sexual-dimorphism
Latest
Sexual dimorphism in Cataclysm
Three years ago, I read this article by Annalee Newitz on sexual dimorphism in WoW, promptly filing it away in my head as one of those interesting quirks about the game and games in general. What really struck me at the time were the alpha pictures of trolls and tauren. While I like the current tauren female model, I'm not terribly enamored of troll ladies, if only because 95 percent of them (not an actual statistic) seem to choose the same blandly "pretty" face. Alpha troll women seemed to share a lot more of the troll male's features, with more pronounced tusks, sharper profiles and more of a hunch like the men. In general, I found these alpha models fascinating. Also interesting to note was that this trend goes both ways: when blood elves debuted, the males were much closer to the females and were beefed up in The Burning Crusade beta. As Annalee Newitz pointed out, the other race that debuted in BC, the draenei, are extremely dimorphic; males are bigger and more massively muscular than orcs, while their females are far less mesomorphic. What interested me, at least so far as the tauren and troll model changes went, is that players complained that the tauren and troll women weren't to their liking, which most likely had an influence on the design of draenei and blood elves. Now, with Cataclysm, we have two new races to consider. How do the worgen and goblins stack up on the dimorphism scale?
Idealizing avatar bodies
There is an impressive and fascinating study on avatar bodies from World of Warcraft over at the Iris Gaming Network. The main thrust of the article is how much the average avatar skews toward traditional tropes of beauty, even (or especially) the non-human races. This addresses a couple of the issues I wrote about in this post -- namely, the lack of a wide range of body shape choices other than heroic.The article mentions the controversy surrounding the introduction of the males of the Blood Elf race, and how Blizzard changed them from their original thin forms to a more muscled shape, and how the community reacted. A great quote from the piece: "From a player's point of view, Blizzard has denied many people the ability to play a character like them, or a character they would like to be. The extreme sexual dimorphism in the races, and the way that Blizzard is quick to "fix" avatars that do not properly fit the ideal, has sent the message to those outside of that body type – not just women, but men as well – that they are not worthy of being represented, that their body types are not good enough for even one avatar in the entire game to represent them."Have a read of the entire article, and post your thoughts.[Via Iris Gaming Network]
