90
Engadget
Score
90

The best in its category. We highly recommend it.

How we score

The Engadget Score is a unique ranking of products based on extensive independent research and analysis by our expert editorial and research teams. The Global Score is arrived at only after curating hundreds, sometimes thousands of weighted data points (such as critic and user reviews).

Image credit: James Trew / Engadget

Latest in Gear

    Image credit: James Trew / Engadget

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review: Minor redesign, major pay-off

    The latest camera feels more complete despite some missing features.
    5 Shares
    Share
    Tweet
    Share
    Save

    Sponsored Links

    Typically, each year's flagship GoPro touts a marquee feature. In the past, that's included 4K/30fps video (Hero 4), built-in waterproofing (Hero 5) and really good stabilization (Hero 7). The new Hero 8 Black ($399) does not have a single showstopping feature. Instead, it brings several updates, each of which is good on its own, but together, I think they add up to the sort of big step forward that fans of the brand have been waiting for. There's actually quite a lot to get through, so we'll dive right into what's new.

    Engadget Score
    Poor
    Uninspiring
    Good
    Excellent
    Key

    Pros
    • Practical new design
    • Improved stability
    • Easy to use while maintaining pro features
    Cons
    • New design renders some accessories obsolete
    • No onboard HDMI port
    • Battery life remains “acceptable”
    • Front-facing display only available with aftermarket accessory

    Summary

    GoPro made something of a comeback with the Hero 7 Black, and the Hero 8 builds on that success. While the core camera remains the same, the whole user experience feels much more refined. Some users will be bummed their filters are no longer compatible, and we’d always appreciate better battery life. Most importantly, the Hero 8 increases the odds of your footage being worth sharing, and that’s what it’s all about.

    Be the first to review the Hero8 Black?
    Your ratings help us make the buyer’s guide better for everyone.
    Write a review

    First of all, the camera itself is physically different from last year's version. Most notably, the Hero 8 now has the mounting fingers built in (meaning, the "pins" that slide into the top of a pole). This means you'll no longer need a "frame" mount to connect it to accessories. This also means easy access to the battery and memory card at all times. Another perk is that this reduces the total footprint of the camera when mounted.

    Another hardware change is that the lens cover is no longer removable. This will be a drawback for those who use things like neutral density or color filters, but a GoPro spokesperson tells me there's a solution for that in the works. The upside is the glass is reportedly twice as strong, so it's less likely you'll need a replacement. We can be sure someone, somewhere is going to test that claim to the limit. There's also no longer an HDMI port, you'll need to buy an accessory for that (mentioned later).

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    HyperSmooth, last year's flagship feature, is back and improved. HyperSmooth 2.0 (as GoPro is calling it) promises even better stabilization and now works across all resolutions and frame rates. This is great news, as you'll no longer have to decide between the type of shot you want or stabilization (including slo-mo). There's also a "Boost" mode that offers even more stable shots than the (now improved) default setting -- the trade-off being a little extra image cropping. More on this later.

    TimeWarp (GoPro's "hyperlapse" feature) has also been refreshed. This time there's an auto mode that promises to take the guesswork out of which speed your video-lapses are recorded. With the Hero 7, you had to set a speed (2X, 5X, etc.) and see what you got. Now, GoPro claims the camera will use the sensors to detect motion and adjust that speed for you. There's also a "real-time" button on-screen, so you can jump out of TimeWarp into regular video. It's a neat effect, akin to adding a slo-mo section to a regular video.

    Two new features -- Digital Lenses and Capture Presets -- make their debut on the Hero 8. Both are really shortcuts to existing things, but like everything else on this camera, they do a good job making things easier to use and understand. In short, Digital Lenses is a new home for all the different fields of view settings (SuperView, Wide, Linear and -- new for the Hero 8 -- Narrow) while Capture Presets are exactly what they sound like: preset settings for popular use cases. (You can also define and save your own.)

    For still-image fans, there's a new LiveBurst photo mode, which is a lot like Apple's Live Photo feature. In this mode, the camera snaps images 1.5 seconds before and after you press the shutter button, increasing your chances of getting a great shot, which you can also share as a short gif-like clip. SuperPhoto (GoPro's HDR mode) also touts improved photo quality in varying light conditions.

    If you're lamenting the lack of hardware upgrades, the Hero 8 still has something for you. Alongside the new camera, GoPro is announcing a line of "mod" accessories, similar to Motorola's Moto Mods. At time of writing, these include a Media mod (a frame with shotgun mic built in, HDMI connectivity, 3.5mm audio in and two cold shoes); a light mod (200 lumens, tuned for video); and a Display mod that adds a fold-out screen so you can frame yourself while looking at the camera. (As a bonus, it has its own battery built-in.) Mods will cost between $49 and $79 each.

    Individually, these new features range from nice-to-haves to solid upgrades, but -- as I alluded to earlier -- after using the Hero 8 for a few weeks, they really come together to make the camera feel more distinctive than its subtle redesign would suggest.

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    Out of the frame

    Back when the Hero 5 came out, the big news was that you no longer needed the waterproof housing (which most people used all the time as it also protected the lens). This made the camera much smaller and more lightweight. With the Hero 8, someone had the bright idea of building the "fingers" that you use to mount the GoPro into accessories right into the camera itself. Turn the Hero 8 upside down and there they are, lying flat and waiting for you to flip them out.

    The fingers stow away magnetically, so they don't randomly pop out. And yes, they are replaceable, should you somehow manage to break them off. They feel pretty sturdy, but I'm sure someone will break them off eventually, given the abuse these cameras are often subjected to.

    This design change merely seems "clever" at first. Like a folding desk that becomes a cooker in a camper van. But after using the Hero 8 for barely half a day, the older cameras and their reliance on additional housings seem like a massive downgrade once you've become used to the convenience of direct access to battery and memory card.

    One small thing I noticed is that sometimes the camera doesn't sit perfectly horizontal when you connect it to a pole or mount. It's easy enough to fix -- manually set it level again and tighten the screw a little more -- but it tripped me up a few times in the beginning. In short, add a mental note to check that right after you check your lens for drops of water or dirt before shooting. There is a new "horizon lock" mode in the app that will fix lopsided video, but it's always better to get the shot right the first time.

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    HyperSmooth 2.0

    I'll admit, I wasn't expecting too much from HyperSmooth when the Hero 7 was revealed. GoPro already added stabilization in the Hero 5, and then an "improved" version of it in the Hero 6, so when it was repackaged in the Hero 7 it was easy to assume it was another incremental upgrade. I was wrong: It was truly impressive and made almost everything shot with it much much better.

    With that in mind, I'm not kidding when I say that HyperSmooth 2.0 is a legitimate improvement. Not just in how it stabilizes (although that is definitely better), but also because it's now available in every frame rate or resolution, including slo-mo modes. On the Hero 7, HyperSmooth was available for most modes, but once you got into higher frame rates or almost anything in 4:3 (an important setting for action cameras) you were out of luck. Now, you don't need to remember which settings it'll work with; all you have to do is decide whether you want HyperSmooth on or off.

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    Okay, there's one more decision: how much stabilization you want. On the Hero 7, HyperSmooth was either "auto" or "off." Now, you can choose between off, on (HyperSmooth 1.0), High (HyperSmooth 2.0) and Boost (which crops a little more of the image).

    If you're thinking that the difference between HyperSmooth's on and High settings means a difference in cropping, this isn't the case. Both will trim the image about 10 percent, with Boost swallowing a bit more of your view (though GoPro doesn't specify quite how much).

    In use, HyperSmooth 2.0 feels more fluid than what the Hero 7 is capable of. I actually liked that the original HyperSmooth wasn't too strong, as I think action sports can look a little weird when they're over-stabilized. Fortunately, whatever GoPro did to improve HyperSmooth this time around, it doesn't feel unnatural.

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    DJI's Osmo Action surprised many with how good its stabilization was right off the bat. This was probably one of the bigger deciding factors for people unsure about which camera to buy. All I can say is that GoPro has neutralized that decision here in the Hero 8. When testing DJI's camera side by side with the Hero 8, you can see the Osmo Action struggles with movements on more than one axis at the same time; even simple things like moving the camera from one hand to another. The combination of sideways motion and the impact of your hand creates a noticeable "twitch," which the Hero 8 absorbs more effectively.

    Boost mode, on the other hand, needs to be used judiciously, I feel. I tested it while hiking, for example, and the lack of lateral movement almost makes your video feel like it's running in slo-mo. It's useful for situations where there's a lot of high-impact, sudden movement. Or, conversely, minimal movement (like blogging or talking to camera), but for certain activities, it might make the action feel muted. There's also that crop I mentioned earlier to consider -- if you need the wide field of view, which action sports generally do, you're losing some here. Either way, it's nice to have the option.

    Resolution changes

    I'm not sure why you might want to shoot in 720p, but if you do, then know that that's no longer an option in the Hero 8. In fact, 960p is also missing too. This makes the lowest resolution on offer is now 1080p. On the flip side, this also means that LiveStreaming is now higher quality at FHD, since it was 720p beforehand.

    Linear mode, the setting that removes any lens warp in real time, is now available in 4K. (It only worked up to 2.7K previously.) You can also combine Linear mode with HyperSmooth for stable, unwarped video at the highest resolution -- a sort of "greedy boy" mode, but it likely will crush the battery life. There's also a new Narrow mode, which GoPro says is akin to the field of view you might be used to recording with on your phone.

    More importantly, for those seeking higher quality, is the maximum bitrate, which is now 100Mbps at 4K, up from 78Mbps in the Hero 7.

    Horizon Lock

    This isn't technically a feature on the camera, as it's in the app, but it so far only works with footage shot on the Hero 8. It's often difficult to keep the camera perfectly level, especially if it's extended on a pole. Your lopsided footage can now be easily (and automatically) fixed in the app. GoPro's app already had a basic leveling tool, but it couldn't help with varying levels of lopsidedness over time.

    Now, simply import your clip, and let the app dynamically level the clip (using the GoPro's motion-sensor data).

    TimeWarp 2.0

    GoPro's version of hyperlapse grows up a little in the Hero 8. When introduced last year, it was a welcome addition to the tool bag: something between a regular time-lapse and a smooth video, and perfect for condensing longer moments into something more dynamic. But it could be hit or miss. Did you want the 2X setting? The 5X? Or the... you get it. In short, doing math before you walk up a mountain kinda takes you out of the moment. Now, just set it and forget it -- let the camera do the work.

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    In practice, it makes those speedy-fast-forward clips feel a lot more natural. Now, if you stop mid-hike at a nice viewpoint, the TimeWarp will slow down too, giving that moment more prominence. You can even force it, with the aforementioned button. Tap it, and the camera drops back into regular video until you tap it again -- perfect for catching that high five, mid-skate. The effect is extra cool, as the video ramps down to real time, making it feel like a slo-mo section, before ramping up to fast-forward mode again.

    The only real problem is the size of the on-screen button. GoPro increased the size during my testing. (It was initially teeny tiny; now it's wider, but it could still be taller.) And if your GoPro's display has gone to sleep, you'll need to tap it once to wake it, then peck the button (and then peck it again to switch it off). If something cool happens spontaneously, and you want to catch it in real time, you're probably going to miss it.

    Even when I was setting up a shot where I knew I would activate the real-time mode, I still found myself missing a beat and pressing the button too late, especially when the screen was off (which it's going to be most of the time). It's still a cool feature, but the experience could use some fine-tuning.

    Perhaps GoPro could repurpose the physical HiLight button (aka the settings/mode button) for this purpose? My guess is that many people would prefer the physical control for a creative tool, rather than for adding a HiLight tag (as you can always review your footage and find that moment you wanted to tag after the fact).

    Digital Lenses and Capture Presets

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    While Digital Lenses and Capture Presets don't technically introduce anything new, they represent one of the key highlights of the Hero 8: usability. GoPro has dramatically improved the UI for its cameras over the years, most notably since a touchscreen came as standard (and you no longer needed to rely on the tiny front LCD).

    With the Hero 8, the UI has changed again. You'll still swipe left and right to swap modes. Likewise, swiping up from the bottom or down from the top gives you access to the same screens as before (gallery and settings, respectively). What's new is the addition of shortcuts to preset settings. For example, hop into video mode and you'll find Standard, Activity, Slo-Mo and Cinematic presets, along with the option to add your own. The idea is to present you with optimized settings depending on what you want to do (and remove the guesswork).

    It's a simple idea, but one that makes you feel more confident you're in the right mode in a given situation. When I was heading out to ride an electric skateboard, for example, I would tap Activity. Later on a hike, I chose Standard as I was shooting mostly scenic or static shots. Beforehand I would often just leave the camera on 1080p/60 as my go-to. That worked fine, but having the taller shot of Activity while riding definitely makes it feel more engaging. The thing is, I knew this before but would either forget or think 1080 was fine and just stick with that.

    Digital Lenses is a little more straightforward: It moves the FOV setting (Wide, SuperView etc.) into a slider. Simply drag that up or down and you'll see what the "Lens" will capture in real time. That's much more helpful than dipping into a menu, changing a setting, then going back out to check your shot.

    Taken with GoPro Hero 8 Black

    Another nice addition to the UI is the option to add shortcuts to the home screen. If you frequently switch between slo-mo and regular speed, you could add one for that. Or maybe you want quick access to HyperSmooth's Boost mode. With the Hero 8, you can configure these shortcuts in the settings.

    Then there's LiveBurst, GoPro's twist on Google's Motion Photo, or Apple's Live Photo. Simply put, it starts taking photos and once you press the shutter it captures 1.5 seconds worth of images before and after you clicked. In this context "1.5 seconds" refers to the three-second video clip you'll be presented with (made up of 90 photos). You can view them as a clip or scrub through them to find the best photo, either in the app or on the camera.

    It's a good way to make sure you bag the shot, and something that makes sense for a GoPro, given its focus on activity. All I know is that I went whale watching once, and ended up with several photos of Humpbacks barely out of the water. It's features like this that would have probably earned me that epic "whale-splash" shot.

    If you were hoping for some more practical updates, like improved battery life, then there's not really any news here. While the Hero 8 has an updated battery, it's still 1,220mAh as before. (The difference is that it offers a higher max output, which is needed for some of the new features.) The end result is still the same old "hour or so" of active use. If you're only shooting moments here or there, that's typically going to see you through a few hours of turning it on, off, tapping around and, of course, shooting.

    The competition (especially DJI)

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    Typically, this is the part where I would say something like "GoPro's only real competition is itself." Of course, there's the Sony Action Cam line, which has some dedicated followers but isn't quite as versatile as a GoPro, thanks to fewer mounts and the slim-but-tall form factor. There's now a new rival from DJI. I already thought the Hero 7 was a better overall camera than the Osmo Action, despite strong competition on the stabilization front (and that second, forward-facing "selfie" screen). The Hero 8 just makes that decision a little clearer.

    GoPro's new HyperSmooth feature eliminates pretty much any doubt about the stabilization, and the new Boost mode might help future-proof GoPro's position here. If you really appreciate the front-facing "selfie" screen on the DJI, the Hero 8 doesn't have anything to offer here (until the screen mod comes out, but that'll cost extra). For me, the GoPro offers a much more "complete" experience, and the Hero 8's additional usability really seals the deal.

    Wrap up

    GoPro Hero 8 Black review

    All in all, the Hero 8 feels like a small but important fork in the GoPro roadmap. Out are some of the older resolutions like 720p and 960p. Along with details that some users will cherish, like the HDMI port and removable lens. The latter presumably have been sacrificed for a slicker, streamlined design (sound familiar?).

    In return, we have what I think is the most comprehensive GoPro experience yet. All of the updates in the Hero 8 add value and work together in a logical way. The user experience has matured to a place where it is welcoming to new users but doesn't hide the power settings. The result is a camera that puts creativity first -- and that's ultimately what you're spending $399 for. The advent of mods to expand the hardware (albeit with an additional cost) should also mean you get more use out of the Hero 8 over time.

    All products recommended by Engadget are selected by our editorial team, independent of our parent company. Some of our stories include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
    Comment
    Comments
    Share
    5 Shares
    Share
    Tweet
    Share
    Save

    Popular on Engadget

    The 2019 Engadget Holiday Gift Guide

    The 2019 Engadget Holiday Gift Guide

    View
    Amazon expands free music streaming to Android, iOS and Fire TV

    Amazon expands free music streaming to Android, iOS and Fire TV

    View
    Senate bill would block US companies from storing data in China

    Senate bill would block US companies from storing data in China

    View
    Sony patent may show a familiar-looking controller for the PS5

    Sony patent may show a familiar-looking controller for the PS5

    View
    MIT researchers teach autonomous cars how to deal with selfish drivers

    MIT researchers teach autonomous cars how to deal with selfish drivers

    View

    From around the web

    Page 1Page 1ear iconeye iconFill 23text filevr