenberg the benefit of the doubt, but increasingly I find myself thinking "what the hell is this guy talking about?"
@PerryAJ
I think the perspective that HTC HD2 shows us is what you can do with so little. That, given an operating system that shows a lot of age, HTC has given it a decent, if not nice face. It reminds me of Windows 3.1. When I first used it in 1987, it was simply beautiful to behold. Windows 3.1 gave us multitasking and a graphical user interface. But underneath was DOS (Disk Operating System) which was a single tasking operating system. Yes, this was not a perfect marriage. Windows 3.1 would crash a few times each day, but ah, it was a BIG improvement over working with DOS (without Windows).
The WIKI reader is one of best gadgets up there considering it is priced not that much above a lot of monthly phone plans.
What a BS list.
What this shows us is that a lot of people are going to be disappointed not seeing their favorite device on the list. Granted, some people may genuinely not agree with the list, but that is life. Michael Gartenberg is a brave man. He could have simply put everyone's favorite gadget on the list, but he took the high road and acted with integrity, and placed on the list the products he truly believed should be there. Whatever his choice, I have sure that Android will survive.
Correction:
"I am sure..." not "I have sure"
Gartenberg is a shill why is here ?
The HTC HD2 is a horror to use. It should be at the bottom of the list.
Bugs, bugs, bugs. HTC sent out some patches, but the bugs are still there. SMS delay bug. Capacitive screen bugs. Pink camera bug (video). 720p video chip disabled. Anyone can search the net and read about the horrors other people are going through, dealing with those HD2 issues.
The HD2 is also no good as a business phone, as most of the WinMo business apps were designed for stylus and have issues with the capacitive screen.
The HTC Nexus/Bravo/Passion will be out in a few days. It's basically a similar phone, but this time running Android, which will clear up many of those issues.
@IT expert
No it won't. Firmware for the HD2 cleared up the issues. Android is still an immature platform and has its own problems, it's not a panacea for the ils of the mobile world.
After looking through comments... Maybe it will be better when renaming engadget to androidgadget? I have never seen so many android ...ok,lovers(i thought about "fanboys")...and so many winmo and iphone haters "just because they are what they are". And it looks like US networks(ok,SOME OF THEM) really suck
@Michael Gartenberg you really have been off the mark in the last few columns.
Phones:
1) Motorola Droid
2) Nokia N900
See my blog post: http://tnkgrl.wordpress.com/2009/12/31/device-of-the-year-motorola-droid/
@(Unverified)
But... Motorola and Nokia are both last generation giants that know blow chunks. I think G-man is on point.
as many problems that people are having with the 27 inch apple desktop, its named desktop of the year... wow
@dirtballrotten so tell us, how many people exactly are having problems with their 27'' iMac, since you are trying to pretend to know
@HighestRanked
http://www.google.com/#hl=en&source=hp&q=27+imac+problems&aq=0&aqi=g3g-m2&oq=27%22+imac+pr&fp=cbc2f75bf9d43a8f
Wow Apple makes shitty computers? Oh and the sky is blue also?
I'm not trying to be mean here, but every time I read this column I'm left totally confused. How can someone so clueless get away with being called a "technology strategist" on Engadget? Is this some sort of punishment from corporate?
I don't see why so many of you people think that just because Apple is in every category, they dominate. They're not the best, no one is. Each excels at a certain thing. Apple is good at getting things more into the public, even to the stupid people who don't know shit about shit, and MS is good at making good products that subtely make their way into almost every person's life. But, in my honest opinion, in terms of software, Apple and Windows are the greatest innovators because they both made excellent OS's. I don't hate OSX, I actually really like it. Apple started the entire touchphone craze with their iPhone, and they made other phone companies have something to compete against. Microsoft made Windows Mobile, which isn't the best, but it isn't horrible in my experience.
I'm talking about the past few years, not just this year.
@Lucas "MS is good at making good products..."
Hm, no, not really.
@HighestRanked Woah, I re-read my comment, it's the worst comment I've ever typed... @_@ I'm too distracted to even type anything right...
Wow at all the Apple love. Where is the Droid? and Linux should be under best OS.
@Atkins why the heck are you going on a personal crusade to protect this writer's unfortunate article that is placed in clear sights for all of engadget's readers? he knew his opinions were being put into the public's eyes, that he's wildy labeled as the "technology strategist" and he knows that not everybody will agree, so let those of us who disagree do so
This is not related to any of the hating going on here, but HTC uses TouchFlo3D for WinMo, SenseUI is for android. That's all, just bugs me sorry!
HTC HD2 the greatest ever phone that nobody has or has seen except in a blog...
I should upgrade from Vista to Windows 7?
and pay to do it?
dont think sooooooooo....
Isn't that 27 inch iMac the one with all the problems?
for netbook I would say Nokia Booklet 3g:
it has it's flaws but it stands compared to other netbooks
Pros
-16 cell battery
-gps built-in
-Aircraft-grade aluminum
-very light and slim
The macbook pro has some amazing hardware, however in my mind netbooks push technology far. Making laptop composites smaller and smaller. Making the Nokia Booklet 3g the best in my mind.
not gunna lie... im at quite a loss why they chose the apple 27in desktop. especially at the stupid reasoning that the performance/price ratio wudn't have been possible earlier. DUH!!! every year the ratio dramatically improves!!! and on a MAC!?!?! thats jus laughable to bring the affordability into consideration at all... lastly, comps have come soo much further since then. why rewind?
@Atkins yeah but i dont think many [smart] people would pay the premium for an allinone, i know i wudnt. wuts the point really? deskspace !> affordability/processorpower/upgradeability. and even if we're talkin just allinones, i think i cud find a cheaper pc...course i dont have numbers and a time machine in front of me so proving this is impossible... just dont see how that one contends.
Interesting... Good choices too.
Worst gadget. Possibly ever.
Have you ever heard of the TwitterPeek? At least that WikiReader thing has some use.
people actually upset with his decision choices, hahaha this is HIS opinion so dont go crying to mummy because your choice isn't there.
3GS?
are you kdding, nothing more than a redressed Samsung?
If you find that any of these cool gadgets are temporarily sold out at Amazon, you can use the free service http://www.aznotify.com/ to watch inventory and notify you (with an obnoxious alarm) the instant it's back in Amazon stock so you can buy it quickly before it sells out again.