Entelligence: Think Pink - First take on Microsoft's Kin
Entelligence is a column by technology strategist and author Michael Gartenberg, a man whose desire for a delicious cup of coffee and a quality New York bagel is dwarfed only by his passion for tech. In these articles, he'll explore where our industry is and where it's going -- on both micro and macro levels -- with the unique wit and insight only he can provide.

In many ways, Kin is the extension and spiritual descendant of the Sidekick (which was a product of Danger, founded by the father of Android, Andy Rubin, and later acquired by Microsoft). At its core, the Kin philosophy is guided by the proposition that one size device doesn't fit all, and specific demographics have different mobile needs.
Kin is not designed as a horizontal platform like Android, iPhone or even Windows Phone 7. It's targeted at a younger demographic with an emphasis on social communicators. Its feature set isn't designed for the mass market and that's exactly what might make it a success. To me, there are three important take aways.
First, mature platforms and markets fragment. This is true of just about all markets. There are features, designs and other factors that all target different users and demographics. It's something that's just starting to happen in the mobile space and Microsoft is wise to get ahead of this curve. If one-size-fit all, and the only focus was on utilitarian functions we'd all drive Honda Civics, wear Timex watches and use BIC pens. We don't -- and the reasons that we don't are what make Kin look very attractive.
"Few devices embody the intersection of mobile and social networks as well as Kin One and Kin Two do." |
Finally, the intersection of mobile and social networks is here. Few devices embody the intersection of mobile and social networks as well as Kin One and Kin Two do. The ability to tie networks together into a cohesive universal view in a way that's not cluttered or look like a user experience suffering from attention deficit disorder is a breakthrough. The result is a new type of user that's able to move from communication to collaboration, and extend that conversation from one-to-one to one-to-many. The implications are huge as the social interactions create trusted and real time information flows that are contextually relevant. The net result? A new type of user that is empowered to make fewer mistakes, creating a larger global and social memory that can be tapped into anytime and anywhere.
Kin shows Microsoft is taking mobile seriously. As a complement to Windows Phone 7, it's a bold move to capture the thought and leadership for an important demographic. By creating a new user experience centered around social communication and interaction beyond voice or even text messages, Microsoft has upped the stakes in mobility and raised the bar for the next generation of devices and leveraged platforms.





















Best Gartenberg piece to date.
@Sisyphus Next to this http://www.engadget.com/2009/11/08/entelligence-heads-i-win-tails-so-do-you/ and http://www.engadget.com/2009/11/01/entelligence-of-ebooks-and-suburban-moms/ One of his best.
@Sisyphus
I understand what microsoft is doing with "Kin"
-tapping into the sidekick and dumb-phone market(tweens and hipsters)
-creating a stepping stone to wp7
-changing the perception that Microsoft is "complicated and ugly"
So with that in mind compare this device to a voyager, or an ev2, both immensely popular dumb-phones from Verizon.
-hi-res camera with flash
-fully integrated into all of the most popular social networks
-keeps a charge for more than two days
-pretty ui-design
-the "omfg it's new" factor
-the "omfg it has a touchscreen" factor
I was at school, looking at engadget today, and a couple of my friends(not into tech) saw the kin1 and 2. They asked me what it was, I told them it was new phone coming out, with a built in zune, that holds everything online, with a myspace-esk system so that you can transfer and see it anytime.
They're mouthes dropped, and the questions poured in.
1st question:how much
a:Idk but it's supposed to be cheap
2nd question:what service
a:verizon
to which they all whet googly eyed saying how small and cute the kin 1 is and, how "sick" the kin 2 looked. My friend actually wants to by the kin 2 once her upgrade comes
minus zune functionality... It may not be our wet dream, as tech-nerds but to everyone else(everyday consumers) this phone looks orgasmic, once the features are on the table, and when compared to other dumb-phones the're really is no comparison at all.
This is something a lot of you aren't thinking about when it comes to these devices, and if this is someone's first smartphone(moderately) , and it proves to be a pretty good situation, whose to say that same consumer won't graduate to wp7 later on?
I for one think that with Verizon service, the ideas and features coming from Microsoft + the reputation and marketing genius of "danger" will make this phone successful, and if it does spawn the reputation of being "the new sidekick"... that's definitely not a bad thing for Microsoft's pockets.
While our eyes are locked on things like wp7 and the evo
The kins demographic's eyes are focused on the next voyager, or sidekick... and compared to those... the kin is definitely a beast, good job Microsoft I understand where your going with this... on a side note though... please add multitasking to wp7... seriously that's the only thing keeping me away form buying a wp7 device this holiday season.
@Sisyphus I banned that guy because he was the worst.
@wtgig I agree with your comments. I personally was not all that impressed by either Kin. However, I felt that perhaps I was just not getting it. So I showed the phones to my teenage daughter. She liked them, though she liked Kin 2 better. I was surprised, but she is very pragmatic and sensible regarding phones. She does not fall for too much 'Gee Whiz' stuff and looks more to how useful a device will actually be to her in real world settings.
@Sisyphus "Few devices embody the intersection of mobile and social networks as well as Kin One and Kin Two do." Agree, those 2 phones sure are unique of its kind. Opinions. http://bit.ly/microsoft-kin-impressions
@wtgig
I'll distill the gist of what you're saying, since I agree:
Once us nerds can collectively get over ourselves, we'll realize from a business (and consumer) perspective that these phones will probably have mass appeal. Just like the iPhone, and the iPad, and any other device that we high expectation-ers decry for lack of functionality.
To be sure, I'm one of those people -- but when I really think about it, I rarely even use half of the components in devices that I think need.
While the vocal minority clamors for futuristic specifications, most people are content with things that work well and look "cool."
@Laura June
Thanks, Laura!
P.S. -- Nice 'stache.
@scottkrk
I'VE BEEN DISCOVERED!
< vanishes in e-smoke >
@Sisyphus
I'll be more specific, wtgig post looks like a carefully crafted piece of communication, or maybe he/she is just an impartial but effective communicator.
If it is an attempt at viral marketing/astro turfing at least it is better than the dancing shop employees campaign from last year.
http://www.bradslavin.com/2009/11/16/microsoft-store-in-mission-viejo/
@Sisyphus
Seriously. I usually always complain about Gartenberg but I do like this one.
@scottkrk
I might have read what you wrote incorrectly, but did you just imply that my post was part of a viral marketing ploy for Microsoft??? if so, I'm touched lol but it most definitely is not.
I'm just sharing my opinion about "the kin", and what I think it's purpose is :-)... which btw doesn't mean I'm buying one, but that's only because It's not meant for my demographic as I said earlier.
at the moment I own a pre(love it), and until I hear legitimate good news about palm's upcoming position in the smartphone world. I will be flocking over to the evo, or whatever htc's wp7 device will be(if wp7 receives true multitasking) just like the rest of us hahaha
@wtgig When you put it like that I have to agree. I think what happens on Engadget (and all tech blogs) is that WE want to be interested in whatever is released and forget that most people don't even know what Engadget is (sorry) and wouldn't care to. They just want to buy something that works, aren't into specs, features, etc beyond basic needs. ie. need a camera, don't care about flash, megapixels, etc.
When you compare this to all the other dumb phones out there it blows them out the water and has the "wow" that Vista lost. From a commercial POV this should do great for MS.
@wtgig
u nailed it..i agree not every body sports a bb n iphone...kin defly has a plush market to go after..only time will tell
@wtgig So what you are trying to say is that these are "well rounded" phones. *badapching*
@wtgig
Great post, this phone is going to be great for it's target market.
Sorry but the phones are fuck ugly.
The UI is a hotmess of a clusterfuck.
Not sure what MS is thinking here. The iPhone 3G is 99 right? And I've heard in some areas it's 49! I mean why would any kid go choose these ugly phones over the beauty of the iPhone.
And for all the Apple Haters lets throw in the Palm Pixi or heck Pre. Those are down in price significantly since launch. And then there's the myriad of dumbphones from LG, Samsung, etc....
@TheLondonExchange Wow, that 5th paragraph in the article is right.
@TheLondonExchange The idea of these phones has always been the data charge..... THAT is where the iphone and other smartphones are expensive. The cheapest plan with full texting (assuming the tweener crown) on an iphone is $90 per month and you are locked in for 2 yrs at that price.
The sidekicks have ended up being cheaper because that data charge has typically been far less. But no word on what the plans will look like for these devices. It should still be cheaper than $90/month.
@TheLondonExchange
please dear god.... let there be ONE engadget article that doesn't have a troll posting about infamous "apple haters"...
@TheLondonExchange Agreed the phones are ugly. I don't get why, or anyone else, would want one over better and prettier devices that you mention.
@TheLondonExchange
These phones are awesome for teens who care about social networking, but you dumbfucks just don't get that.
And iPhone for 99$? Only under contract. These thing are gonna be like 150$ without contract.
The UI is just awesome. It's a lot like what WP7 is gonna be. And IMO it's really nicely organized, when you know what's going on there.
And you sir, are an Apple fanboy.
Cheers.
@N900
Let's see what the target demographic says. Fragmenting the market has pros and cons. It can lead to devices that are more effective for the people they are targeted to (by omitting stuff they aren't interested in and doing a better job of what they do care about). On the downside, it can be confusing and migration can be difficult. The biggest problem is that this particular demographic has the attention span of a gnat on coke and also demands their personal objects be cool (not something that is easy to plan for since they decide that, not some focus group in an office).
It will be interesting to see how this plays out.
@TheLondonExchange They aren't smartphones, your comparison is invalid.
@TheLondonExchange I just don't agree that the phones are ugly. Kin One isn't dissimilar to the Pre; which you subsequently mention, and Kin Two is too plain to be thought of as anything, let alone ugly.
As for the UI, as Gartenberg rightly says, it is designed for a specific demographic, one which one would imagine, hardly frequents Engadget and thus is unlikely to share the same opinions as yourself.
You must also not forget that yes the iPhone 3G is $99 in the states, but in Europe where it will be sold sim-free, it will likely be half the price of the sim-free 3G. Price, you must remember is one of, if not the biggest factor for teens when deciding upon their new phone.
@TheLondonExchange
"a hot mess of clutserfuck"
Thank you so much for this phrase.
@UrgentMatter
"@TheLondonExchange Agreed the phones are ugly. I don't get why, or anyone else, would want one over better and prettier devices that you mention."
#1 Nether of you, despite you high opinion of yourselves, speak for the personal tastes of everyone.
#2 Because you dont speak for the needs or wants of everyone on the planet.
Once you figure that out, you would never make such a statement again without feeling foolish.
@TheLondonExchange
you would have been highest ranked if you didnt mention the iPhone.
They ARE ugly phones, and the ui IS and ugly clusterfuck that isnt sure if its running sidekick or motoblur or wp7, so it just throws them all together in a blender
@Canucker Agreed, but that's why it's good to start young. As their target demographic doesn't care if it has a Snapdragon processor or HDMI out etc. However as you said, they'll have to find a way reel in our short-attention span Gen X kids of today (lol), to be successful.
@TheLondonExchange
I think the UI is ingenious (don't like the color scheme), in particular the Kin spot. Is this phone for me? No, I'm not even registered on any Social Networking sites, but I can still recognize that this will be a huge improvement over current "messaging" marketed phones like the LG enV line.
We don't know what the price of these phones will be, and more importantly we don't know the price of the data plan. When those details are revealed, then we can make comparisons to other phones and plans. You may very well be right, if this device falls under a smartphone data plan I'd be inclined to agree with you.
@N900
Let me know how it turns out. I'm a member of Gen Zzzz unfortunately, but have a definite interest in this demographic as I directly fund two members of it....
@hi0u826d
Assuming it ever gets to Europe... If the Zune is any indication, these devices may never make it over the border, let alone across the sea. Sad, really.
@BAGAGT1 The Kin Spot is cool, but not original. My employer came up with an identical human interface years ago - and a timeline based GUI too, like the Kin Studio. You'll catch it later in the year, but I cannot say on what device / platform. All said, MS have demonstrated it first, so credit where it is due.
@TheLondonExchange
The reason people will buy this ahead of the iPhone is because of one thing - to get to your social networking you still need to download apps. When given the choice between a device where you have to figure that out, then download them, install them, and use each separately, and one where all you do is input your login details one time and have instant access to all your accounts at once, I know which one a hell of a lot of people will choose.
So yeah, to cliche the hell out of it, if you don't want it, it's not for you.
@Fanman Agreed. That was the one saving grace of his post.
@dboobis I think a person that uses Facebook and Twitter regularly will easily figure out how to download apps on smartphones... Plus, apps save login information, so you don't have to enter them every time you want to use one. KIN doesn't offer any convenience compared to smartphones, really. It's all about the pricing.
Overpowered dumbphone, or under-featured smartphone... I think KIN depends on who's looking at it. I would like it as a secondary phone since I have a Droid already.
@ai4281
The point isn't figuring out how to do it, it's having to do it in the first place. Imagine a man and a woman driving somewhere. They end up getting lost. The man says "I'll just keep driving until I see something I recongnise, shouldn't take too long". The woman says "Let's just ask for directions". Both might get you where you're going, but one is a damn sight easier than the other.
@grapeDrank
But it's a lousy social networking device.
Sincerely,
iPhone 3GS owner
^ was for @grapeDrank
i love entelligence! Gartenberg's articles are short, concise and thought provoking!
I think this is more evidence of Microsoft starting to produce rounded products rather than mere platforms. It may not do everything, but that's because it's not supposed to. If it did everything Windows Phone 7 did, what would be the point of Windows Phone 7? And how pissed off would Microsoft's phone manufacturing partners be? This is more the tightly controlled Xbox versus Windows Phone's PC I think.
@Malcolm
The Kin1 is definitely a rounded product!
@Canucker I see what you did there
It's a riddle wrapped in an enigma wrapped in a pre-teen sleepover.
@semblance
...and designed to match my Ben10 constume outfit....ohh yeahhh! Now just make another one to match my hana montana undies and consider my brand loyality to be yours till I stop wetting my bed. Deal?
I agree completely with the whole concept of Marketing products toward demographics and even though I personally would like to see more flexibility from the platform I understand that I'm not the target and I guess that makes it okay. I just hope that Companies won't take this approach and attempt to fit each successive device into an ever shrinking niche that they believe needs to be filled.
@JohnDeSilva
"I agree completely with the whole concept of Marketing products toward demographics"
I love how this is some sort of revelation on these tech blogs. Welcome to remedial marketing.
@grapeDrank
I wonder how your mind works mate. 'oooooh, engadget post, lets go there as fast as possible and say the iphone is the greatest thing in the world regardless of the article. job done, now i can rub it against my iballs'
Smart market focused product; completely agree with Gartenberg
@grapeDrank So if 100,000 people have cars that constantly roll over and explode, and 1,000 people have cars that don't, the former is better?