Cashless businesses can be efficient and convenient while acting as a barrier against robbers looking to steal a stack of bills. However, they can exclude people without a bank account or those who can't or don't want to load funds onto a prepaid debit card, which often charge fees.
"It just seemed to me unfair that I could walk into a coffee shop right across from City Hall, and I had a credit card and could get a cup of coffee. And the person behind me, who had United States currency, could not," Councilman Bill Greenlee, a bill co-sponsor, told the New York Times. A spokesman for Mayor Jim Kenney, who signed the bill into law last week, noted to the Wall Street Journal that 26 percent of city residents are below the poverty line.
Similar legislation is under consideration in cities including New York, San Francisco, Chicago and Washington, DC. In New Jersey, the legislature has approved a bill which now just needs Governor Phil Murphy's signature to become law. Massachusetts, meanwhile, has long required businesses to accept cash.
There are a few exemptions to the Philly law, namely parking garages and lots, online and phone transactions, retailers with a membership model (such as Costco) and companies where a credit card deposit is usually necessary, like hotels and rental car businesses.
There's also a measure that could exempt stores like the cashierless Amazon Go chain. The provision allows cashless "transactions at retail stores selling consumer goods exclusively through a membership model that requires payment by means of an affiliated mobile device application." However, Amazon reportedly told the city Go stores would still be affected, because consumers don't have to be Prime members to shop there. They only need an Amazon account.