Well, we can't say we didn't see this coming -- Judge William Alsup in the federal Northern District of California today dismissed Psystar's antitrust counterclaims
in Apple's copyright infringement lawsuit
against the wannabe Mac cloner. According to the judge, Psystar's hotshot legal team
failed to provide facts "plausibly supporting the counterintuitive claim that Apple's operating system is so unique that it suffers no actual or potential competitors." Not only that, but the judge also found that Psystar actually contradicted itself in pointing out that Apple has to advertise heavily to promote OS X against competing operating systems that perform the same tasks, and that Apple is "certainly entitled" to ask its customers to only use OS X on Apple machines. Yeah, that's a smackdown. Psystar has until December 18th to amend its complaint and try these arguments again, but we can't say we think it's got a shot in hell here -- and something tells us that that court-mandated alternative dispute resolution process
isn't going to get very far in Psystar's favor either.Disclaimer: Nilay's a lawyer and sells bootleg OSx86 machines out the back of his van, but he's not
your lawyer and this isn't legal advice.