But let's start with praise because there are big chunks of the game that deserve it -- namely, the entirety of the Going Rogue starter experience and most major subsequent arcs. The stories unveiled as you work as a Loyalist or Resistance member are interesting and diverse, and they remain that way even if you're leveling another Loyalist or Resistance member. Even though the choices you make frequently have little in-game benefit, you really feel like you're moving through a story made just for you, with plenty of chances for you to make your own mark on things.
More to the point, the Going Rogue starter experience is especially noteworthy because it reaches that rarest of goals: creating morally ambiguous choices that are actually morally ambiguous. You have to choose, for example, whether to help the terrorists fighting for absolute freedom in service to one man's lost daughter or to help the police apprehending a dangerous criminal with a desperate need to help others. Both sides are good and bad at the same time. The choices, and the stories that result, are engaging.
And that's one of the reasons the starter areas for both heroes and villains desperately needed a revamp: Not only was the presentation of those stories dull as heck, but there was barely a story to be told in the first place.
Huge chunks of City of Heroes sadly follow what I like to call the mission salad formula. A contact has you fighting enemy group X, and then he throws in a certain number of missions involving enemy group X until you move on to a different group. You've got some street sweeper missions, some missions to click glowies, and a "kill everything" mission or two, and you just do these in whatever order until you run out of missions.
Sure, there were hints of a story there. Generally, that story amounted to a restatement of fact mixed with Mad Libs. "THE CIRCLE OF THORNS have taken over AN OFFICE BUILDING where they ARE STASHING ARTIFACTS in order to MAKE PIZZA, so you have to RETRIEVE the ARTIFACTS and SO I CAN JUST TYPE ANYTHING HERE AND IT SHOWS UP." There's no sense of buildup or development; you're just running down missions until you've finished with a given area.
City of Villains got the idea of having a single arc story to work right, but all of the arcs were still completely isolated. Sadly, they remain so even late in the game: There's nothing tying one story arc to any others, and as a result there's still not much sense of your character's having moved through a single story. Nemesis will curse at you if you've been taking missions to fight him non-stop or you've never seen him before in your life. (I know, you're probably just seeing a duplicate, but bear with me.) Elements all exist in isolation.
Of course, Faultline has the exact opposite problem. It's a zone with a single coherent storyline, but if for whatever reason you outlevel one, you wind up tossed several chapters ahead. So that's a bit problematic.
The thing is, several of these individual arcs are good. Some of them are even downright excellent. And there are questgivers who have a whole lot of personality and really get you engaged in what's happening. Many of the later arcs really do just what they ought to do -- they make you feel like you're building up into a climax. The signature arc has thus far done a great job of ramping up the tension and keeping the player involved the whole way through, making each installment part of a coherent whole.
Ultimately, though, CoH suffers in its story department partly because it just can't replicate its source material. If you think of each character as a superhero, then each character is really in his or her own title -- and there's no sense of that, really. You're running through these messes without the feeling that you're part of an overall story path. Is that something that's really avoidable with the limitations of the medium? Probably not. Is it still a little upsetting? Yeah.
But there's a lot of really good stuff in there. Story, in CoH, is sometimes lacking and often incoherent when viewed up-close. Get a little bit of distance, though, and there's a coherent picture, and there are bits mixed in that are flat-out brilliant.
Comments can be left in the comment field below, like usual, or mailed along to firstname.lastname@example.org. By next week, we'll have nearly moved into the new year, so I'm going to take the opportunity to look back at the previous year for CoH. There were some big changes, after all.
By day a mild-mannered reporter, Eliot Lefebvre unveils his secret identity in Paragon City and the Rogue Isles every Wednesday. Filled with all the news that's fit to analyze and all the muck that's fit to rake, this look at City of Heroes analyzes everything from the game's connection to its four-color roots to the latest changes in the game's mechanics.