It's completely anecdotal and lacking in what some might call "scientific rigor," but we're digging the, ahem
, relevance of Phil Gyford's little text input faceoff he performed for his blog recently. The piece pits an Apple Newton, Palm Vx, Treo 650, and Apple iPhone up against each other, with regular pen and paper and a laptop's full QWERTY keyboard thrown in for reference. The results may or may not surprise you, but (spoiler alert) after the MacBook Pro took top honors in blazing through a 221 word passage twice, the iPhone beat out the rest of the competition, with the three pen-related inputs (pen and paper, Newton MessagePad and Palm Graffiti) all taking up dead last. The iPhone, Treo and pen and paper all were relatively close in speed, and naturally your mileage may vary. That said, where do you think you fall? Drop in your results in comments (the full text he used can be found at the source link) or hit up the poll below with your best guestimate. We're dying to know!
Which mobile text input method is faster for you?
|Hardware QWERTY||12585 (62.5%)|
|Software QWERTY||3974 (19.7%)|
|Pen and paper||3133 (15.6%)|
|Handwriting recognition||442 (2.2%)|