Poetic Justice: A Haiku about your ISP
comcast you bastard stop raising my monthly bill regional sports fees
Read MoreWilliam Smolen
Engadget Editorial Policies
The unique content on Engadget is a result of skilled collaboration between writers and editors with broad journalistic, academic, and practical expertise.
In pursuit of our mission to provide accurate and ethical coverage, the Engadget editorial team consistently fact-checks and reviews site content to provide readers with an informative, entertaining, and engaging experience. Click here for more information on our editorial process.
Stories By William Smolen
-
-
Opinion: The Fragmented Reality of Modern Android
I'm something of an Android fanboy. After having an iPhone for three years, I was uncomfortable with the lack of freedom I had with the device. Make no bones about it - the iPhone is a beautiful display of what's possible when manufacturers successfully synergize their hardware and software. It rarely disappoints its common user by consistently maintaining a reputation of reliability; put simply, the device is intuitive and it works. For the majority of smartphone users, the above value proposition hits expectations. However, this simply wasn't enough for me. I craved additional features to mirror PC capabilities, and the iPhone simply didn't offer these - barring a jailbroken iPhone. In 2013, I wasn't quite sure which Android devices were worth the money. It was a technology that I wasn't interested, to that point, and I lacked any trusted individual opinions - after all, to the majority of my peers, I'm the one they go to with questions. At the time, I was employed by the retailer formerly known as RadioShack (I kid - the brand and many of its properties were recently sold) . A coworker consistently pushed his Galaxy S4 into my hands, convinced it was far superior to my iPhone 5, and forced me to, at the very least, give the UI a try. What I found was a far better Android experience than what I was expecting; the touch screen was responsive, the software was intuitive, but ultimately, the level of customization blew me away. I soon learned that the impression made that day was, in many respects, unique to the Samsung Galaxy line, and a symptom of a much larger problem: the Android ecosystem is a very broken, fragmented, mess. This mess stands out to me for one primary reason - users invest hundreds of dollars every year in the most powerful smartphones on the market, but find themselves losing their stream of software updates in a matter of months. It took me some time to understand why this problem prominently exists within the Android ecosystem. As Google continues to update their mobile OS, the responsibility is currently on both the Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) and the carriers to push changes out to their users. Given the profit seeking motive of any business, these updates seem to quickly disappear as phones become outdated. After all, why spend money on developing for an outdated piece of hardware that isn't generating revenues when compared to the latest flagship? This fragmentation creates a massive security risk, among a whole host of other issues. But as long as OEMs find it necessary to develop their own in-house software to overlay the core Android Open Source Project (AOSP), what other recourse does Google have? Redditor /u/Javiguer recently posted a wonderful alternative to the system in place: modularize, as Javiguer phrases it, the AOSP. In order to make system-level changes to any Android phone, one must acquire, what is known as, root permission on their device. This opens another can of security risks as potential malware can now execute dangerous actions at a very deep level. But one could easily argue that the pros of 'rooting' an Android device heavily outweigh the cons. One of the best applications, if you can call it that, available to users that root their devices is named Xposed. This application acts as a secondary 'app store', if you will, and enables the user to install a host of packaged modules, enabling a much deeper level of customization on the phone. If you're interested in learning more about Xposed, check out the XDA Forums, but for all intents and purposes, understand that it enables you to change system-level functions across your Android device. Xposed is not officially endorsed by Google, but as /u/Javiguer explains, the methodology behind the root-requiring application could be the solution to this horrific fragmentation problem. Rather than enable OEMs to flat out overwrite the AOSP, any OEM-level changes would be optional 'modules' that the user could enable and disable at will. This setup would maintain the core AOSP as the root of the hardware and simplify, from a technical end, the actual updating process. OEMs would be free to push updates to their modules as they please, but it would seem utterly irresponsible at that point to not support the latest AOSP builds when it requires so little work to push the update. Why does this matter? Well, Google clearly thinks there's significant value in the AOSP vs the OEM versions of the software as they released an entire line of devices, known as the Nexus family, based on the simplicity of AOSP. These devices are also generally supported via software updates for far longer than their OEM counterparts, as Google owns the direct channel necessary to push over-the-air (OTA) updates to the Nexus devices. It's also far easier for Google to keep these devices updated for longer periods of time as the hardware is designed to support the core project. In other words, when Google wants to update one Nexus device vs another, they need to make far fewer changes between iterations of the same software. Hopefully Google conquers this problem soon. Apple was wise enough to avoid the possibility of fragmentation by maintaining a singular product line supporting iOS, and refusing to license out the software/open up the source code. The downside of such a scenario is a less diverse array of options available to consumers. Apple has sole control over the direction of iOS and the phones that support it.
Read More -
Growing Up Geek: Billy Smolen
The king has arrived. Reading through some of the other pieces in the Growing Up Geek category, I've come to realize I'm younger than most Engadget contributors. Born in 1994, the internet has been a mainstay in my life. Growing up, the computer room, the affectionate name for my dad's office, was my kingdom and the spinnytwisty chair was my throne. And though our old Gateway was largely a glorified Snood machine, I was fascinated by how it was all possible. Born and raised Jewish in the northern suburbs of Chicago, I experienced my first Christmas morning in the June of 1999; I awoke to find a strange looking repairman exiting my basement, followed by my parents. Little did I know, he had just 'installed' the Nintendo 64 that would become a focal point of my childhood (and college days). To that point, I had only experienced the joy of PC gaming, specifically everything and anything published from Humongous Entertainment. My older sister and I spent hours playing that console and the oh-so-few games we had to chose from. When she grew tired of the games, I shared the passion with my best friend Ross. And when Ross received Ocarina of Time for his sixth birthday, the rest was history. Our allegiance to the Zelda series kept us busy for a number of years. Now, it is worth noting that I forced Ross to name the profile in OoT after me (Billy5 to be exact) - he still won't let me live that down. He and I spent hours in our basements together playing through a variety of games, though the Zelda series occupied most of our time. If we got stuck in a video game, we would try to decipher the pictures in the cheat-manuals; of course, we couldn't actually read back then. When we got bored, we reverted to 'fixing' his dad's old Pachinko machine - unfortunately, we never achieved that goal. We even launched our own business at age six (with tremendous help from Ross' dad) by manifesting our own take on Pokemon cards in Microsoft Word. The result was a hand-made trading card, depicting a black and white stick figure, which we marketed and sold through a Microsoft Publisher website. We even had one sale, outside of our families! I hesitate to state that sale was actually addressed toward some sort of Ohio detainment center - not kidding. But at a quarter a pop, that was a bargain, right? Ross and I continued to fuel each other's passion for technology, though only he went on to formally study computer science (at Washington University in St. Louis). Our interests weren't always perfectly aligned, and I would say my path was the riskier of the two. By 2004, I found myself frequenting a group of online forums (the Invisionfree community, for the initiated) despite a federal law prohibiting my use of such communication media: the COPPA. These message boards provided an opportunity to find more like-minded geeks that my primary schools seemed to lack. I successfully hid my age from my new-found online friends and was able to participate in discussions spanning a wide-variety of technologies and games. I started to teach myself basic HTML and CSS through the Invisionfree platform. I was actively reading up on emerging technologies and plotting to launch my own web host (by means of a reseller package - I thought it was genius). I envied the technicians that occasionally came into our home and I glorified the geek's lifestyle. Middle school was a rough time (even Ross attended a different middle school in the same town), but these online communities and blogs became my safe haven. Yet for whatever reason, this passion of mine was something I was ashamed of and I did everything I could to hide it from just about anybody I came in contact with. The social anxieties have certainly subsided, and I had a much better time in high school than I did in middle school (as I'm sure most would say). I don't know who I would really be without the geek inside me. It's a great feeling when you can say, with a high degree of certainty, that you truly know who you are at heart. Though my interests have certainly evolved since my early teenage days, and my social skills are greatly improved, I'm still the same geek at heart. Ross and I started to freelance during our Junior year of high school, which led me to an interest in the consulting industry. Today, I'm a rising Senior at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign studying Finance and Information Systems & Information Technology (ISIT). I'll be aiming for a career in the IT Consulting field, more specifically in Analytics, but I've always enjoyed creative writing. I'm not one to do multiple drafts, nor will I claim to have phenomenal writing expertise, but I look forward to actively contributing in this role and I applaud Engadget for engaging its audience in such a manner. I'll definitely be taking a stronger interest in this role than I did in my athletic career.
Read More
