Blue Laser Wars Cont.

Ken Weeks
K. Weeks|03.12.06

Sponsored Links

Ken Weeks
March 12th, 2006
In this article: format wars, FormatWars
Blue Laser Wars Cont.
Blue Laser Wars Cont.

Following up on their useful examination of HD-DVD, TeamXbox has published an easy-to-understand run-down of the facts concerning Sony's Blu-Ray (aka Beta-Ray) format. They're even kind enough to summarize their own article:
  • Blu-ray Disc has a higher storage capacity per layer than HD DVD.
  • Blu-ray Disc has a higher transfer rate and recording speed that HD DVD as the result of using a higher value of NA.
    • At 10,000 rpm rotation speed results in a 12X Blu-ray Disc drive while that is equal to 9X HD DVD.
    • Therefore, HD DVD is required to rotate at higher speeds to reach the same transfer rates of Blu-ray Disc.
  • Blu-ray Disc media has a different internal structure than HD DVD and DVD. Thickness is the same for the discs, but different for the layers inside.
  • As a result, hybrid discs are easier to develop on Blu-ray Disc because of the format’s 0.1mm thickness for the data layer. A single side Blu-ray Disc could incorporate a dual layer DVD-9 (8.5GB) disc, but in the case of HD DVD, that requires a double side disc.
  • HD DVD media is less expensive to manufacture than Blu-ray Disc because it doesn’t require significant changes to existing production lines.
 However many gigs your rearview mirror ornament of choice ends up packing, I tend to agree with Mr. Gate's that this latest format war is a loser's game. The future has to lie somewhere beyond getting off the couch to change discs. It's too much like switching channels without a remote.

[previously: HD-DVD vs. Beta-Ray]
All products recommended by Engadget are selected by our editorial team, independent of our parent company. Some of our stories include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Popular on Engadget