Droid Incredible review

At this point, the HTC Incredible should seem like pretty familiar territory to our readers. We first caught wind of the device in a ROM leak back in December of 2009, and shortly thereafter saw lots of little snippets on the phone that made it clear it was headed our way. Of course, it's a potent combination that's been put together here -- an HTC-made, Verizon-locked device sporting a 1GHz Snapdragon CPU, 8GB of internal storage, 748MB of ROM, a microSD slot (with support for up to 32GB cards), an 8 megapixel camera with dual LED flash and autofocus, 480 x 800 AMOLED capacitive touchscreen, and most importantly, Android 2.1 with HTC's Sense UI on-board. The combo of America's largest (and some say best) 3G network with a super-fast, Sense-equipped Android phone is a match made in nerd heaven. We've seen a near-exact device in the HTC Desire -- basically the Incredible for the European market -- and the internals and screen technology are almost identical to the Nexus One, but the Incredible has a personality that's all its own. So is this the next killer device on the US market? Or have we heard this tune before? Read on for the answers you seek!

Droid Incredible hands-on

Hardware

As you've seen in the leaked photos (and more recently, press photos), HTC and Verizon have teamed up to make what looks like it would be a fairly tame, streamlined device into something decidedly edgier. Instead of going for a predictable smooth back, HTC has given the Incredible a tiered, weirdly angular soft-touch casing which the company says is meant to evoke the styling of a race car. We weren't immediately psyched on the concept, but after getting it into our hands, we'll admit that the decision wasn't completely crazy. It not only sets the device apart from its slate touchscreen contemporaries, but actually gives you a little something to hold onto when you've got the device in your grips. While it looks like this odd decision could add thickness to the phone, when we compared it side-by-side with the iPhone 3GS and Nexus One, they were all about even.

Beyond the racing flair, HTC has added some subtle red highlights on the phone (around the camera lens and on the ear-piece), but it's kept things pretty clean around the sides. Up top there's a sleep / power button on the left-hand side, a standard headphone jack on the right, and along the left side of the phone you've got a volume rocker and Micro USB connector. We definitely miss the inclusion of a dedicated mute switch on the recent crop of Android devices, and we wouldn't have complained about a camera button -- but those two minor niggles are certainly not deal breakers.

On the front of the device you've got that big, beautiful WVGA display, four touch-sensitive hard buttons (here arranged in HTC's familiar home, menu, back, and search configuration), plus an optical trackpad standing in for the typical trackball found on earlier phones. We were pleased to discover that the wonky sensitivity on the hard buttons we experience on the Nexus One were nowhere to be found here.

All in all, the Incredible looks and feels like a modern, sophisticated smartphone with a lot of that masculine edge that Motorola imparted to the Droid along with the curvy smoothness the Droid Eris sports. It's almost like the two devices mated (which kind of makes sense). It's a handsome phone, though we suspect some people will be bothered by the Verizon-inspired tweaks that have been made here.

Display

In general, the Incredible's display was very reminiscent of the Nexus One screen -- that should come as no surprise, they're identical -- though the touch response seemed notably better here, likely a software issue. Because these displays are the same, it means they share the same issues; we disliked the color intensity on the Incredible just as we did on the Nexus One. Reds and oranges, in particularly, look overwhelmingly saturated here, and other colors aren't truly represented. It's just too colorful, if you can believe it. Another somewhat major issue that we struggled with on the Incredible (just as we did on the Nexus One) was the awful screen visibility in bright daylight. We had numerous occasions where we simply could not answer a call or take a picture due to the AMOLED display's poor showing outdoors. In overcast settings (such as the one above) it was usually bearable, and If you crank the brightness all the way up on sunnier days you can get some visibility, though once you're outside and can't see the display, that's a bit of a challenge. In all honesty, we love certain aspects of these screens, but we're perplexed as to why HTC continues to use this same display when it's clear the daylight performance is hamstrung.

Camera

The camera is one of the big selling points of the Incredible. At 8 megapixels, it's obviously one of the highest resolution smartphone shooters on the market -- but is it any good? In our tests, we found the Incredible's camera capable of taking stunning photos -- particularly in daylight settings -- though it also has a few drawbacks that made it a little less usable than we would have liked. First the good though. Unlike other HTC cameras, there doesn't seem to be any color spotting or weird splotches here. When we took a snap, the reproduction was true to the source (or certainly as true as other cameras we've tested). The shutter speed is fairly quick, though by no means Palm Pre quick, even with the review option switched off. You take pictures using the trackpad button, though we would have liked an option to take pics with an onscreen trigger as well, as pushing in the rather shallow trackpad caused the camera to shake a bit. Another issue we had was that the autofocus seemed to shoot first and ask questions later, meaning that on a number of occasions it appeared to have locked on to its subject and snapped a photo, but the results were rather blurry. We had a similar issue with the flash, where we felt it was jumping the gun just enough to blow out a lot of the images we tried to take. Those issues aside, the more time we spent with the Incredible's camera, the more used to it we got, and by the end of this review period (which admittedly wasn't as long as we would have liked), we were getting pretty handy with it. We had particularly good results when we switched the metering mode to centered.

Droid Incredible test photos

The Incredible also does fairly high resolution video -- up to 800 x 480. We would have liked to see a 720p option here, but we realize we're being hopeless romantics. Regardless, the higher res video did a decent, if somewhat pixelated and slightly stutttery, job at capturing a beautiful Brooklyn sunset. We had better results at VGA resolution, but both modes were more than acceptable for basic shooting. Just don't expect this to stand in for your HD camcorder, and you'll be all set.

800 X 480

640 X 480

Sound quality / speakerphone

As you may know, we loved the sound quality on the Motorola Droid. In fact, we think it's probably the best sounding phone we've ever used. We didn't get quite as excited about the Nexus One (tinny, not loud enough), but the Incredible has seriously jockeyed for Moto's spot here. The earpiece on this device is loud and clear, but never painful on the 'drums, while the speakerphone is excellent for both conversations and video / audio playback. It's a really solid speaker which should be more than sufficient for conference callers and voracious media snackers alike. Bravo guys!

Storage

In a somewhat new move for Android phone, HTC has equipped the Incredible with 8GB of internal storage as well as a MicroSD slot which can handle an additional 32GB -- giving you a whopping potential 40GB of space for your goods. We love the idea of a hardwired option for content storage, but HTC has some problems with this implementation. Firstly, many apps currently available in the Android Market which utilize an SD card for offloading data aren't able to see the internal storage at all, which means if you drag some APKs you want to install or want to download some data when you're in an app, you're out of luck. It just simply doesn't see it. This was especially problematic with the NYC Bus & Subway Maps application which requires a download of the train maps, and when we tried to run Nesoid (a popular NES emulator), it not only couldn't find ROMs saved on the phone's storage, but it force closed when we tried to move up a directory! This may not seem like a big deal, but more than once when using the phone we hit this brick wall by not having an SD card present. For the $199 price tag on this thing, it wouldn't have killed HTC or Verizon to throw in even a 2GB card to make the transition easier.

Software

We're not going to go into excessive detail on Android 2.1 and the Sense UI present on this phone, as you can read all the details on the software in our previous reviews of the Desire and the Legend, though there are tweaks and additions here that are worth making mention of.

Firstly, we need to talk about the differences between Android 2.1 with and without the Sense UI. If you've looked at a Nexus One (or own one), then you probably know that the experience with the UI is a mixed bag. Some portions of the software have been dramatically cleaned up, while others seem to be left on the cutting room floor. That's absolutely not the case with 2.1 and Sense. Basically, the Incredible -- and all devices with that combo -- feel like complete, polished, modern smartphones, with none of the perks or features missing. In particular, the homescreens have been massively expanded here, giving you seven screens in which to store icons and widgets... and there are a lot of widgets. HTC has included a handful of its own widgets alongside some of the familiar stock ones which Google offers. Of course, the widgets (and their corresponding apps) which HTC offers generally offer far more functionality than Google's options, and they're also tied together with Sense in way that makes the experience of using them within the OS feel complete -- something notably missing from the Google-only experience. To say that this UI is competitive with something like iPhone OS 3.1 (or 4 for that matter), or Palm's webOS is an understatement; in many ways it's superior to what Apple and Palm are offering.

HTC has done a marvelous job in tweaking Sense in all the right places. The first Sense device we tested was the Hero, which we found to be seriously lacking in the horsepower department, resulting in an experience that was sluggish and disappointing. The performance of the Incredible couldn't have been more opposite. The phone never hiccuped, and scrolling between pages or up and down long lists happened without hesitation. Not only was the UI blazingly fast and responsive -- even with all seven homescreens running heavy widgets -- but as we mentioned previously, the touchscreen response on this phone seem remarkably better than its contemporaries, which leads us to believe that HTC has honed the software in this regard as well. That sensitivity comes in especially handy when using HTC's new pinch feature on the homescreens, which brings up a "card" view of all your pages. The only spot where we noticed any kind of slowdown was when using the live wallpapers -- we're not really big fans of the concept to begin with, but it did seem to make the homescreen frame rate visibly more sluggish. Besides just the cosmetic stuff, HTC has also done seriously heavy lifting in the details department, continuing to improve the music, video, and photo browsing options on their devices, as well as making their fantastic on-screen keyboard even better in this higher resolution version. We found finger tracking and typing speed to be considerably improved, as well as word prediction and correction. Apple, watch your back... HTC has done a damn good job of sneaking up on your tech, and maybe improving on it. We can't stress this enough: HTC has made a really good OS (Android) into a truly amazing and competitive OS. HTC has even improved upon the copy and paste functions of the phone, making the process much more iPhone-like, but expanding on that with options to share and look up your selections via a context menu. Oh, and did we mention the amazing new text flow in the browser? No matter how far you zoom in, HTC's software will reflow the text you're looking at to make it zoomable. It's pretty amazing, actually. We don't know why Google doesn't just collaborate with the company in a more formal fashion, because no one else has been able to deliver this cohesive and enjoyable of an experience with Android.

It should also be noted that the browser on these phones is equipped with Flash lite, though we had lots of trouble getting videos to play on many of the sites we visited (Engadget included). If someone was hoping to convince us that Flash could work on a device like this, consider the job unfinished.

Verizon and HTC have collaborated on a few perks in the OS as well, cleaning up the Google Navigation, er, navigation, and also collapsing Visual Voicemail into the messaging app on the phone, making it easier to get at all your communications at once. We're Google Voice users (which of course perfectly integrates with the device), so we didn't spend much time with Verizon's version. HTC was also happy to point out that its email app supports multiple Exchange, POP, or IMAP accounts with a unified inbox -- something that should please a number of enterprise users. Other bundled apps include Quickoffice, a PDF viewer, HTC's Teeter game, and Peep, the company's built-in Twitter client. A note about this latter application; we're big fans of HTC making Twitter an integrated part of its UI, but this app has the annoying habit of auto-updating your timeline and jumping to the most recent tweet, which makes this "solution" less than appealing. We ended up sticking with Seesmic, and probably will until HTC addresses this minor issue. One other item that cropped up -- which may or may not have to do with this being an unreleased device -- is that we got very different results for apps in the Market. Some programs we were looking for just simply didn't show up in our searches. We had the same problem with the Desire and Legend when testing, and HTC says it's looking into this problem, though we have yet to hear a proper explanation from the company on why this is occurring.

Overall the experience with 2.1 and Sense was a complete pleasure -- using the phone felt fast and efficient. We'd like to point out that we've been running the Incredible without any third party task managers, and without manually killing any applications. Android is designed to multitask without the need for utilities of the sort, and based on Steve Jobs' words from the recent iPhone OS 4 event, we were extra curious to see how this brand new build of the software would fare. We can tell you this -- it hasn't let us down yet, and we're not seeing any sluggish behavior or force closes on apps. If this OS has a need for management of its processes, we haven't experienced it yet.

Network / Battery life

As usual, Verizon's network was outstanding. We know everyone already accepts how rock-solid Big Red's connections are, but we'd like to point out that at various times while riding an NYC subway underground, the Incredible managed to squeeze connectivity out of the big V. In fact, when we first took the phone out of its box we were riding the train, and it picked up enough data to auto-update our time and location. Now that really is something.

As we said previously, we didn't have an enormous amount of time to test this device, but in the handful of days we had, we found battery life to be good, but not outstanding. In comparison to the Nexus One, it seemed to fare a bit worse; we could get through a day, but things were down to the wire by the end of the night. It's obvious that a lot of these widgets and background processes HTC is running are going to put a strain on your device, and given that we're pretty active with our smartphones, something is bound to give. Now keep in mind there's nothing really abnormal about the battery life on the Incredible -- it's just not going to wow you.

Wrap-up

Let's just put this out there: the Droid Incredible is the best Android device that you can purchase in America right now. It's better than the Droid, better than the Nexus One, and certainly beats the pants off of any previous generation handsets like the Eris, myTouch, or Cliq. It's not just a very, very good Android phone (though it is); it's also an excellent smartphone no matter how you cut it. If you're on Verizon right now, you're finally getting really great options for phones, but the Incredible is currently sitting at the top of that heap with a good bit of distance to the next in line. Sure, there are still issues like a lack of quality titles in the Android Market, and if a hardware keyboard is a must, this won't do the job for you. Also, while Sense is truly great on this phone, there may be users who prefer a more streamlined, stripped down experience. Still, if you're looking for an ultra-fast, extremely capable smartphone that has the guts and gleam to go the distance, the Incredible just might be the Droid you're looking for. Yes, we made that joke.

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:31AM]

Truly remarkable phone 0_0

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:32AM]

@Alexpeegs sorry I just read the conclusion :D

[victorvelasco1 Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:33AM]

@Alexpeegs we want Evo!

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:36AM]

@victorvelasco1 I wants Incrediblezzz. anywayz I preordered just now

[tbonez Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:38AM]

Remarkable phone yes, sadly it's somewhat wasted on Android. This is why HTC needs to buy Palm so it can release phones like these running webOS.

[Vellie Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:38AM]

@Alexpeegs The pictures are "Incredible"

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:40AM]

@tbonez Ohh please you've never even used a sense UI phone so stop lying

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:40AM]

@Vellie haha you mean that beautiful AMOLED screen :p

[statickeith Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:44AM]

@victorvelasco1 totally man, EVO 4G/Supersonic is gonna kill every other smartphone in the market. Even the iPhone!

[JS Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:55AM]

@Alexpeegs

Here's my review:

No front facing camera, it sucks.

[camroncake Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:55AM]

Damn you CDMA, now I can't have this phone anywhere else

[John Stathakis Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:00AM]

@Alexpeegs I'd buy that bitch so, so hard... if it were coming out a few months ago. im bailing from verizon, the sprint coverage is about as good where i live and the evo is calling my name.

[Greenverde Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:00AM]

@Alexpeegs

Why can't something like this be on AT&T? We don't all want iPhones...

[Complex Pants Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:09AM]

@Greenverde Nexus One? The incredible is kind of like HTC's remix of the Nexus One.

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:10AM]

@Greenverde ...but AT&T want you to have iphones so that sucks for you. It must suck D:

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:12AM]

@JS too bad Evo doesn't do skype cause verizon exclusived that S%&* so I don't see any point in having a front facing camera lol

[Alexpeegs Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:13AM]

@John Stathakis Yeah man If the Evo was on verizon I'd be buying that Bitch too

[tbonez Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:28AM]

@Alexpeegs

I have a used a Windows Mobile phone running Sense UI (HTC Diamond) and even currently own an HTC Hero. Android to me is little more than a glorified version of Windows Mobile. Clunky and disconnected. Not nearly as aesthetic, intuitive, or innovative as both iPhone OS or webOS. This love affair with all things Google has to stop! They could come out with gCrap and everyone would go crazy for it.

[Miakandogadget Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:09AM]

It's a beast.

[ZEXXES1 Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:13AM]

@John Stathakis The EVO is calling my name too! I feel you!

[Vamadeus Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:24AM]

@tbonez I don't think it's a waste by any means, but it would be really cool to see this phone run WebOS. This is the hardware Palm should have used.

[lv2bll54 Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:30AM]

2 real flaws with this outstanding phone

1. the camera will get butchered with it protruding out like that

2. I already decided to get an EVO

but still a great phone!!

p.s. ANDROID FTW!!!!

[Outsider Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:30AM]

Everyone: Please low-rank idiots who thought they were clever by making a blatant pun on this phone's name.

[juanvaldez Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:31AM]

@Alexpeegs You can still use 3rd party (non-skype branded apps) to access Skype's video chat.

[Leeknows Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:53AM]

@camroncake If you don't mind having a flat back then get the Desire. It's GSM and is almost identical inside.

[AlexSanchez Posted Apr 19th 2010 3:03AM]

@victorvelasco1 sprint, thats a call out!

[scioncas Posted Apr 19th 2010 3:20AM]

@Alexpeegs No denying that. But my N1 feels so sad when it sees engadget looking down on it and praising other devices. There is no mayor gap between the two of them.

[Miakangadget Posted Apr 19th 2010 4:05AM]

This gets my dick wet.

[TareG Posted Apr 19th 2010 8:45AM]

@victorvelasco1 If they did this good a job with the Incredible, I can't begin to imagine how awesome the EVO will be...

[giajunko Posted Apr 19th 2010 9:01AM]

@Alexpeegs The Sense UI makes it look sexier. Looking forward for the Evo! Reactions to Incredible. http://bit.ly/droid-incredible-by-htc-video

[doutorpiranha Posted Apr 19th 2010 9:03AM]

remarkable?

ah yes, remarkably tacky and fugly

[FrancisL4D Posted Apr 19th 2010 9:40AM]

@Alexpeegs: I've used Sense UI (HTC Hero, now an HTC HD2), and I'd have to agree with tbonez that I would LOVE to see HTC buy Palm.

Who WOULDN'T want to see what HTC's Sense team could do with an underlying OS like WebOS, consider what they've done with both WinMo and Android...?

[InfinityDevil Posted Apr 19th 2010 10:15AM]

@statickeith It will also kill its own battery, I'm sure.

That said, more devices = more open competition = better smartphone ecosystem for all!

[meeit Posted Apr 19th 2010 10:22AM]

@Alexpeegs Are you broken?
http://www.skype.com/download/skype/android/

[crawdad689 Posted Apr 19th 2010 10:27AM]

@Alexpeegs

Wow. It's absolutely awe-inspiring to witness this OS and ecosystem go from 0-100 in only the last 1+ years. HTC + Google is a completely winning combination, and there's no doubt that the coming years will be an absolute boon for them. They are a force to be reckoned with, and I wouldn't be surprised if they gain market-share EVERY SINGLE QUARTER, for the next x years.


That was a wonderfully written review, Josh. You hit on all of the points I was interested, and gave the perfect amount of detail. It proves yet again that Engadget lacks the severe Apple bias that Apple bashers swear up and down is rampant. Plain and simple, you guys love well-made handsets, and you never shy away from the appropriate amount of criticism/praise. Your analysis is always spot-on. Bravo.

[Frankenstein Black Posted Apr 19th 2010 10:36AM]

@Alexpeegs - Agreed! HTC P0WNs!!!
Verizon (and crap CDMA) on the other hand Sux Azz!
And will continue to suck until they launch LTE!
Then they wont suck. Sayin...

[Plexus Posted Apr 19th 2010 11:51AM]

@Alexpeegs

I got my HTC Desire last week and I can confirm that it really is the top of the pops.
I loved my old Hero but this is on another planet altogether.
I'm still holding tight to my (other) HTC HD2 though; although I consider myself an Android guy, the HD2 is just too good to let it go.

[tmzt Posted Apr 19th 2010 11:57AM]

@John Stathakis Sprint coverage meaning CDMA or WiMAX?

[credo Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:28PM]

"We're not going to go into excessive detail on Android 2.1 and the Sense UI present on this phone" ...5 paragraphs later, lolz

And the AMOLED screen is nice, not super, just nice. (super > incredible: things that make you go hmm...)

[angermeans Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:44PM]

@Greenverde +1 Yes, we all do not want iPhones. Come on ATT we shouldn't have to spend $520 to get a great Android 2.1 Phone. Get off the iPhone train and get with the future. When the time comes iPhone and Apple are going to drop you like a hot potato and you will be left with severely crippled phones like the Aero and Backflip that many people don't want.

[msatlas Posted Apr 19th 2010 12:49PM]

You can use Fring to make Skype calls just fine.

[Lord Vader Posted Apr 19th 2010 1:03PM]

The force is strong with you Engadget. That last line proves it

[LordDarkHelmet Posted Apr 19th 2010 2:04PM]

@Lord Vader the Schwartz is strong with you my friend,

[Lord Vader Posted Apr 19th 2010 4:22PM]

@LordDarkHelmet. I'm sorry, usually i would brutally maim you at this time. But, Engadget...they..they... they seem to have triggered an emotion inside me....they referenced my men's mistake...and made a joke of it...they gave a tip of the hat...is this a tear in my eye...Wait, WHAT THE? Who left this Sizzling Onion here?

[sonicwind Posted Apr 19th 2010 4:54PM]

@ZEXXES1 Me too. 4G in my city!!!

[normac88 Posted Apr 21st 2010 1:39PM]

@Complex Pants HTC made the nexus one

[jamor Posted Apr 25th 2010 10:02PM]

@sonicwind Sorry Sprint is not going 4g - it is just an enhanced 3g.

Verizon is going to real 4g first (LTE). Sorry you got scammed =/

Do your research before you buy technology.

[GSpot Posted May 14th 2010 7:41AM]

@lv2bll54, I disagree with you regarding the camera issue. Because the camera uses a flat lens, just as with watches that have a flat crystal, they have proven to be less susceptible to getting scratched and the zoom feature on the camera works internally not externally.

[huzzlehoff Posted Jul 2nd 2010 3:34AM]

@Alexpeegs
Should definitely be 9/10 on scorecards

[jrolls Posted Jul 2nd 2010 9:07PM]

@Complex Pants lol HTC made the nexus one though.