Aliph Jawbone Icon reviewSee all photos
Goodies and build quality
Let's focus on the Jawbone Icon for now. First of all, kudos to Aliph for its petite and 100%-recyclable packaging -- expect some flowers from treehuggers soon. To our further surprise the small box packed similar goodies as the Jawbone Prime: on the first layer you'll find three fits for the earbuds with that funny loop stopper (which pushes against the concha to help secure the device), and for the naysayers there's the good old earloop with four earbud fits. If none of these fit you then at least this feast would sound good on your eBay listing. Further down the box are a stash of bilingual (English and Spanish) manuals and cards that remind you not to eat the product, followed by a hard-flex USB-to-micro-USB cable and a wall adapter.
Our adventurous nature led us to 'Fit Option A -- earbud only.' OK, 'adventurous' was a lie -- we just don't like the earloop as the space is already taken up by our spectacles. Anyhow, without much effort The Ace was already fit snuggly in our right ear (and its symmetrical design means it's lefty-friendly too) -- apparently the key is to point the earpiece downwards while plugging it into the ear, and then twist up to secure. Thankfully, the Voice Activity Sensor nipple -- a crucial element of the NoiseAssassin operation -- has good contact with our skin despite the shorter body, but with such remarkable lightness sometimes we couldn't tell for sure! We've been shaking our heads and jumping around yet The Ace stayed on, but of course, a well-aimed brush by your hands may eventually knock it off, plus the summer sweat might become its biggest enemy so do keep that earloop.
Functionality and control
Aliph boldly claims that the Icon is its "most sophisticated and accessible Jawbone yet," so let's see: yep, we're already liking that on / off switch on the back, which is much less of a hassle than the traditional hold-down-for-five-seconds nonsense. Not much else can be found on the earpiece except the micro-USB port and multi-function button next to the earbud -- the latter deals with phone calls (single click to pick up or hang up calls; double click to redial), checking battery level (single click) and launching a DialApp (hold down the button; we'll cover this later). There are no volume buttons -- the cunning Jawbone Active Dynamic Range Management normalizes all caller volumes around your preferred volume, as controlled by your phone initially. In a way the Icon makes up for what it lacks, if you feel left out at all -- iPhone users are treated to an extra on-screen battery gauge icon which is a first for non-Apple Bluetooth headsets, and apparently Apple's cool with this so it should be staying around for a good while.
Pairing with our phones was no harder than before -- like the Icon's predecessor the process is still PIN-free, still remembers up to eight pairings (and when the quota's full, the least used profile is replaced by the ninth one) but now supporting two simultaneous calls instead of cutting the old one off when picking up the other (so that you can toggle between two calls, like call waiting on one line). That said, we did have the occasional hiccups while attempting to pair with a second phone, and the ultimate solution was to do the tragic hard reset.
All these fancy features sound good so far, but we have yet to get to the real juice of the Jawbone Icon, so how about some sound tests? Round 1 -- Icon paired with a laptop vs. iPhone voice memo (control), both exposed to a simulated bar environment:
Seems like NoiseAssassin did the job well -- the suppressed noise was nowhere near the original volume, although from time to time our voice was slightly saturated but still retaining good clarity overall. If you recall, the Jabra Stone barely reduced the noise level under the same simulation, so we're happy with the Icon so far.
Round 2 -- phone call made on the Motorola DEXT with and without the Icon (audio captured via headphone jack of our iPhone 3GS), both under the same bar noise as before:
Although the Icon had a rough start -- probably for initial calibration -- it settled pretty quickly into a conversation-ready mode, and the dialog was more audible than the Jabra Stone's in the same test. We even prefer the outcome of the Icon to the Motorola DEXT's onboard noise elimination -- the latter's strong filter made us sound like mumbling with an open mouth, if that's possible at all. Seriously though, the Icon has impressed us in both tests.
Update: the Jawbone can now stream music and podcasts via an A2DP update from the MyTALK website.
What can we say? Aliph's hit the spot with six pretty rad designs for this one product range alone, while offering a fresh platform to customize each Icon headset and making it easier to use at the same time. More importantly, the Icon has a noise elimination trick that actually produces results, although we'd like to see that pairing bug fixed with a firmware update sometime soon. Looks like we have a winner here then! One final wish from us: how about some stereo Bluetooth headphones, Aliph?