Arena.net lays out Guild Wars RMT policy

Though the Guild Wars terms of service have never allowed players to trade in-game currency for real money, this past week Arena.net laid out – in no uncertain terms – what they think of the practice. Their anti-RMT policy is extremely harshly worded, going so far as to use the phrase 'illegal' to describe these third-party transactions. The policy clarifies why they feel this hard-line approach is required, and details some of the steps they use to address the problem. Apparently the company bans some 5,000 accounts a week over this issue, and claim to have GMs monitoring the issue 24 hours a day.

The PlayNoEvil Game Security blog clarifies an issue we have with the statement: by definition this practice is not illegal. It's against the game's EULA, to be sure, but Arena.net and other game developers are not (that I'm aware of) empowered to sway the American justice system. While we certainly find the idea of buying gold a bit strange, throwing around words like 'illegal' is a poor idea. They also insinuate that gold farmers (as a rule) are installing keyloggers and hacking accounts. While obviously that's the case in some circumstances, we tend to think that's a pretty broad brush to pain that group with. That's a question for you: do you consider the actions of gold farmers actively illegal? Should they be?