A few notes before we start:
A note on set bonuses
- I'm assuming you don't have access to ICC-10 or -25, at least not on a regular basis. For all I know, maybe you play on a realm where bored players are pugging heroic Lich King-25, but that's not the situation most bears new to 80 will be in. When it comes to pugging raids, tanks tend to be subjected to more scrutiny than other players, and it's my assumption that you are interested in gearing a bear in order to tank rather than looking for pieces relevant to content you're already doing.
- I'm assuming you probably have access to Onyxia, Vault of Archavon and (maybe) some ToC. Most servers have PUGs running this content fairly regularly (if not, start one!). Trial of the Crusader is a sticky wicket, but after waffling over my "Must not assume they're raiding! Must not assume they're raiding!" rule, I've compromised and listed the ilevel 245, tier 9 pieces available if you get your hands on a Trophy of the Crusade. With many players upgrading to tier 10 right now, there is much less competition for these.
- I'm not assuming you're an arena star: Everyone can get Relentless and Furious gear these days with a little elbow grease, but Wrathful set pieces still require an arena rating to get, so screw that.
- This is not a comprehensive list. There are a lot of PvP pieces here, but I've listed only the Furious or above pieces. I think it's a waste of time to grind honor toward anything below that. I've also eliminated most of the pieces we've previously covered in our February 2009 guide to bear gear. You may want to take a look at that if you're still leveling your bear (it'll give you some tips on good reputation pieces and quest rewards), but otherwise I consider much of the information obsolete ("I never look back, darling; it distracts from the now." -- Edna Mode).
- I am a huge cheapskate. I've pointed out alternatives to the more expensive choices where possible. The only exception to this is the weapon slot, which is problematic if you don't or can't raid. If you're going to drop money anywhere, make it here and/or the boot and chest slots.
- For anyone without a very good Emblem of Frost income who wants to prioritize the order in which they get their pieces, I would buy the cloak first (you won't replace it until well into Cataclysm), then the idol, and then the gloves, legs, helm and shoulders. If you're running Vault of Archavon every week, you may want to buy the head and shoulders first, as Toravon has a chance to drop the gloves and legs.
As with just about any tier of content you could name, non-set pieces may be better than their tier-set counterparts on an individual basis. A lot of the attraction of a tier piece lies in how good the corresponding set bonuses are. Tier 10 bonuses for bears are very, very good
; the four-piece is essentially an additional Barkskin
every minute, and the two-piece is a meaty damage boost to both single-target and AoE threat. I highly recommend getting the four-piece when you can and using an Ikfirus's Sack of Wonder
for the chest.
By contrast, tier 9 is take-it-or-leave-it territory, especially if you only have access to the ilevel 232 version. The four-piece bonus to Barkskin is nice if you find yourself tanking for any PUG raids at all, but that's really about it. Don't bother gearing around retaining it.
No matter what you do, if you have any combination of the following, you should consider yourself well geared.Helm
To be frank, there aren't a lot of outstanding options in this slot outside of raids. Fortunately, every option allows you to socket a meta gem, and the top six options are relatively close to each other.Enchant
: Arcanum of the Stalwart Protector
(requires Argent Crusade revered)Meta Gem
: Austere Earthsiege DiamondNeck
I was surprised to discover just how empty this slot still is; all of the really worthwhile stuff comes from raid. Actually, for the top pick, that's still kinda true.Shoulders
Assuming you can get an Ikfirus' Sack of Wonder (see below), you'll want to buy the tier shoulders eventually in the interests of rocking four-piece tier 10. However, until that point, the Titan-Forged shoulders are an excellent choice.Enchant
: You have a few different options here. The classic tanking choice would be Greater Inscription of the Pinnacle
from Sons of Hodir exalted (or, if you're a scribe, Master's Inscription of the Pinnacle
), but if you prefer more health, you can use Greater Inscription of the Gladiator
(available for 10,000 honor).
If you want to go for a more offensively-oriented enchant, use Greater Inscription of the Axe
from Sons of Hodir exalted (or Master's Inscription of the Axe