Guardian changes hinted at for Book 12
Book 11 is currently on the Preview Server, but the LotRO devs are already hinting at what's to come in Book 12. Continuing their class by class revamp, the devs have marked Guardians, the tank class of the game, as the next to get a look over.
Players excitedly compiled lists of improvements they would like to see for this class. Dev Hakai chimed in on the thread to let the Guardians know about two upcoming changes planned for Book 12.
First, Guardians will be gaining a dps stance. The new stance will be centered around the 2 handed axe skill that will increase their damage output. New skills will be introduced to support the stance as well. I'm guessing the stance will also decrease their armor while it's active. I'd also hazard a guess that, like the Minstrel's new dps stance, Warspeech, it will be a toggle so the Guardian can jump in to tank an add when needed.
Many other games have tried the "dps stance for tanks" trick with varying results. The biggest problem is groups not wanting to fill a dps slot in the party with a second-tier dps'er. The only way it makes a dps'ing Guardian attractive is if you know you're going to need a second tank at some point in your evening's adventures. World of Warcraft feral druids are a good example of that working (although they also bring emergency healing as well.)
The biggest benefit to the Guardian is, of course, soloing. Playing through the solo quests is all about dps and tank classes (and healer classes) are painfully slow at this. I'm sure Turbine will be looking very carefully at the new Minstrel Warspeech stance in Book 11 when implementing the similar Guardian stance.
The other news from Hakai was not good. Shield Taunt is getting a nerf. The Guardian skill was designed to help the class gain a good chunk of threat, but the way it is currently implemented, it sends Guardians straight to the top of the hate list. This skill is being modified to the original intention of the creators and the Guardians are losing a powerful panic button.
I'm sure Guardians are going to scream loud and long about this one complete with petitions, sit-ins and the usual melodrama that accompanies major skill nerfs. But sometimes you just have to bite the bullet for class balance. Plus, without an emergency taunt, Guardians are now forced to be more aware of their threat. And that makes for better players.
More details should be trickling out soon about other Guardian changes as Book 12 inches closer to going up on the Preview Server.
