In a response to the thread Rauss of Sentinels disagreed. He believes that a Paladin tank should not rely on Judgments to build threat. Rauss relies on Consecration, Hammer of Righteousness, and select Seals/Judgments to build aggro- depending on the situation. He thinks the original poster should expand to additional aspects of the class to realize its true potential.
I haven't had the pleasure of running with a Pally tank since the patch. If threat generation has truly been nerfed, the whole group must throttle down and adjust in order to keep the tank tanking. What has been your experience as (or with) Paladin tanks since the patch?