Latest in Alex

Image credit:

Spring Design vs. Barnes & Noble: all the nooks and crannies

Nilay Patel
11.03.09
Share
Tweet
Share
Save

Sponsored Links

So we followed up with Spring Design to figure out what exactly its relationship with Barnes & Noble had been during the development of the Nook and why the company was suing, and, well, it's looking like B&N played some dirty pool here. You're looking at the actual NDA signed by Barnes & Noble and Spring Design, wherein each party agreed to keep their secrets... secret. After signing the agreement, Spring Design showed the Alex dual-screen ebook reader and associated marketing materials to B&N execs all the way up B&N CFO Kevin Frain and B&N.com president William Lynch, who said he was "looking forward" to a partnership. Soon after that, Spring implies that all contact stopped until Barnes & Noble announced the Nook. Lawsuit time!

Here's where it gets tricky, though -- the NDA contains pretty standard language specifically allowing both B&N and Spring Design to walk away from each other and develop competing products, so long as they don't use any of the confidential information they learned under NDA. Without knowing exactly what Spring Design showed to B&N and how much of that influenced or is included in the Nook (which Barnes & Noble currently won't let anyone touch), we can't say much about how this one's going to play out, but for right now we're looking at a huge corporation bringing out an Android-based ebook reader with dual electronic paper and touchscreen LCD displays just months after being shown the same concept by a three-year-old startup, and that's not exactly a warm and fuzzy bedtime story. We'll see what happens next -- Barnes & Noble, you have anything to say?

Gallery: Spring Design vs. Barnes & Noble complaint | 10 Photos


Gallery: Spring Design vs. Barnes & Noble NDA and exhibits | 46 Photos

All products recommended by Engadget are selected by our editorial team, independent of our parent company. Some of our stories include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Share
Tweet
Share
Save

Popular on Engadget

Study says climate change is starving the oceans of oxygen

Study says climate change is starving the oceans of oxygen

View
Tesla's electric ATV should launch at the same time as the Cybertruck

Tesla's electric ATV should launch at the same time as the Cybertruck

View
Jeff Bezos: US is in 'big trouble' if Big Tech rejects military contracts

Jeff Bezos: US is in 'big trouble' if Big Tech rejects military contracts

View
The best USB phone charger

The best USB phone charger

View
Hackers targeted BMW, Hyundai in hunt for trade secrets

Hackers targeted BMW, Hyundai in hunt for trade secrets

View

From around the web

Page 1Page 1ear iconeye iconFill 23text filevr